Recently we are seeing this rush to say the defense is the reason the Giants are bad.
This is incorrect.
The Giants may have been eliminated by the Titans but the season ended at 1-7.
Shurmur and Eli have been talking about “close” and “competitive” games that we lost by single digits.
Now the defense may have blown the games to both the Colts and the cOwboys, but the truth is the Giants would be 7-9 and out of the playoffs with those wins anyway.
The fact of the matter is
The Giants started 0-2 and the defense allowed 20 pts in both games. The offense managed just 15 pts and 13 pts.
In fact the Giants scored 20 pts or less in 6 of the first 8 games, Hiw many games could possibly be won with those numbers? The season was over at that point.
Furthermore, the Giants suffered 5 single digit losses in this stretch and in 4 of them the opposition scored 20, 20, 23, 20. So was it the defense that caused those losses? Or was it the defense keeping them “close” and “competitive”?
The Giants were eliminated to the extent that they dumped off Eli Apple and Snacks and thus hurting the defense because the season was already over.
On top of it- in the 5 Giants win. The defense got 2 turnovers vs Texans, got 2 turnovers in San Fran, 4 turnovers including a defensive TD vs Tampa, 3 turnovers and a defensive TD vs the Bears, and 3 turnovers and a defensive TD vs the Redskins.
You are looking at multiple turnovers in 4 of the wins and and 3/4 turnovers and defensive TDs in 3 of the wins.
Eli Manning threw under 200 yards in 3 of the wins.
If the Titans game was a “single score game for a long time”as Shurmur said it was because of the defense and not our offense which got shutout.
The Giants this year were bad. The offense was bad and the defense became bad as the season wore in and long after it was over and pieces were removed from the team.
I’m sorry but this was not the story of a great offense being subjected to blown game after blown game by the defense. That may have happened in the last 2 meaningless games but it’s not the story of the season.
Of course people will respond when they read something that they blatantly disagree with, or that is not rooted in reality.
Whats eye scratching is people are still blaming the offense for the last two games. Thats where the problem lies with assessing blame.
Can we blame the offense for a no show against Jax, Dallas first time, Washington, and Atlanta. Absolutely. No one is innocent in those games.
But the narratives that Eli cant lead us from behind (false.)
The narrative that the offense failed us in the last two games (false)
The narrative that the defense was worn down early (false)
We have to separate fantasy from reality at some point.
some of your narratives are insane.. good offenses in 2018 get the field goal against dallas.. that was a gimme.. also above you mention how the defense screwed up the games against Saints and Falcons.. did you ever bother watching them before they played the giants? Teams had scored 43, 37, 41, and 29 against them before they faced the giants.. giants scored 6 meaningful points in that game.. then with less than 5 minutes to go Giants great offense score 14 points once the game had already been decided.. 8 of those came with less than 10 seconds to go (ATL basically didn't care about anything at that point).. Both NO and ATL offenses were kept well below their normal scores going into the 4th quarter.. in the meantime our offense was well below scoring level against their defenses.. Don't blame the defenses for that game.. our offense sucked far more in those games than did our defense..
I really could not care less what you think about me. you are wrong and have selective vision because I post on different topics. I happen to think you are a toxic angry and confrontational person and this site was much better when you were banned.
Thats great. I think the site would be much better without. See how this works?
I am confrontational to people who call a fan boy, elitist, or anything that mocks people supporting Eli. Are you going to deny you call posters that?
As opposed to a poster that calls people the Cult of Eli and Eli fanboys constantly?
Everyone knows the fucking reason you have posted continually that the defense carried the team in 2007 and 2011, and it has nothing to do with making the site better.
what a disingenuous fuck.
some of your narratives are insane.. good offenses in 2018 get the field goal against dallas.. that was a gimme.. also above you mention how the defense screwed up the games against Saints and Falcons.. did you ever bother watching them before they played the giants? Teams had scored 43, 37, 41, and 29 against them before they faced the giants.. giants scored 6 meaningful points in that game.. then with less than 5 minutes to go Giants great offense score 14 points once the game had already been decided.. 8 of those came with less than 10 seconds to go (ATL basically didn't care about anything at that point).. Both NO and ATL offenses were kept well below their normal scores going into the 4th quarter.. in the meantime our offense was well below scoring level against their defenses.. Don't blame the defenses for that game.. our offense sucked far more in those games than did our defense..
Good offenses take care of gimmes? There are no guarantees in football. They offense stalled. It happens. The Giants scored 17 points in the 4th quarter and since 4 plays didnt go there way - they failed? Thats really weird logic, dont you think?
And I mentioned the offensive failures in Atlanta. Did I not? So how is that inane narratives?
Of course people will respond when they read something that they blatantly disagree with, or that is not rooted in reality.
Exhibit A
Exhibit B
Exhibit C
Quote:
Still doesn't change the fact that people starting a million threads a day slamming Manning and placing the blame solely on him.
Of course people will respond when they read something that they blatantly disagree with, or that is not rooted in reality.
Exhibit A
Exhibit B
Exhibit C
lol. You're obsession with me is an all time hight
Quote:
some of your narratives are insane.. good offenses in 2018 get the field goal against dallas.. that was a gimme.. also above you mention how the defense screwed up the games against Saints and Falcons.. did you ever bother watching them before they played the giants? Teams had scored 43, 37, 41, and 29 against them before they faced the giants.. giants scored 6 meaningful points in that game.. then with less than 5 minutes to go Giants great offense score 14 points once the game had already been decided.. 8 of those came with less than 10 seconds to go (ATL basically didn't care about anything at that point).. Both NO and ATL offenses were kept well below their normal scores going into the 4th quarter.. in the meantime our offense was well below scoring level against their defenses.. Don't blame the defenses for that game.. our offense sucked far more in those games than did our defense..
Good offenses take care of gimmes? There are no guarantees in football. They offense stalled. It happens. The Giants scored 17 points in the 4th quarter and since 4 plays didnt go there way - they failed? Thats really weird logic, dont you think?
And I mentioned the offensive failures in Atlanta. Did I not? So how is that inane narratives?
No but you keep trying to pass the blame only to the defense.. our offense sucked at the beginning of the year.. our defense was respectable.. by the end of the year the roles were reversed.. but at neither stage did any of them look good.. plus defense has the excuse of starters being traded.. JPP, Snacks, Apple and then Landon Collins being hurt..
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=577778
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=577764
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=577779
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=577789
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=577781
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=577359&thread_page=1
Threads from the first page alone about Eli where I neither posted or posted well into the thread. Selective reading. Usually the case when someone stalks you.
No but you keep trying to pass the blame only to the defense.. our offense sucked at the beginning of the year.. our defense was respectable.. by the end of the year the roles were reversed.. but at neither stage did any of them look good.. plus defense has the excuse of starters being traded.. JPP, Snacks, Apple and then Landon Collins being hurt..
How am I only blaming the defense when I said the offense sputtered against 4 of the first 7 teams we played? And if you are going to make excuses for the defnes,e you can do it for the offense too.
The fact is we were by far the worst 4th quarter defense in the NFL this year. This from the start to the end. The fact is we blew 6 leads in the last 2 minutes. The fact is we didnt force a punt in 5 of 6 games in the the 1-7 start. These facts cannot be denied. And the failure of the defenses included Snacks and Apple. And JPP was never on this team so he is irrelevant. And Collins was healthy for the majority of the year.
The defense failed us in the 4th quarter from game 2 all the way to game 16. The offensive production is a separate issue.
Quote:
I really could not care less what you think about me. you are wrong and have selective vision because I post on different topics. I happen to think you are a toxic angry and confrontational person and this site was much better when you were banned.
As opposed to a poster that calls people the Cult of Eli and Eli fanboys constantly?
Everyone knows the fucking reason you have posted continually that the defense carried the team in 2007 and 2011, and it has nothing to do with making the site better.
what a disingenuous fuck.
Quote:
No but you keep trying to pass the blame only to the defense.. our offense sucked at the beginning of the year.. our defense was respectable.. by the end of the year the roles were reversed.. but at neither stage did any of them look good.. plus defense has the excuse of starters being traded.. JPP, Snacks, Apple and then Landon Collins being hurt..
How am I only blaming the defense when I said the offense sputtered against 4 of the first 7 teams we played? And if you are going to make excuses for the defnes,e you can do it for the offense too.
The fact is we were by far the worst 4th quarter defense in the NFL this year. This from the start to the end. The fact is we blew 6 leads in the last 2 minutes. The fact is we didnt force a punt in 5 of 6 games in the the 1-7 start. These facts cannot be denied. And the failure of the defenses included Snacks and Apple. And JPP was never on this team so he is irrelevant. And Collins was healthy for the majority of the year.
The defense failed us in the 4th quarter from game 2 all the way to game 16. The offensive production is a separate issue.
Which 3 games did the offense not sputter in the first 7 games?
If the idea is that the defense isn't the only side of the ball that needs help, well.... no shit.
It looks like we've devolved entirely into personal attacks and arguing over nonsense, though - so the football portion of this thread (whatever it was), appears to be in the rear view anyway.
If the idea is that the defense isn't the only side of the ball that needs help, well.... no shit.
It looks like we've devolved entirely into personal attacks and arguing over nonsense, though - so the football portion of this thread (whatever it was), appears to be in the rear view anyway.
Perfectly sums up the state of this website currently.
Quote:
In comment 14245840 chuckydee9 said:
Quote:
No but you keep trying to pass the blame only to the defense.. our offense sucked at the beginning of the year.. our defense was respectable.. by the end of the year the roles were reversed.. but at neither stage did any of them look good.. plus defense has the excuse of starters being traded.. JPP, Snacks, Apple and then Landon Collins being hurt..
How am I only blaming the defense when I said the offense sputtered against 4 of the first 7 teams we played? And if you are going to make excuses for the defnes,e you can do it for the offense too.
The fact is we were by far the worst 4th quarter defense in the NFL this year. This from the start to the end. The fact is we blew 6 leads in the last 2 minutes. The fact is we didnt force a punt in 5 of 6 games in the the 1-7 start. These facts cannot be denied. And the failure of the defenses included Snacks and Apple. And JPP was never on this team so he is irrelevant. And Collins was healthy for the majority of the year.
The defense failed us in the 4th quarter from game 2 all the way to game 16. The offensive production is a separate issue.
Which 3 games did the offense not sputter in the first 7 games?
Houston, Carolina, Saints. The Saints game looks bad on paper. But the lost fumble by Gallman and Penalties were a killer. We did move the ball on them and had it at one score game with 5 minutes to go.
If the idea is that the defense isn't the only side of the ball that needs help, well.... no shit.
It looks like we've devolved entirely into personal attacks and arguing over nonsense, though - so the football portion of this thread (whatever it was), appears to be in the rear view anyway.
Good post Arc. Ill take responsibility of responding to the posters who had no interest in talking about the post. Ive got to be better.
This doesn't absolve the offense. Their output was not enough in the first 8 games. But, look back at the games where they hang around, Barkley scores a TD late in the 4th, only to have the lead given right back and resulting in a loss. Win one or two of those games early, you don't what kind of residual effects it has on the season.
All this said, I think the offense was pathetic. That lies with a terrible OL, bad coaching, bad gameplanning, and bad playcalling, in my opinion. Also, while we saw better output in the second half and a lot has been attributed to adding Jamon Brown, our running game actually took a hit once OBJ went out. Brown certainly helped us, but the OL went from downright terrible and likely the worst in the league to simply fall in the bottom 1/3. We still need serious upgrades simply to be an average to slightly above average OL. That should give the overall offense a tremendous boost next year.
Quote:
In comment 14245847 dep026 said:
Quote:
In comment 14245840 chuckydee9 said:
Quote:
No but you keep trying to pass the blame only to the defense.. our offense sucked at the beginning of the year.. our defense was respectable.. by the end of the year the roles were reversed.. but at neither stage did any of them look good.. plus defense has the excuse of starters being traded.. JPP, Snacks, Apple and then Landon Collins being hurt..
How am I only blaming the defense when I said the offense sputtered against 4 of the first 7 teams we played? And if you are going to make excuses for the defnes,e you can do it for the offense too.
The fact is we were by far the worst 4th quarter defense in the NFL this year. This from the start to the end. The fact is we blew 6 leads in the last 2 minutes. The fact is we didnt force a punt in 5 of 6 games in the the 1-7 start. These facts cannot be denied. And the failure of the defenses included Snacks and Apple. And JPP was never on this team so he is irrelevant. And Collins was healthy for the majority of the year.
The defense failed us in the 4th quarter from game 2 all the way to game 16. The offensive production is a separate issue.
Which 3 games did the offense not sputter in the first 7 games?
Houston, Carolina, Saints. The Saints game looks bad on paper. But the lost fumble by Gallman and Penalties were a killer. We did move the ball on them and had it at one score game with 5 minutes to go.
See thats what I mean.. what you described there is sputtering.. Carolina game, the giants offense sputtered.. Dallas and Atlanta.. they didn't sputter.. they actually sucked, were bad, horrible..
Um, ok.
Um, ok.
Turnovers.. its still much closer to sputtering then calling the Jags game as just sputtering and not a bad offensive game..
They had not one, not two, but three third down stops on D overturned by penalties, one of which was an INT where Collins was deemed to have hit a defenseless WR.
Then, they scored two TD's in the last few minutes to take the lead, only to have Carolina be given a phantom 1st down to set up the winning FG.
I challenge anyone to find a play in the history of the NFL where an intercepting player is called for a personal foul for an illegal hit.
They had not one, not two, but three third down stops on D overturned by penalties, one of which was an INT where Collins was deemed to have hit a defenseless WR.
Then, they scored two TD's in the last few minutes to take the lead, only to have Carolina be given a phantom 1st down to set up the winning FG.
I challenge anyone to find a play in the history of the NFL where an intercepting player is called for a personal foul for an illegal hit.
Yes.. and on many levels.. ok so the giants O didn't sputter in 2 games out of the first 7.. but then you can't call the jags, dallas and ATL game as just sputtering..
Fact - Both the offense and defense were responsible for our poor record in 2018. Does it really fucking matter if it was a 68-32 split or a 27-73 split? Both units need improvement.
And it was the right call - not sure what people are complaining about.. would we have preferred to finish 7-9 or 8-8 ...to 5-11?
I wouldn't. I'll take the 6th overall pick. Thanks.
Quote:
Carolina....
Um, ok.
Turnovers.. its still much closer to sputtering then calling the Jags game as just sputtering and not a bad offensive game..
We scored 31 points. They didnt sputter. Come on.
And it was the right call - not sure what people are complaining about.. would we have preferred to finish 7-9 or 8-8 ...to 5-11?
I wouldn't. I'll take the 6th overall pick. Thanks.
Snacks was a good player. But what did Eli Apple do here to stand out?
Quote:
If at 1-7, management hadn't decided to trade defensive assets for picks.
And it was the right call - not sure what people are complaining about.. would we have preferred to finish 7-9 or 8-8 ...to 5-11?
I wouldn't. I'll take the 6th overall pick. Thanks.
Snacks was a good player. But what did Eli Apple do here to stand out?
He was better than next man up. That's the point. He does start for the number 1 seed Saints after all.