Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
as he's up for a new contract after the season. I'm a fan of his, as much for his attitude and effort as anything, but it'd be irresponsible not to be open to it. Giving him the deal he's likely looking for doesn't really do anything for us in our current stage of rebuilding
Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Go away.
Don't throw your hat in to be GM anymore. You don't have the stomach for it.
everyone else is on the block, but you need to get fair value for them.
I hate to see Snacks go, but the rebuild would take longer than his knees have left. Same for Collins, and I'd only want to trade him if we could get significantly more than we'd get in a comp pick if he were to sign elsewhere.
Some of the vets are established guys who could fetch a reasonable return, and in all likelihood would probably not last until the rebuild is done regardless.
Last but not least Eli, if he were to waive the NTC - I'd hope he could find a team where he can at least have a productive end to his career.
Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Go away.
Don't throw your hat in to be GM anymore. You don't have the stomach for it.
Because I don't tolerate stupidity and idiocy. Listen, if I was GM of the Giants, I would make sure I was surrounded by the best and the brightest football minds. Not people who think we should trade Saquon Barkley.
are mostly positive, especially considering the shit show around them. I think Hernandez, Hill, and Carter are all solid pieces to have moving forward. Obviously Barkely goes without saying
Because I don't tolerate stupidity and idiocy. Listen, if I was GM of the Giants, I would make sure I was surrounded by the best and the brightest football minds. Not people who think we should trade Saquon Barkley.
That's not what he said though. He didn't advocate actively trying to trade Barkley. Instead, in his mind Barkley shouldn't be untouchable.
If someone came to us with a Hershel Walker-type proposal, should we take it? It would be hard to say no.
Because I don't tolerate stupidity and idiocy. Listen, if I was GM of the Giants, I would make sure I was surrounded by the best and the brightest football minds. Not people who think we should trade Saquon Barkley.
That's not what he said though. He didn't advocate actively trying to trade Barkley. Instead, in his mind Barkley shouldn't be untouchable.
If someone came to us with a Hershel Walker-type proposal, should we take it? It would be hard to say no.
Lets be realistic. If this is the case, nobody is ever untouchable. If someone offers 12 first rounders for Mahomes, you think they take it??
I trade him for a second round 2019 pick today. He may develop, but he has been part of the OL problem - not in sync with Vet, and totally whiffing on plays. I think he can develop, but it's not a slam dunk.
Collins is another - what difference is he making in the secondary. I'd trade him for a third rounder today.
Collins
Everyone else can go.
Hernandez
Shep
Sean Connery as Jimmy Malone
Andy García as George Stone/Giuseppe Petri
Robert De Niro as Al Capone
Charles Martin Smith as Oscar Wallace
Patricia Clarkson as Catherine Ness
Billy Drago as Frank Nitti
Richard Bradford as Chief Mike Dorsett
Jack Kehoe as Walter Payne
Brad Sullivan as George
Del Close as Roy Alderman
Vito D'Ambrosio as Bowtie Driver
Clifton James as District Attorney (uncredited)
Don Patrick Harvey as Officer Preseuski
Hernandez
and Engram based off of last year.
On defense it might just be Snacks
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Collins
I don't know about Collins anymore. He went from stud to dud pretty quickly.
& that's it.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Go away.
...that's it.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Come back to planet earth
...that's it.
I'm with HoodieGelo... throw in Lorenzo Carter and Hill. Also, maybe Hernandez.
Quote:
Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Go away.
Don't throw your hat in to be GM anymore. You don't have the stomach for it.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Barkley
SB, Odell, Hernandez, anyone else???
Bingo.
SB, Odell, Hernandez, anyone else???
In that case, only Barkley and Hernandez.
I hate to see Snacks go, but the rebuild would take longer than his knees have left. Same for Collins, and I'd only want to trade him if we could get significantly more than we'd get in a comp pick if he were to sign elsewhere.
Some of the vets are established guys who could fetch a reasonable return, and in all likelihood would probably not last until the rebuild is done regardless.
Last but not least Eli, if he were to waive the NTC - I'd hope he could find a team where he can at least have a productive end to his career.
OBJ
barkley
hernandez
hill
90%
shep
engram
collins
I want back but would be okay moving on
snacks
jenkins
should trade
vernon
manning
Quote:
assuming the return is at best a 2nd rounder, who is untouchable. Who wouldn't you trade for a 2nd rounder?
SB, Odell, Hernandez, anyone else???
In that case, only Barkley and Hernandez.
I don't think we should bother debating OBJ's worth, but how sad is this roster? Outside of a few guys, not many have value.
Quote:
In comment 14143974 Go Terps said:
Quote:
Barkley is our best and most valuable player by miles, but at this point he might be the only guy on our roster that would net more in trade than we spent on him. If we're actually serious about rebuilding this roster through the draft he's our best chip.
There isn't anyone on this disaster of a team that should be untradeable.
Go away.
Don't throw your hat in to be GM anymore. You don't have the stomach for it.
Because I don't tolerate stupidity and idiocy. Listen, if I was GM of the Giants, I would make sure I was surrounded by the best and the brightest football minds. Not people who think we should trade Saquon Barkley.
Sean Connery as Jimmy Malone
Andy García as George Stone/Giuseppe Petri
Robert De Niro as Al Capone
Charles Martin Smith as Oscar Wallace
Patricia Clarkson as Catherine Ness
Billy Drago as Frank Nitti
Richard Bradford as Chief Mike Dorsett
Jack Kehoe as Walter Payne
Brad Sullivan as George
Del Close as Roy Alderman
Vito D'Ambrosio as Bowtie Driver
Clifton James as District Attorney (uncredited)
Okay this made me laugh
Don Patrick Harvey as Officer Preseuski
Quote:
Kevin Costner as Eliot Ness
Sean Connery as Jimmy Malone
Andy García as George Stone/Giuseppe Petri
Robert De Niro as Al Capone
Charles Martin Smith as Oscar Wallace
Patricia Clarkson as Catherine Ness
Billy Drago as Frank Nitti
Richard Bradford as Chief Mike Dorsett
Jack Kehoe as Walter Payne
Brad Sullivan as George
Del Close as Roy Alderman
Vito D'Ambrosio as Bowtie Driver
Clifton James as District Attorney (uncredited)
Okay this made me laugh
Don Patrick Harvey as Officer Preseuski
Okay this cracked me up
I said he was not untouchable. If someone is offering me 2 #1s for him I'm gonna consider it.
Barkley
Beckham (can't even if we wanted to)
Rosas
Dixon
Carter
Hill
Tomlinson
Hernandez
Shepard (maybe)
Engram (maybe)
^^^ plus 13 for another year at least
Hernandez
Hill
Odell (unless they get 2 1st rounders - but think his dead money would be a deal breaker)
Everyone else can be traded
Starting Dline
Offensive skill positions (WR/RB/TE)
Because I don't tolerate stupidity and idiocy. Listen, if I was GM of the Giants, I would make sure I was surrounded by the best and the brightest football minds. Not people who think we should trade Saquon Barkley.
That's not what he said though. He didn't advocate actively trying to trade Barkley. Instead, in his mind Barkley shouldn't be untouchable.
If someone came to us with a Hershel Walker-type proposal, should we take it? It would be hard to say no.
Quote:
Because I don't tolerate stupidity and idiocy. Listen, if I was GM of the Giants, I would make sure I was surrounded by the best and the brightest football minds. Not people who think we should trade Saquon Barkley.
That's not what he said though. He didn't advocate actively trying to trade Barkley. Instead, in his mind Barkley shouldn't be untouchable.
If someone came to us with a Hershel Walker-type proposal, should we take it? It would be hard to say no.
Lets be realistic. If this is the case, nobody is ever untouchable. If someone offers 12 first rounders for Mahomes, you think they take it??
Collins is another - what difference is he making in the secondary. I'd trade him for a third rounder today.