So the Mets invite him to spring training. Still a fast guy. Approaching 40.
What do we know? Seems relatively durable. Good vet presence? Pinch-runner? Spot CF? Can’t be for but a few bucks. Good move?
As long as he’s been around, I know next to nothing about the guy.
How does this move affect any other possible OF moves?
Happy Tuesday, BBI!
I know Flores' career didn't wind up how many of us hoped or anticipated, but the Mets did him no favors.
Same so far with the aforementioned Nimmo.
They've almost already blocked Alonso because where does 37, 38, 39 and 40 year old Cano go?
Pretty sure those legs aren't play second base everyday.
I know Flores' career didn't wind up how many of us hoped or anticipated, but the Mets did him no favors.
Same so far with the aforementioned Nimmo.
They've almost already blocked Alonso because where does 37, 38, 39 and 40 year old Cano go?
Pretty sure those legs aren't play second base everyday.
Agreed all around. Just let the best guys play and let everyone compete. It's not that complicated. honestly I wouldn't even have an issue letting Mcneil try out CF. Who knows. Just don't make decisions around a mediocre vet like Frazier. That only makes everyone look bad when he's hitting .185 on May 1st. I actually think he will have a bounce back year but why make the decision on who to start right now?
Who knows how many games that might cost the Mets. 1, 2, 3? Could be the difference between wild card or not, or shit it's December, could be the difference between the division or not.
1 game in April is just as valuable as 1 game in September.
I'd do what you said, start the best players and ideally it works out that Frazier is your backup, not the other way around, and not a situation that when Frazier fails you then put McNeil in when you're 5 games out of the wild card and clinging to meaningful baseball by the all-star break.
I think all fans obviously want the team to win first and foremost, but I also think most fans would accept losing with youth (though that's relative with McNeil) more than losing with mediocre veterans like Frazier.
- Keith Law, December 2019
PAY UP DAN lol
- Keith Law, December 2019
PAY UP DAN lol
I saw that and immediately thought of you. Where do you fall in the kelenic/dunn ranking discussion? I think Law is still overly high on Dunn, as has been his MO with high draft picks he likes. I like Kelenic a lot, but I still fail to see where he's on some other level from Vientos or Gimenez.
Quote:
“They were clearly a top 10 system for me before the trade”
- Keith Law, December 2019
PAY UP DAN lol
I saw that and immediately thought of you. Where do you fall in the kelenic/dunn ranking discussion? I think Law is still overly high on Dunn, as has been his MO with high draft picks he likes. I like Kelenic a lot, but I still fail to see where he's on some other level from Vientos or Gimenez.
I called Kelenic Harper-lite,the good with the bad, draft time. I love that old school scrappy player. One of his first pro games he was caught looking for a K. He was PISSED, cursing up a storm on way to dugout. Within 30 seconds he came out to talk to the coaches about what his approach was, etc and seeing what he did wrong and what to improve I LOVE THAT!!!!!
Dunn is good, in my opinion is boom or bust. Something clicks and he’s filthy. It doesn’t click he’s quadA or good setup arm
Kelenic has a chance to be special. My personal low end on him is an8-10 year career that people undervalue him. His upside is just special, unique.
Quote:
“They were clearly a top 10 system for me before the trade”
- Keith Law, December 2019
PAY UP DAN lol
I saw that and immediately thought of you. Where do you fall in the kelenic/dunn ranking discussion? I think Law is still overly high on Dunn, as has been his MO with high draft picks he likes. I like Kelenic a lot, but I still fail to see where he's on some other level from Vientos or Gimenez.
I know draft picks don't always pan out, but why do you think Kelenic was #6 overall draft pick, Vientos went in the 2nd round, and Gimenez was the #15 ranked IFA in his class?
Most people feel like Kelenic has a higher upside than the others.
May not pan out that way, but think think that's pretty clear.
That opinion has appeared to shift upwards (like Law stating that he's a top 20-30 prospect in all of baseball) but some of the more localized prospect writers (like the guys from baseball prospectus who follow the mets system a little more closely) have been a little more muted relative to the rest of the met system. His debut in pro ball last year was perfectly acceptable and it definitely appears his make up has won scouts over in a big way (as shecky's thoughts indicate). Here's what BP said about Kelenic in his updated Mets top 10 a couple weeks ago:
So my question with Kelenic is specifically in comparison with other similarly aged guys in the system like Vientos (half a year younger) and Gimenez (half a year older) who also have blue chip pedigrees and have flashed impressive tools at premium positions. In Gimenez' case his makeup has also been similarly praised. I wish we still had all 3 I just personally am curious as to what specifically separates Kelenic from those 2.
Quote:
In comment 14229175 Shecky said:
Quote:
“They were clearly a top 10 system for me before the trade”
- Keith Law, December 2019
PAY UP DAN lol
I saw that and immediately thought of you. Where do you fall in the kelenic/dunn ranking discussion? I think Law is still overly high on Dunn, as has been his MO with high draft picks he likes. I like Kelenic a lot, but I still fail to see where he's on some other level from Vientos or Gimenez.
I called Kelenic Harper-lite,the good with the bad, draft time. I love that old school scrappy player. One of his first pro games he was caught looking for a K. He was PISSED, cursing up a storm on way to dugout. Within 30 seconds he came out to talk to the coaches about what his approach was, etc and seeing what he did wrong and what to improve I LOVE THAT!!!!!
Dunn is good, in my opinion is boom or bust. Something clicks and he’s filthy. It doesn’t click he’s quadA or good setup arm
Kelenic has a chance to be special. My personal low end on him is an8-10 year career that people undervalue him. His upside is just special, unique.
Thanks Shecky. Knowing that's how you feel about him, would you have given him up for Diaz?
2008 - Kyle Skipworth
2009 - Zach Wheeler
2010 - Barrett Loux
2011 - Anthony Rendon
2012 - Albert Almora
If the 2 leaders are within 5% of each other, or the leader has less than 30% there will be a run-off between the top 2. If a run-off results in a tie the tiebreaker will be vote total in the previous poll, we will continue to "go back" in the polls until there is a clear leader.
*Jeff McNeil is ineligible
*Chris Flexen is ineligible
*Drew Smith is ineligible
*Tyler Bashlor is ineligible
1) Andres Gimenez (SS) AA 19/37 votes- 51%
2) Peter Alonso (1B) AAA 24/36 votes- 67%
3) Ronny Mauricio (SS) Kingsport 12/33-36%
4) Mark Vientos (3b) Kingsport 16/31-52%
5) David Peterson (LHP) A+ 21/31- 68%
6) Franklyn Kilome (RHP) AA 20/33-61%
7) Thomas Szapucki (LHP) A 18/32-56%
8) Shervyen Newton (SS) Kingsport 12/30-40%, Run-off with Anthony Kay 17/33-52%
9) Anthony Kay (LHP) AA 18/26-69%
10) Simeon Woods-Richardson (RHP) Kingsport 12/30-40%
11) Luis Santana (2B) 15/26-58%
12) Will Toffey (3B) 10/29-34%, run-off with Cecchini 15/27-56%
13) Gavin Cecchini (2b) 14/26-46%
14) Francisco Alvarez (C) 9/26-35%
15) Dez Lindsay (OF) 7/18-39%
16) Tony Dibrell (RHP) 9/23-39%
17) Jordan Humphreys (RHP) 7/21-33%, Run-off with Nido 18/24-75%
18) Ross Adolph (OF) 6/25-24%, run-off with Nido 18/25-72%
19) Adam Hill (RHP) 4/26-15%, Run-off with Nido/Crismatt 11/26-58%
20) Junior Santos (RHP) 6/28-21%, Run-off with Nido 11/20-55%
21) Tomas Nido (C) 10/23-43%
22) Luis Guillorme (SS) 9/24-38%
23) Adrian Hernandez 6/26-23%, run-off with Wahl/Cortes 8/15-53%
24) Carlos Cortes (2b) 8/21-38%
25) Steven Villines (RHP) 4/16 25%, Run-off with Thompson/Wahl 9/23-39%
26) David Thompson (3b) 8/23-35%
27) Ali Sanchez (C) 9/17-53%
28) Bobby Wahl (RHP) 11/25-44%
29) Eric Hanhold (RHP) 7/21-33%, run-off 7/20-35%
30) Luis Carpio (IF) 4/18-22%, runoff with Uriarte 9/14-64%
31) Stanley Consuegra (OF) 4/20-20%, runoff with Uriarte/Valdez 6/17-35%, advances due to more votes in previous poll
32) Juan Uriarte (C) 4/19-21%
33) Freddy Valdez (OF) 7/17-41%
34) Daniel Zamora (LHP) 3/17-18%, run-off with Montes De Oca 10/12-83%
35) Jaylen Palmer (??) 3/12-25%, run-off with Montes de Oca/Vilera 9/16-56%
36) Ryley Gilliam (RHP) 5/22-23%, run-off with Manea 8/16-50%, advances due to more votes in previous poll
37) Matt Winaker (OF) 4/22-18
38) Kyle Dowdy (RHP) 6/20-30%, run-off with Vilera 9/12-75%
39) Jaison Vilera (RHP) 6/17-35%
But...
I’m a huge fan of a dominant pen, but not a dominant reliever. Just my opinion, and I know it’s a minority opinion. Diaz has a chance to be in that rarified air of consistent, dominant end of game shut down guy he’s young, controllable (in my opinion, closer is the least valuable ‘controlable’ Asset since their arb pay is grosslyinflataaed compared to any other position)
Anyway, I’m rambling. This is one of the toughest trades to say you like or don’t like. Too many pieces. Cano. His contract. The $20mm. Bruce/Swarz. Their contracts. Diaz. The prospects Dunn/Kelenic. There’s simply too much to say if you liked the trade or not. But Brodie wanted/needed to make a statement. Knew the first deal he made he needed to have other orgs scratch their heads wondering if he knows what he’s doing. Excite the fan base. EXCITE JEFF. He had to make this trade, and Seattle was NOT making this trade without Kelenic... lol, damn I rambled...
But...
I’m a huge fan of a dominant pen, but not a dominant reliever. Just my opinion, and I know it’s a minority opinion. Diaz has a chance to be in that rarified air of consistent, dominant end of game shut down guy he’s young, controllable (in my opinion, closer is the least valuable ‘controlable’ Asset since their arb pay is grosslyinflataaed compared to any other position)
Anyway, I’m rambling. This is one of the toughest trades to say you like or don’t like. Too many pieces. Cano. His contract. The $20mm. Bruce/Swarz. Their contracts. Diaz. The prospects Dunn/Kelenic. There’s simply too much to say if you liked the trade or not. But Brodie wanted/needed to make a statement. Knew the first deal he made he needed to have other orgs scratch their heads wondering if he knows what he’s doing. Excite the fan base. EXCITE JEFF. He had to make this trade, and Seattle was NOT making this trade without Kelenic... lol, damn I rambled...
It was a good ramble though. I agree with just about all of it. Every piece in the deal was high variance so I guess we just wait and see.
That's a very fair point. I guess my argument isn't so much that I'm opposed to not being high on the other guys, but rather curious about why (especially when his own opinion seems to have evolved a lot in a short period of time).
Generally speaking the scouting industry does not "buy" RH 1b and for the most part they are right. The list isn't long. The list doens't have to be long for Alonso to be good but it's betting on the side of recent history which seems "Safe"
Exactly - the law of averages rewards skepticism more than optimism.
Quote:
To not be high on alonso and say “hats off to the kid he proved me wrong” than to go out on a limb first and say you think he’s legit
Generally speaking the scouting industry does not "buy" RH 1b and for the most part they are right. The list isn't long. The list doens't have to be long for Alonso to be good but it's betting on the side of recent history which seems "Safe"
You said it much better than I sir, well put
Law is known for his stubbornness in refusing to admit he was wrong. It took him several years into his career before he admitted that he was wrong on Chris Sale.
Whatever happened to Rob Neyer -- was he forced to retire in shame over his "Jose Reyes is the worst everyday player in baseball" hot take from early 2006????
Quote:
say this... Seidler takes hits for being negative and trolls attack him because of his intertwining his political views on twitter BUT he and Jeff P do attend a LOT of games. So there is some added value to them.
Whatever happened to Rob Neyer -- was he forced to retire in shame over his "Jose Reyes is the worst everyday player in baseball" hot take from early 2006????
It looks like he's just an author now
Link - ( New Window )