College football 10/20 and other QB prospect discussion

His throws were on target and he was moving well. I actually liked what I saw in the glimpses I caught.

In comment 14136854 chopperhatch said:

Quote:

In comment 14136849 AcesUp said: Quote: This game is a huge test for him and he's failing miserably. Literally none of the QBs have done shit so far today. Although Jones' receivers dropped a ton of balls.

Consider his surroundings. Football is a team sport, right?

gym. I see Clemson's up 24-0.

How has Finley looked?

An absolutely extraordinary player. A mix of Russell Wilson and Drew Brees. Perfect pocket presence, accurate, mobile, has a gun....if only he were coming out this year.

In comment 14136861 SFGFNCGiantsFan said:

Quote:

gym. I see Clemson's up 24-0. How has Finley looked?

He’s making Eli look like Rodgers.

This Bama team would pummel them worse then the last time they met. OSU would be closer but not much.

Clemson... maybe if they can get to TyLaw, otherwise.. nope.

Finley is trash. Another floating lollipop for an interception

In comment 14136856 mdc1 said:

Quote:

In comment 14136855 chopperhatch said: Quote: In comment 14136853 SFGFNCGiantsFan said: Quote: In comment 14136842 BigBlueCane said: Quote: and maybe Clemson. Don't forget the Irish! Agreed. Also, if we get a loss from Clemson or OSU, Michigan would be a tough matchup for Bama in my opinion. They run the ball very well and have a carnivorous defense. Plus Patterson hasmade some plays. Could be fun. lol, you cannot be serious.

Very serious. Did you watch the game?

In comment 14136868 BigBlueShock said:

Quote:

Finley is trash. Another floating lollipop for an interception

Finley is not the best QB on the field by a long shot. Clemon's backup Chase Brice is better.

Mark Richt is a very narcissistic head coach that is stuck with his 90's era offense and in doing so he's managed to piss off and alienate the fanbase. The banner planes are being funded now and will likely fly again this year, demanding changes be made.

He may end up being my QB2 behind Herbert

He gets flushed out of the pocket every freakin' play

Who the hell is this QB for Colorado? He looks good.

Better prospect than Findley, Grier or or Lock at this point.

In comment 14136874 markky said:

Quote:

In comment 14136868 BigBlueShock said: Quote: Finley is trash. Another floating lollipop for an interception Finley is not the best QB on the field by a long shot. Clemon's backup Chase Brice is better.

Brice is now in the game and has made some nice throws.

was not impressive. Lots of bad throws and into coverage.

Nationeide commercials are so brutal.

In comment 14136766 dep026 said:

Quote:

Pressure on 3rd THROW THE BALL ON FIRST FUCKING DOWN JUST ONE TIME!!! He can’t get fired soon enough.

You really want to fire him? Why? The defense gave up less than 100 yards. The run game got going in the fourth quarter, and Patterson had some nice runs. They dominated time of possession. Is it Harbaugh’s fault that Evans fumbled? They crushed Wisconsin. What exactly do you want Harbaugh to do?

The coach who deserves to be fired is Franklin. Up 33-21 today with 4 minutes left and Franklin has McSorley throw the ball three straight times. Now that’s a terrible coach.

In comment 14136894 chopperhatch said:

Quote:

Better prospect than Findley, Grier or or Lock at this point.

Yep. Waiting to see how Herbert does. If he struggles I might end up having to redo my QB board. Still looking through other guys as well (keeping an eye on UCF v ECU) May even see what the Minshew hype is about.

Get it done vs Ohio State.

Happen before. Wow. Horribly unprepared.

In comment 14136946 chopperhatch said:

Quote:

Happen before. Wow. Horribly unprepared.

Not how you rehearse it for sure.

What a run!!

In comment 14136949 GoDeep13 said:

Quote:

What a run!!

The tackling was atrocious on that play.

Up 7-0.

Maybe if Oregon gets down by enough the coach turns loose Herbert so that we can so when he needs to throw the ball for once.

But Herbert is not playing well right now. And Oregon simply looks overmatched right now.

Offense is trash. Run, Run, pass every possession. It’d be nice to see them throw it on 1st and 2nd down and let the qb get in a rhythm

In comment 14136985 GiantsRage2007 said:

Quote:

Offense is trash. Run, Run, pass every possession. It’d be nice to see them throw it on 1st and 2nd down and let the qb get in a rhythm

Agreed completely. It doesn't really matter, though, because the D can't stop anything right now. Herbert has missed throws today, too, but they only have 9 plays all half.

In comment 14136980 Giants34 said:

Quote:

But Herbert is not playing well right now. And Oregon simply looks overmatched right now.

Im definitely watching and I dont think he looks all that bad. The big sack was a result of his lone completely whiffing on an assignment. His two deep throws were right there but his receivers dont have that extra gear. But I think the playcalling is holding him back

In comment 14136991 Giants34 said:

Quote:

In comment 14136985 GiantsRage2007 said: Quote: Offense is trash. Run, Run, pass every possession. It’d be nice to see them throw it on 1st and 2nd down and let the qb get in a rhythm Agreed completely. It doesn't really matter, though, because the D can't stop anything right now. Herbert has missed throws today, too, but they only have 9 plays all half.

For sure. Their D is BAD!

down 20 and have to start passing. this will be interesting.

Purdue gets a TD just before the half and it’s 14-3.

runs 3 times for -4 yards. No pass attempts inside the 10. Geez.

21-6 Purdue now.

just run 3 times from the 5?

But is Herbert playing? Stats saying someone else is in?

In comment 14137041 mattyblue said:

Quote:

just run 3 times from the 5?

Because they have the worst coaching staff in the nation. Down 20 they ran three times to put themselves down 17.

Looks good, especially their LT.

In comment 14136862 chopperhatch said:

Quote:

An absolutely extraordinary player. A mix of Russell Wilson and Drew Brees. Perfect pocket presence, accurate, mobile, has a gun....if only he were coming out this year.

Agreed. I can't believe how good he is.

Gashes Ohio State for a TD. 28-6 now w/11:39 left.

I’m so happy right now.

This second half but he definitely needs to learn to read the defense better. He's staring down his recievers too much, but overall looks better. Daniel Jones will be moving up draft boards rapidly soon. As I said before, if he had a better recieving core, he'd look much better. He's my dark horse QB pick! Findley laid a huge egg today and his stock took a hit.

In comment 14137090 mittenedman said:

Quote:

In comment 14136862 chopperhatch said: Quote: An absolutely extraordinary player. A mix of Russell Wilson and Drew Brees. Perfect pocket presence, accurate, mobile, has a gun....if only he were coming out this year. Agreed. I can't believe how good he is.

Agree as well. His command of the offense for such a young player is extraordinary! He literally has everything you want in a QB

In comment 14137101 tyrik13 said:

Quote:

In comment 14137090 mittenedman said: Quote: In comment 14136862 chopperhatch said: Quote: An absolutely extraordinary player. A mix of Russell Wilson and Drew Brees. Perfect pocket presence, accurate, mobile, has a gun....if only he were coming out this year. Agreed. I can't believe how good he is. Agree as well. His command of the offense for such a young player is extraordinary! He literally has everything you want in a QB

Except draft eligibility. Herbert has looked very good in the second half. He plays in a juvenile offense, but you can see he is still making reads.

In comment 14137097 tyrik13 said:

Quote:

This second half but he definitely needs to learn to read the defense better. He's staring down his recievers too much, but overall looks better. Daniel Jones will be moving up draft boards rapidly soon. As I said before, if he had a better recieving core, he'd look much better. He's my dark horse QB pick! Findley laid a huge egg today and his stock took a hit.

Agreed. Every QBs warts were shown today. Out of it all I think Jones performed the best of the potential draft eligible guys. Like you said. Had Jones’s receivers caught their passes today he’d look a lot better stat wise.

may be best for Giants to go BPA in round 1, and then take a QB with 2nd round pick. Sucks Tua is still a year away from eligibility.

With 2 minutes left.

Wow

Looks like shit

In comment 14137124 nyjuggernaut2 said:

Quote:

may be best for Giants to go BPA in round 1, and then take a QB with 2nd round pick. Sucks Tua is still a year away from eligibility.

Herbert did not light the world on fire today, but that dude can play. We would be lucky to be in a position to draft that guy.

What an awesome day!