Should the Giants go DL Round 1, and QB Round 2?

A better idea may be to trade back up into the bottom of the first round to get that 5th year club option.

I think this only becomes a possibility if Herbert stays in school.

On the Justin Herbert thread, draft either Nick Bosa or Ed Oliver or Jonah Williams and the go Daniel Jones in the second. I wouldn't touch Will Grier with a stick, he's a bum in a QB friendly system that made Geno Smith look like a Heisman worthy candidate... hard pass

.

In comment 14137604 Ten Ton Hammer said:

Quote:

.

That's the beauty of both Oliver and Bosa, they can play in any defense.

You go best player available. That is a good strategy to replenish the talent on the roster, IMO.

We had very good to dominate DLs. We can use more talent upfront. You hear me complain if they drafted a talented Defensive Lineman.

.

In comment 14137601 tyrik13 said:

Quote:

On the Justin Herbert thread, draft either Nick Bosa or Ed Oliver or Jonah Williams and the go Daniel Jones in the second. I wouldn't touch Will Grier with a stick, he's a bum in a QB friendly system that made Geno Smith look like a Heisman worthy candidate... hard pass

If Herbert stayed in school I think Jones would probably be a first round pick. He may anyways depending on how the rest of the year and the predraft process goes.

A lot of football to watch/scout

But if there is a pass rusher that can bring back what NYG used to have in that department, it is certainly a strong play.

I understand it's the downside of a losing season I didn't
expect to be eliminated after six games .
When you know where you are picking and what moves you make
even this season we may seems some moves and wouldn't be
a bad idea to accumulate as many picks as you can plenty
of need's .

WCO QBs are common, Giants need to get smart at roster building.

Team needs help at every position expect DT and RB.

With that said I would go to a difference maker on D in the 1st. Then try again to fix the OL.

Choosing position over value is a terrible draft strategy.

someone who lifts the offense or defense because he's a step above most or all other players available when you pick.

It wont be a questiin after the combine. It might not even be close if he plays well against Miami and Clenson.

enough to take him in the first, it's probably not worth using a 2nd for lesser QB

If the player is a rare one, and move solder to the right side.

Pass rusher, OK.

Etc

In comment 14137719 Danny L said:

Quote:

Team needs help at every position expect DT and RB. With that said I would go to a difference maker on D in the 1st. Then try again to fix the OL.

I wouldn't complain about getting a difference maker on D. However and I know it's early, but it sounds like the draft is deeper on D this year and if that's the case, I'd look for a top OL in the 1st.

We need to fix the OL ASAP, and allow us to use the playmakers we have to the fullest. I think with an O hitting on all cylinders we can get away with an average D.

That said if a difference maker on D is head and shoulders the BPA, then I think they'd have to take him and I'd be good with that.

We Drafted Barkley, fix the damn Oline first.

+1

Drafting players. I can the OP can’t wait until season is over. We have 10 games to evaluate the players we have on the roster.

Drafting players. I can see the OP can’t wait until season is over. We have 10 games to evaluate the players we have on the roster.

DG drafting offensive linemen in every single round of the 2019 draft is actually a reasonable course of action.

behind that oline would be criminal.

in 2019? Let's sign Sam Bradford and just pick OL/DL first overall until 2023.

QB QB QB

In the hell are you asking this now? Seriously, this is not even worth the effort to type.

As of todsy, that’s probably DL.

fix the OL or we will back here again.

I hate using letters to shout out how i feel ,but for the sixth year in a row can we draft fucking OL with our top draft picks so that we can run an NFL type offense.

FCS!

In comment 14138099 Chip said:

Quote:

fix the OL or we will back here again.

Agreed.... Also we do not have a 3rd round pick in this draft. I'd trade back and load up on the OL early in this draft. We need to fix this OL with some young talent now. OL this year, Barkley will rush for a 1000 + plusssssssss.

In comment 14137927 LeftHook said:

Quote:

We Drafted Barkley, fix the damn Oline first.

Problem is they are not taking a LT with a top 3 pick because we just signed an average one for a ton of money. They are not taking a guard that high or a center so they have to go Defense

.

Depending on free agency then line next either oline or dline. We still have lots of holes.

I’d go BPA every round which hopefully includes some pass rushers & OL help. I move on from Eli & attempt to trade Beckham for more draft picks in 2019 which we are light on right now.

I’d start Lauletta at QB, he will either be serviceable or he won’t. If not, we are in solid position to go QB in 2020. I’m not overreaching for a QB in 19 to make up for not doing it in 18, I’m fine with Lauletta.

With a pick that may go extremely high on a crummy team-- he needs to make the right call. If the QB's are not that great then sure pass on them in the draft.