Hypothetical: would you trade #6 overall for Wentz?

in a heartbeat

for Wentz.

Honestly, no - I don't think I would. I think he's going to be one of those guys who has a hard time staying on the field.

Plus, he's already 3 years into his rookie deal - so, we'd have to extend and pay him within a couple years which, again, is very risky.

I just don't trust him to hold up. Besides, I can't see NYG/PHI making this type of deal with each other. I know it's just hypothetical, but there's a much higher probability of the Giants just signing Nick Foles (which I'd hate, personally..)

.

Hypothetically, yes. My only question about Wentz is his durability.

I would rather see us draft our next QB.

would ask for more

I had a buddy of mine whose an Eagle fan say the price would be Saquon & 2 firsts for Wentz.

In comment 14262180 Sean said:

Quote:

I had a buddy of mine whose an Eagle fan say the price would be Saquon & 2 firsts for Wentz.

LOL in his dreams. If I'm trading Saquon *and* 2 firsts, I want a 24 year old Peyton Manning.

That's funny. It's like when Giants fans want two first rounders for Beckham. Crazy talk.

I would not trade that pick for Wentz. I'd rather just draft Haskins. And I don't love his game.

And yeah, the Eagles would absolutely want more from NYG than just 6 overall. They'd want more than that from an AFC team - so they'd really drive up the price for us, I'm sure.

Wentz was awesome last year before he got hurt - but this is two years in a row now he hasn't been able to finish the season. He has now missed 8 games in the last 2 years.

He's also a little older than the typical 3rd year rookie - he's already 26.

to ask for more than one first rounder for a known quantity at qb. even if injury prone.

will want TWO first rounders and more for Wentz

Guy is always hurt. He was great last year with a great running game and line against bad to mediocre competition.

......but I doubt either team would do it, more so the Eagles.

Simply because they could be seeing him in division for the next 10 years and that wouldn't sit well with anyone involved with the Eagles.............

You can give your divisional rivals a player that plays the most important position in sports, esp with his talent.

He’s on the Tony Romo career track.

arc does raise a good counter about his health.

But it would be worth the stretch. The guy is more athletic, fitter Ben Roethlisberger.

He was going to be the MVP last year. That’s not easy talent to find.

They would probably have looked to move Wentz. But not now. Wentz is their QB

And like Arc said, it would take way more than the sixth pick

In order for Philly to agree

And next years first

This years and next.

But that + saquon is too much IMO and I'm guessing their asking price would be 3 ones or the equivalent of

Trading Wentz to a division rival? What kind of happy horseshit is this delusional fantasy?

How about Bill Belichick for a signed Ernie Accorsi toupee?

Reality is a good place folks.

it’s not happening. and those saying no, the Giants would be so lucky.....

Never happen but I’d trade the house. At least 2 first round picks.

I don’t think he’s long for this league.

right after we get (3) 1st round picks for OBJ

if he was touched by the hand of God before answering.

However his medicals scream red flags. Would be a very risky move.

Not even a question. I'd even consider trading #6, and next years 1st for him.

Let's put it a different way. If Wentz was in this years draft and was available at #6, are you drafting him?

Eagles trade wentz to Raiders for multiple picks...Carr to Giants

I'm not even a Carr Fan|

Realistically, I believe Nick and Teddy B will be avaialable. I'd take Nick....I don't have any feel for Teddy.

The only reason I say that is his health. He has had 2 season ending injuries the last 2 years. The knee should be healed, but the back worries me. Nobody seems to come back from the back injuries 100%.

In comment 14262345 Natek212 said:

Quote:

Not even a question. I'd even consider trading #6, and next years 1st for him. Let's put it a different way. If Wentz was in this years draft and was available at #6, are you drafting him?

Not if he has a back injury.

Iggles would want and get much, much more. Like 2# 1s and 2 #2s.


Silly question.

In comment 14262395 Matt M. said:

Quote:

The only reason I say that is his health. He has had 2 season ending injuries the last 2 years. The knee should be healed, but the back worries me. Nobody seems to come back from the back injuries 100%.

Two words: Rob Gronkowski.


And TE is much more physically demanding than QB.

In comment 14262311 MookGiants said:

Quote:

if he was touched by the hand of God before answering.

he was touched by Ray Handley in the rest top parking lot

In comment 14262458 EricJ said:

Quote:

In comment 14262311 MookGiants said: Quote: if he was touched by the hand of God before answering. he was touched by Ray Handley in the rest top parking lot

I know your probably think that it was funny, but...it wasn’t.

Grow up

...for Wentz.

And then hold a very nice retirement party for Eli Manning.

In comment 14262180 Sean said:

Quote:

I had a buddy of mine whose an Eagle fan say the price would be Saquon & 2 firsts for Wentz.

Stopped reading after the tenth word

.

In the extremely remote chance they do decide to move Wentz, they are not trading him to the Giants. If you don't think there would be a line of suitors for Wentz, you are kidding yourself.

I get the injury thing, but I don't think it is predictive of the rest of his career. People said the same thing about Phil Simms early in his career. Wentz is a star, he can make throws Foles couldn't dream of making.