Patricia Traina
& #8207;
Verified account
@Patricia_Traina
Giants have waived CB BRandon Dixon, OT Adam Bisnowaty, LB Derrick Matthews, CJ Goodwin, TE Stephen Baggett and CB Bryon Fields.
Patricia Traina
& #8207;
Verified account
@Patricia_Traina
They've signed G Chris Scott, CB Chris Lewis-Harris (as previously reported), G Malcolm Bunche, WR Alonzo Russell, DT Mike Jones and former Rutgers RB Robert Martin.
I'm more surprised by Dixon. I thought he had enough good moments last year to at least come to camp.
Yes, I do, and yes, it sure is.
DAVE TE-COMPLETE ADAM BISNOWATY SCOUTING REPORT - ( New Window )
Quote:
got beat out by Malcolm Bunche. Remember the great report Bisno got from a scout here. Drafting is a crapshoot
Yes, I do, and yes, it sure is.
DAVE TE-COMPLETE ADAM BISNOWATY SCOUTING REPORT - ( New Window )
oof, big swing and a miss there.
Quote:
In comment 13963213 RAIN said:
Quote:
Must really not be that impressive.
IMHO never had the quickness needed for the NFL.
+1.
Even I was that watching UPitt games.
The upside: at least Reese didn't pick him in the second or third, where we needed OL picked in at least 1 of those 2 rounds.
No but he did move up in the 6th round to draft him and blew a 7th rounder.
New York Giants Roster Moves Add Six Players, Cut Six Players - ( New Window )
It is very alarming that going into training camp, Reese's backup plan at RT was Bisnowaty.
under the old regime this guy would have been given longer....not any more....I think I like it
Think about this......since we drafted Eli, 14 years ago, we have only drafted 2 OLmen that we have re-signed.....Snee and Beatty, and Beatty just happened to be in the right place at the right time....
RB ROBERT MARTIN (5-11, 210):
Bench: 19. (10th)
Vertical jump: 32.
Broad jump: 9-6.
40: 4.66.
3-cone: 7.02. (8th)
20 shuttle: 4.07. (T-1st)
60 shuttle: 11.30. (2nd)
Article on Rutgers players - ( New Window )
Quote:
did Reese suck at drafting offensive lineman. I mean I know Bisno was a 6th round pick, but he couldnt make last years initial roster even though we had crap to choose from and he couldnt beat out a bunch of UDFAs this year. I still cant believe how much cash was laid out by Arizona and SF for Pugh and Richburg. They will regret those contracts soon enough.
It is very alarming that going into training camp, Reese's backup plan at RT was Bisnowaty.
Almost as alarming as his Plan A being Bobby Hart
under the old regime this guy would have been given longer....not any more....I think I like it
Jerry's kids!
Lets hope Dave doesn't start doing the same thing with his!
I guess not to those who count.
oh man I forgot that footnote. Good pick!
under the old regime this guy would have been given longer....not any more....I think I like it
Why? He was a sixth round draft pick. The expectation is that those players are projects.
Goes to show how difficult scouting really is, especially down in the 5th/6th/7th/UDFA scrum. So many variables to contend with.
I wouldn't be surprised if he ends up on and off the roster a few more times.
This is only a mild surprise. He didn't even make the 53 from last year. He was practice squad and then elevated to the 53 later on.
Exactly, it wasnt that he ignored the line, he just didnt know who to draft. And his free agent pickups left a lot to be desired as well (eg. Schwartz).
How would you characterize Reese's drafting considering this fact; In the 9 years between 2004 through 2012, a grand total of 2 premium picks in round 1 through 3 were spent on O-line players (Snee 2004, Beatty in 2011)? That's an 11% investment on the 5 O-line positions.
Maybe Reese didn't put a high value enough on Oline, maybe he and his scouts were just poor at scouting them.
To me, you have to be willing to make a larger investment on OL in the way of premium draft picks (rounds 1, 2, 3), or get unusually lucky via free agency, to build an effective O-line.
It's like he had terrible taste in olinemen, or looked for all the wrong things.
Meanwhile compare to Hernandez, DG's first olineman.
Quote:
There was a myth that Reese "ignored" the line. He threw a bunch of draft picks and bushels of free agent dollars at the line. He didn't ignore it; he tried very hard and failed. IMO, failure is worse.
It's like he had terrible taste in olinemen, or looked for all the wrong things.
Meanwhile compare to Hernandez, DG's first olineman.
Compare to what exactly, the guy hasn't played a single down yet and could be a complete bust, you don't know at this point so a comparison is pointless.
Quote:
In comment 13963589 81_Great_Dane said:
Quote:
There was a myth that Reese "ignored" the line. He threw a bunch of draft picks and bushels of free agent dollars at the line. He didn't ignore it; he tried very hard and failed. IMO, failure is worse.
It's like he had terrible taste in olinemen, or looked for all the wrong things.
Meanwhile compare to Hernandez, DG's first olineman.
Compare to what exactly, the guy hasn't played a single down yet and could be a complete bust, you don't know at this point so a comparison is pointless.
Other than Richburg, I never liked any of Reese's OL picks, often reaches, or overpaid FAs like Schwartz and Baas. I'm actually excited about Hernandez fwiw.
regulator : 5/14/2018 3:20 pm : link : reply
that was one of the more glowing scouting reports I have ever read... one would think we just drafted the next Tony Boselli!
I'll scream it from the rooftops, but sy clearly lays out the prospects strengths, weaknesses and current pro comp. Can cruise through an entire list of OL in a few short minutes.
About 15 minutes in to the other review, I was still on the part about Pittsburgh being a steel town and Bis excelling at chalk tossing in elementary school.
Think about this......since we drafted Eli, 14 years ago, we have only drafted 2 OLmen that we have re-signed.....Snee and Beatty, and Beatty just happened to be in the right place at the right time....
We drafted Eli?
What a heavy cost to pay. A whole 7th round pick. When you have the chance to hold on to a 7th round draft pick, you absolutely must do it.
WE FLY HIGH, NO LIE, YOU KNOW 'DIS - ( New Window )