Since 2003, when the Giants win the first meeting with the Eagles, they have made the playoffs every single time.
When they lose the first meeting with the Eagles, they have missed the playoffs every single time.
Here are the results below:
2003 L 14-10 No playoffs
2004 L-31-17 No playoffs
2005 W 27-17 Yes playoffs
2006 W 30-24 Yes playoffs
2007 W 16-3 Yes playoffs
2008 W 36-31 Yes playoffs
2009 L 40-17 No playoffs
2010 L 27-17 No playoffs
2011 W 29-16 Yes playoffs
2012 L 19-17 No playoffs
2013 L 36-21 No playoffs
2014 L 27-0 No playoffs
2015 L 27-7 No playoffs
2016 W 28-23 Yes playoffs
2017 L 27-24 No playoffs
Causation - maybe it's more on offer for them
Coincidence - once I met a blond who had fun
I say: run the darn ball.
I do think it might give us an idea of how well we match up against 1/3 of our opponents for the division. With that in mind, the stat is not as surprising as it appears at first glance.
Don't forget that losing to the Eagles might not just indicate that the team is not good enough for the playoffs - it might also indicate that the Eagles are a very good team that year (with the contrapositive also being true). Again, given that they represent one third of the competition for the division title, it's not as surprising as you might think that there is a correlation between these two things.
Causation - maybe it's more on offer for them
Coincidence - once I met a blond who had fun
I say: run the darn ball.
I've said the same but it is hard for them to stay with it when their line still struggles with simple combo blocks at times. They get man handled at times. They certainly need to at least keep opponents honest but this teams identity should always be around running the ball.