Is Adam Schefter right?

I would like to think it is rock bottom, but it will likely get worse.

Was pretty damn bad. But then again we're not motivated in 2011 without it.

Trey Junkin comes to mind.

This loss was awful for a lot of reasons, but it was an 0-4 team going nowhere.

2010 Eagles game, among others.

is usually wrong about everything.

Can’t remember a worse day. Perhaps taking it up the ass in SB 35?

There have been many worse than this.

kick in the nuts while we were already down.

Like someone else said, it feels like the end of the Eli era.

In comment 13636583 David B. said:

Quote:

Trey Junkin comes to mind. This loss was awful for a lot of reasons, but it was an 0-4 team going nowhere.

Junkin was playoffs, not regular season.

Still.. we've seen worse than this. 2010 against the Eagles was worse than this

Quite frankly, if we were 3-1 or 4-0, today would have been much more devastating.

but with all the injuries, especially Beckham, it's one of the more discouraging.

.

but I WATCHED the fumble.. It was one of the most horrible experiences of all time. My Dad still cant stand Herman Edwards to THIS DAY..

.

with little hope for anything. And the only really crushing thing today was the OBJ injury and we won't know until next year whether that's a career-killer or not.

In comment 13636583 David B. said:

Quote:

Trey Junkin comes to mind. This loss was awful for a lot of reasons, but it was an 0-4 team going nowhere.

i still lose sleep over the Trey Junkin loss. that one really bothers me.

In comment 13636611 blueblood said:

Quote:

but I WATCHED the fumble.. It was one of the most horrible experiences of all time. My Dad still cant stand Herman Edwards to THIS DAY..

the fumble was the only play I saw in that game!

Game was meaningless.

That was bad.

It’s rock bottom today but there’s a light at the end of the tunnel because with OBJ out, we are definitely picking top 3, maybe first overall.

It exposed everything about how this team was poorly constructed and that he does not get the most out of his
players . it's a sad day 6 years of Eli's career down the
fucking shitter that's what irks me the most .
Eli deserves better we should have got two more Lombardi's
with him IMO .

pretty close

that Giants team could have won the Super Bowl because the season was wide open. This loss put the nail in the coffin of a season that had slipped away.

is that the Giants were a pretty bad team before the injuries -- losing Odell is just icing on the whole cake of bad

the Pisarcik fumble game is probably the most important game in the history of the team. Anyone who would have traded a loss for a win that day either isn't a Giants fan, or doesn't know what they're talking about.

To the worst day. Just take your pick of Eagles losses:

Pisarchik fumble
Dodge kicking to Jackson
Plax shoots himself, Giants lose in 2009 Playoffs

The 2017 Giants will be lucky to win a game.

In comment 13636670 Matt in SGS said:

Quote:

that Giants team could have won the Super Bowl because the season was wide open. This loss put the nail in the coffin of a season that had slipped away.

+1 Al Toon. For everything Matt said. 2010 Eagles game probably #2.

In comment 13636691 RobCarpenter said:

Quote:

To the worst day. Just take your pick of Eagles losses: Pisarchik fumble Dodge kicking to Jackson Plax shoots himself, Giants lose in 2009 Playoffs The 2017 Giants will be lucky to win a game.

Sorry, he said regular season..

it absolutely is.

My top concern right now is that a poor offensive showing the rest of the way might convince ownership or Reese that it's time to move on from Eli.

This is bad in a different way. In those years it was almost always pretty apparent that the team wasn't good. The D was often very good, but offense just didn't have players.

This team has players, it had legitimate reason to think it could compete at a high level. And it's not just the O-line that sunk them. The D has been crummy, too.

Today might be the most disappointing day. Can't say if it's the worst.

Yes.
But the JP fumble was the worst,Trey Junkin a distant 2nd, 2010 Philly 3rd.
But we are rapidly closing in on those teams in the mid 60's that featured Olympic track starts Henry Carr and Clarence Childs as our DBs.

was pretty bad

His job is over i n January

...

In comment 13636750 spike said:

Quote:

His job is over i n January

I wouldn't count on it.

.

.

was pretty bad too

Why do people keep referencing the SF game?

The tweet is about regular season losses.

"Regular season game" means what many of you think it does

In comment 13636836 BigBlueShock said:

Quote:

"Regular season game" means what many of you think it does

Inconceivable!!

is slipping away. I went out to lunch with my wife during the game, something in past years that would have been unthinkable. I just can't muster any enthusiasm for watching a poorly coached, undisciplined, stupid collection of inept football players fucking up in every way you
can imagine. The product stinks. It makes you realize what smoke and mirrors accounted for last season.

But I wonder how much of that has to do with getting older and having other things on my mind. It'd be nice to have football Sundays be a fun diversion, but they're not.

In comment 13636836 BigBlueShock said:

Quote:

"Regular season game" means what many of you think it does

LOL, good catch, I missed the regular season part of it as well.

now Im just bummed. The injuries...

Will this loss have the same effect?

Going into the bye week

When LT ruptured his Achilles. The crowd was dead silent for the rest of the game-shellshocked.Will never forget how quiet the stadium became.

Maybe all 4 for the season.

This is right there with the Eagles D Jackson collapse. This season is now screwed. However I don't think its as catastrophic as The Fumble.