Yes/No is Brandon Marshall back next season?

That s true, but

I like Marshall hope he stays

with a pay cut.

He was not as advertised at all. Over the hill looking for $$$. MO

Filled and not a large cap hit.

question is what FA WR's are available that are younger and have the ability to produce as a #2 to OBJ more than Marshall at around the same price? Might have to take another chance on him if there isn't a better option out there. OBJ and Engram should be big enough threats to open up opportunities for Shepard and another WR.

After given huge opportunities to showcase themselves all of the back-up WRs performed poorly, I wouldn't bring back any of them except maybe Rudolph just to see if he develops a little more in camp.

He's seems done

but I'd give him a shot if he is willing to take a pay cut.

$5 mill and use it elsewhere.

if he shows nothing in pre-season dump him but I think you
can't judge him with MacHandley at the helm shit the
entire offense needed more reps in pre-season instead we
had the epic battle for the backup spot what a total waste
of pre-season .Offense was in a coma to open the season
glad that disaster has passed . Marshal barely got a touch
the he got hurt .

This team needs to get younger, healthier, and faster.

Enjoy retirement Brandon, you've had a great career!

He showed little interest in catching the ball.Basically, he sucked.Even before he was injured.

.

Guy sucked when he was healthy! Pass !

No how.

No way.

We are trying to fix this locker room. Marshall is gone. 4mm cap relief.

No way.

We are trying to fix this locker room. Marshall is gone. 4mm cap relief.

Marshall arguably lost them at least 1 if not 2 games.

He has to go.

$5m or Marshall. Gone. Done.

he looked horrible before going down.

Gettleman watches the film he will be a goner.

*

Was he ever here?

.

That big fork sticking out of his back is a problem though.

way

In comment 13775880 SomeFan said:

Quote:

way

+1

but not lately, I would think we would pass on him.....

I don't Gettlemen will saddle this team with older veterans like Marshall whose best years are behind them...

In comment 13776002 Jersey55 said:

Quote:

I don't Gettlemen will saddle this team with older veterans like Marshall whose best years are behind them...

Gettleman brought in a lot of vets in Carolina. He signed Mike Adams, Julius Peppers, and re-signed Charles Johnson. I can see Marshall back with a pay cut.

Think his time is coming to an end.

If SB is the pick, and Eli is the QB, he is physically a nice complement to what we have.

Spread them out - toss sweep (too advanced for Giants Mickey Mouse, I know) Ellison blocking from traditional TE, Engram blocking from H-back in the slot, Marshall blocking from WR.

If the o-line can slow the opposition down for a step, we would have tremendous size/leverage advantages.

And any pass play where he is singled, long or short, is a potential score because he can overpower CBs and his probably decreasing speed does not really matter.

If Eli is not the QB, I would not keep him, however.