Jeremiah suggests Giants trade back 2x in 1st round

In very close order, Darnold, Barkley, Nelson. If Cleveland takes someone not named Darnold, Barkley or Nelson number one overall then and only then would I listen to a offer from Cleveland to go from 2 to 4. I need all three of their second rounders to make it happen (4, 33, 35 & 60?)

I'd LOVE to see two trade downs, BUT, I don't want to see the Giants drop lower than about slot 12 or so. The scenarios where the Giants drop down to Buffalo's 21 and 22 slot just don't work out for the Giants. The value on players drops off at about 15 or so. Optimally, I'd like to see them pick up a first rounder in next year's draft and have them draft a qb then. All the QB's in this draft have good potential but they all have at least one big potentially busting flaw too. There are no sure things this year. Eli has another year or two in him and I'd rather them draft a qb next year. Also getting another 2nd or 3rd rounder in this years draft would go a long, long way to rebuilding the O-Line and LB corp.

I'd rather drop back to 4 and pick up a few second rounders and whatever else.I'd like to have another 2 in this draft.

In comment 13855631 Jay on the Island said:

Quote:

if the Giants already had a young franchise QB on the roster. Unless someone hands DG a crystal ball that shows that Webb is that guy it is too risky to pass on a QB at 2.

looks like the Giants front office really screwed Gettleman by not playing Webb last season, because its almost draft time and nobody knows what this kid can do in real time football as a pro, so Gettlemen is going to have to shoot blind in this draft..

In comment 13856029 GFAN52 said:

Quote:

In comment 13856022 arcarsenal said: Quote: Vegas odds on a Wonderlic score? That's how we're judging Lamar Jackson's intelligence? Good lord. BTW, since you brought up Watson, you may want to know that he posted the lowest Wonderlic score of ANY QB in last year's draft. Do you think any GM would penalize him for that now based on what he did when he played? I don't. He was fantastic and can clearly handle the pro game. Good point.

does anybody know how Lawrence Taylor did with the wonderlic test, I would imagine he did not do too well and if thats true then the whole wonderlic business is just plain crapola....

In comment 13857526 Jersey55 said:

Quote:

In comment 13856029 GFAN52 said: Quote: In comment 13856022 arcarsenal said: Quote: Vegas odds on a Wonderlic score? That's how we're judging Lamar Jackson's intelligence? Good lord. BTW, since you brought up Watson, you may want to know that he posted the lowest Wonderlic score of ANY QB in last year's draft. Do you think any GM would penalize him for that now based on what he did when he played? I don't. He was fantastic and can clearly handle the pro game. Good point. does anybody know how Lawrence Taylor did with the wonderlic test, I would imagine he did not do too well and if thats true then the whole wonderlic business is just plain crapola....

It's certainly a crap shoot. Marino scored a 16. Jim Kelly scored a 15. Rodgers scored a 16. Eli scored a 39. So there really isn't a correlation between what you score and your success in the NFL...