Steve Serby's mock draft.
1. Cardinals - Nick Bosa (DE, Ohio State)
2. Giants (from 49ers) - Dwayne Haskins (QB, Ohio State)
3. Jets - Quinnen Williams (DL, Alabama)
4. Raiders - Clelin Ferrell (DE, Clemson)
5. Buccaneers - Ed Oliver (DT, Houston)
6. 49ers (from Giants) - Greedy Williams (CB, LSU)
Link - (
New Window )
Quote:
In comment 14249804 GoDeep13 said:
Quote:
Jones Reminds me of Mitch Trubisky. And while the opinions on Trubisky are split (I personally like him and expect him to continue to improve) Id thin a lot of you would take a Trubisky like talent to start 2019.
No effin way would I take Trubisky.
you wouldn’t want a 24 yr old mobile QB with the 3rd highest QBR behind only Mahomes and Brees? Interesting.
Not him, nope.
LOL....Exactly on point and I would be one of them
Quote:
In comment 14249821 section125 said:
Quote:
In comment 14249804 GoDeep13 said:
Quote:
Jones Reminds me of Mitch Trubisky. And while the opinions on Trubisky are split (I personally like him and expect him to continue to improve) Id thin a lot of you would take a Trubisky like talent to start 2019.
No effin way would I take Trubisky.
you wouldn’t want a 24 yr old mobile QB with the 3rd highest QBR behind only Mahomes and Brees? Interesting.
Not him, nope.
Quote:
In comment 14249628 Bruner4329 said:
Quote:
So let me get this. Giants are going to trade up from 6 to 2 that will cost them a lot of capital in draft picks which we need, for a QB that at best is a middle first round pick. Come on wake up people. This aint happening Haskins may be the best QB in the draft but he is not a sure thing by far. If you watch the games sure he looks great, standing in the pocket for 10-15 seconds showing poise and then throwing a pass to a wide open WR. Fact is this is not reality. Ohio State talent is heads above most opponents they play. This is not the NFL. he is raw and unproven. Would like to see what he can do when he actually gets rushed and has a hand in his face. If DG did this then he really should be fired.
Bruner, I asked a previous poster to name a college QB prospect that they evaluated that they feel was a better prospect that performed well under pressure (No reply yet). I’d like to ask you the same question?
I think Jones has made a number of very good plays under pressure. The but he can’t both throw AND catch the ball. His WRs were trash.
What game or games did Jones face this past year where you say he performed well under duress?
Quote:
In comment 14249656 Dutch77 said:
Quote:
In comment 14249628 Bruner4329 said:
Quote:
So let me get this. Giants are going to trade up from 6 to 2 that will cost them a lot of capital in draft picks which we need, for a QB that at best is a middle first round pick. Come on wake up people. This aint happening Haskins may be the best QB in the draft but he is not a sure thing by far. If you watch the games sure he looks great, standing in the pocket for 10-15 seconds showing poise and then throwing a pass to a wide open WR. Fact is this is not reality. Ohio State talent is heads above most opponents they play. This is not the NFL. he is raw and unproven. Would like to see what he can do when he actually gets rushed and has a hand in his face. If DG did this then he really should be fired.
Bruner, I asked a previous poster to name a college QB prospect that they evaluated that they feel was a better prospect that performed well under pressure (No reply yet). I’d like to ask you the same question?
I think Jones has made a number of very good plays under pressure. The but he can’t both throw AND catch the ball. His WRs were trash.
What game or games did Jones face this past year where you say he performed well under duress?
so you wouldn’t take Trubisky over Eli or all the FA QBs or the Draft QBs this year? Good thing you just watch football.
Eli, maybe. Look Trubisky is nothing special, IMV. If you like him fine.
Quote:
so you wouldn’t take Trubisky over Eli or all the FA QBs or the Draft QBs this year? Good thing you just watch football.
Eli, maybe. Look Trubisky is nothing special, IMV. If you like him fine.
Quote:
In comment 14250042 GoDeep13 said:
Quote:
so you wouldn’t take Trubisky over Eli or all the FA QBs or the Draft QBs this year? Good thing you just watch football.
Eli, maybe. Look Trubisky is nothing special, IMV. If you like him fine.
we don’t need special. We need effective.
Quote:
In comment 14250219 section125 said:
Quote:
In comment 14250042 GoDeep13 said:
Quote:
so you wouldn’t take Trubisky over Eli or all the FA QBs or the Draft QBs this year? Good thing you just watch football.
Eli, maybe. Look Trubisky is nothing special, IMV. If you like him fine.
we don’t need special. We need effective.
Not with a 1st round pick. Lauletta could do that.
Dutch, with all due respect, it would cost an arm and a leg to get a premium edge rusher through free agency. How is that working out with Oliviier Vernon? The Giants lost their ballgames in the second half of the season, because of a crappy defense with no pass rush. I firmly believe that DG and PS are very cognizant about the QB situation and where it is heading. They also are very much aware of the lack of talent In the trenches on both sides. You can’t force a draft pick at any position, including QB. I like what I see in Haskins, but as it is pointed out, how is he against a pass rush under pressure? We don’t have enough information to determine that. That is for the scouts to determine though. If DG in PS like him, they will take him.
Quote:
So let me get this. Giants are going to trade up from 6 to 2 that will cost them a lot of capital in draft picks which we need, for a QB that at best is a middle first round pick. Come on wake up people. This aint happening Haskins may be the best QB in the draft but he is not a sure thing by far. If you watch the games sure he looks great, standing in the pocket for 10-15 seconds showing poise and then throwing a pass to a wide open WR. Fact is this is not reality. Ohio State talent is heads above most opponents they play. This is not the NFL. he is raw and unproven. Would like to see what he can do when he actually gets rushed and has a hand in his face. If DG did this then he really should be fired.
Bruner, I asked a previous poster to name a college QB prospect that they evaluated that they feel was a better prospect that performed well under pressure (No reply yet). I’d like to ask you the same question?
In this year's upcoming draft none. But that is my point these guys including Haskins are over rated because all people see are him throwing the ball with a clean pocket 99% of the time. Last year I thought Mayfield had exhibited the most pre draft and from what I have seen I think he will be the best of the bunch. IMO jury still out on others. After today I really wonder if Jackson has all the tools to be a good NFL QB. All he has going for him are his legs.