I know there have been threads recently saying how terrible the show is. I didn't post on them because I hadn't had much chance to listen and form an opinion (I'm not posting on them now because I think the threads are dead).
I've now listened a little on a couple different days and I'm not saying the show is great, but I and will say they've talked more about the GIANTS in a couple days than Francessa would in a couple weeks (especially considering their season is over). I'll give 'em a chance.
Anyone else agree?
The show is God awful.
If you listened to Francessa for years, you know that he would not agree that the Giants are the only story and he would not be talking about them nearly as much. He would be talking ad nauseum about baseball, lack of free agency signings, Yankees pitching staff, etc.
I eventually tuned into Mike's show occasionally years later, but don't miss so much Yankee talk.
And then Gregg Giannotti does an impersonation of Chris Carlin.
It's so transparent. WFAN has to know this thing is a trainwreck.
If they are going to make it as a trio, it will take some time.
Big shoes to fill. So big they needed three people.
BART Scott is funny but does not add as much as you would expect from an ex player. The other day he was going on about how Brady was the greatest winner but not the greatest QB. He beat the point to death.
I found Francesca tedious. His rants were amusing but he was often so obviously unprepared and his belittling Of callers was tedious. He was a legend but it was time for some new voices
And....channel changed.
Which, after 30 years of Mike (with and without the Mad Dog), is a step down for WFAN. Very hard to find that must-listen person or team. And Francessa wasn't that when he started, he was just another guy. They'll have to figure out who they think the guy is, then be patient.
Bart Scott the worst combo of arrogance and ignorance.
Gray asks a question then gives her answer to it before finishing her sentence.
The worst sports show ive ever heard.
Gio is legitimately a better version of carton or what carton wished he could be. He’s funny and knows when to cut the shtick. Plus his impersonations are amazingly good
I personally think Giannotti is a great addition, and he has made the morning show exponentially better, even better than when the show was at its highest popularity with Carton and Boomer.
As I said the other day, the afternoon show needs time. I've always liked Carlin, but Maggie Gray is a poor man's Kim Jones and Bart Scott just doesn't really fit in. I can't wait to hear him talk baseball this spring! Hahahahahahaaa
Roberts OWNS that show. He dominates the conversation while Benigno just chimes in 'Yeah, bro. Agreed.'
Benigno is funny when it comes to his Jets rants, but he's pretty blah otherwise.
Morning Show is very good.
Can't believe they still do that. Updates were a huge deal when the station started because sports news was hard to come by. In particular getting timely scores was huge. Now everyone can get updates any time they want with their phone so what's the point?
Fun fact - in the first year or so WFAN had updates every 15 minutes. It was ridiculous. Between commercials and updates the hosts couldn't get any flow going. There was a near mutiny I think and mgmt relented and the 20/20 was born. It was great and played a big role in the station's success but it's a relic now.
Huh?
Not to go "there", but I'm pretty sure Carlin would be fired for saying something like that.
2) How are the ratings and reviews?
It was my understanding that they don't do the 20/20 updates anymore as of Jan. 1 - just top of the hour? With stupid CBS Sports minutes sprinkled in?
He has no idea what he's talking about. He just blurts shit out without doing any research. He is just terrible. And he really has an issue with Odell. And i'm sick of him talking about Odell and money. Did Bart Scott play for the Jets for free? I gave this show a shot, but i cant anymore. i'm done
I think you missed his point on Eli, it wasn't that Eli is bad it was having to deal with an aging superstar QB on the way down ala Montana, e.g.
2) How are the ratings and reviews?
They talk hockey 32.6% of the time. Bart is a big fan and surprisingly knowledgeable. You should definitely check it out.
You need people with New York sports knowledge pumping through their veins.
2) How are the ratings and reviews?
You're a monster.
Quote:
is the ring leader. His latest gem was the Giants are one of the least desirable places for a HC candidate to go and his first reason why was Eli Manning. There's so much wrong with that statement...not worth it. Surprise...a former Jet with nothing good to say about the Giants.
I think you missed his point on Eli, it wasn't that Eli is bad it was having to deal with an aging superstar QB on the way down ala Montana, e.g.
I know exactly what he was saying. You're right. It's still a terrible point and not accurate at all.