I'm actually starting to believe he is aggressively bad at his job. He's a professed Giants fan and has always been tough on the team, which I've felt has been over-compensation: He killed us for the 2016 signings of Jenkins, Snacks, and Vernon. And to be clear, he didn't kill us for being in the position to need to do that--which is a fair criticism--but for the signings themselves.
Per below, I feel like he's unnecessarily critical of everything NFL teams do. In short, I do not respect his analysis at all. I had stopped reading him but clicked on the below article to give him another chance. I think his analysis is bad. The Giants deserve better than a "C" for trading inconsequential picks for a good LB when they're moving from a 4-3 to a 3-4. The Browns deserve more than a B- for trading for Tyrod Taylor, whom Barnwell has defended extensively on Twitter.
I think I'm at the point of just ignoring this guy altogether. What say you BBI? Am I being too tough? Link
- ( New Window