so you're tasked with making a poll:
Who will be the starting and backup QBs for the 2019 NY Giants?
I'd guess you would want 5 to 7 choices. maybe more? you have to start with Eli as one. probably add Lauletta, although his 2018 wasn't a great on or off field indicator. and the Giants did lett Webb go after 1 year. add in some prospective FAs, trade candidates and draft prospects.
So who would you list in a 5 to 7 name poll as most likely to be in consideration to hold down the #1 or #2 NY Giant QB spot in 2019? as it stands right now. pre-combine. etc
Kyle Lauletta
Nick Foles
Dwayne Haskins
Daniel Jones
Tyree Jackson
Will Grier
2019 pick.... maybe lock
2019 draft pick
Lauletta
Draft pick
Lauletta.
Draft pick/Sloter.
Lauletta.
Draft pick/Sloter.
Ditto.
THAT is not happening!
definitely not Eli
If they decide o take a QB
they will probably carry 3 QB's Whomever they draft won't be the starter .
If they Sign a QB Say Foles Bridgewater Would they not have to cut or trade Eli before hand ?
Very difficult to make an accurate Guess .
Haskins and Jones are the only two I think they might take .
I don't think Either are worthy at 6th pick
Eli is basically a lock to start and backup could be a number of players really .
This.
This is what I WANT to happen --- Flacco or Foles is what I think WILL happen.
Of course. You just want your hero to start and nothing else matters, isn't that right/ You''re a hero worshipper.
Basically, Fix the Trenches, then worry about a QB.
Eli
Kyle
2019 1st round pick
2019 draft pick not 1st round
FA veteran
Trade Veteran
But Lauletta will be 3rd string not getting past the hof'er Tanny
There you go again, acting as though you know anything about the minds of our front office and ownership. Give it a rest for once.
Basically, Fix the Trenches, then worry about a QB.
David Carr? That ship has sailed :)
If he's gone though?
Dark times have arrived.
Giants have been very blessed to have solid QB's from the day they picked up Kerry Collins... man, it's been a long run! 19 years.
Before Collins, well there was Simms, and you really have to go all the way back to JFK and freakin' YA Tittle to find another Pro Bowl QB.
Ah, what we take for granted.
Quote:
to spend a young QB's non-vested time until we shore up the obvious OL problems. Do that, and it's time to bring in a young QB. Doing it before is just wasting years of his time. No QB can play behind the crap we've put out there the last several years. So until that time, I'd personally keep Eli. He proved to me this season he can still make all the throws, and run the team.
Basically, Fix the Trenches, then worry about a QB.
I agree. Giants probably 2 drafts away from competing for a playoff slot provided they find a QB.
This makes sense to me, too. I guess it doesn't necessarily have to dictate everything they do, especially if something unexpected occurs, but it's a factor they have to deal with.