Just watch these highlights...I can't imagine having that type of player in blue...we've never had a guy like this...He flicks the ball 60 yards, and is so MF'ing fast..He is a game changer that when paired with SB, and OBJ....Engram, and Sterling...wow
That would be worth the price of admission, and our Offense would set records...I just don't think he can physically handle the NFL for more than a few seasons...but dammit if I'm not super intrigued by this kid
Kylar is a freak - (
New Window )
yeah, I imagine a bunch of those are actually sacks right? Isn't that how college counts those?
And had 378 or fewer his 3 other seasons. Also finished with a college comp% = 60.9% vs Murray's 67.4%.
Just a note, but sacks in college are considered rushing attempts, so that should put it into perspective that he ran fewer times than you think he did. It’s also amazing that he ran for 1000 yards on 140 attempts. He basically ran for 1100 yards on 120 attempts, assuming he was sacked 20 times for a loss of 100 yards.
By the way, Cutcliffe called running plays for Daniel Jones. A lot of them, actually. How many people here consider him a running QB?
And the Seahawks' offense got worse the more they threw the ball. They switched it back this year and got better.
But I don't see Wilson and Murray as similar players. Murray is much more explosive.
Quote:
had a season with 527 pass attempts
And the Seahawks' offense got worse the more they threw the ball. They switched it back this year and got better.
But I don't see Wilson and Murray as similar players. Murray is much more explosive.
He was talking about in college.
Interesting about Jones at Duke. In 2016 and 2017 he has more rushes than Murray did last year. Again, have to correct for sacks.
And regarding comps to Lamar Jackson. Jackson was a different type of player in college. He ran the ball quite a bit more than Murray did. 260 & 232 times his last two years. I'm a huge Jackson fan, but he can fairly be called a running QB. I don't think that applies to Murray.
Fun fact - he had 3 receptions while at Wisconsin
Quote:
In comment 14266759 FatMan in Charlotte said:
Quote:
had a season with 527 pass attempts
And the Seahawks' offense got worse the more they threw the ball. They switched it back this year and got better.
But I don't see Wilson and Murray as similar players. Murray is much more explosive.
He was talking about in college.
Sorry, my mistake.
Mayfield too, they're both thickly built guys. I'm not sure I see that with Murray, he's built like slot back. Does he have the frame to add 15-20 lbs? That's something they'll have to look at.
Even if you decide he's an injury risk and likely to miss some games, I don't think that should stop a team from drafting him early. There are plenty of QBs out there that are capable of holding down the fort for a handful of games - Foles and Keenum have turned that experience into big contracts. However, it's incredibly difficult to find QBs that can be true difference makers and elevate the team around them. If you decide Murray can be one of those guys, you take him because the upside far outweighs the risk.
It would be shocking to me if Murray did not succeed as a passer. Certainly, there is nothing to suggest that he can’t sling it - and do so accurately - at the next level. And that is what differentiates him from Vick and Jackson.
People complain about his slight build and argue that it puts him at risk of injury. But I don’t think that is true. Russell Wilson and Brees are the smallest QBs in the NFL, and they have been healthy with out issue (Brees got hurt early, but that was unrelated to height or build). Meanwhile some of the bigger QBs - Luck, Newton, Big Ben, Wentz - have missed significant time due to injury.
With the changing NFL, I don’t believe height is a predictor I’d anything. I believe it’s even less of a concern if he measures in at the height At which OU listed him.
As was pointed out to you in the other thread, build is not a predictor of injury. Slight or not
Last year I was repeatedly assured that slight Josh Rosen would be injured by the wind let aline an NFL player and he did not get injured yet the appropriately built Darnold did as did the "monster" Josh Allen, who i pointed out had a ling injury history already
You would think a fanbase that saw slender Eli become an "iron man" but not "Big Ben" would know this
Furthermore, basing a rookie year of staying healthy or being hurt isn't indicative of anything.
You can continue to reason away that being slight AND short isn't an issue.
I assure those who will make the selection or will pass will know it is an issue
Not saying he isn't good, in fact I'm very impressed with him and think he will be drafted before Haskins.
Just saying this is a better gauge of what you will get in the NFL. Link - ( New Window )
Based on the video, that was a solid performance.
If I had to go with Murray at 6 or trade up to get Tua next year, I’d rather just go with Murray and keep my assets. If it doesn’t work out, we can at least react to it a year sooner.
I know jobs are on the line and it doesn’t work that way, but I think he’s be electric with Barkley and Beckham, especially if we keep adding to the OL.
+1. This post makes a ton of sense.
Andrew Perloff
Andrew Perloff
@andrewperloff
"He’s the best athlete on the field and the smartest player on the field at the same time." - Oklahoma coach Lincoln Riley on Kyler Murray (
@dpshow
)
9:27 AM · Dec 3, 2018 · Twitter Web Client
I think his Wonderlic will be just fine
You’re kidding, right?
Link - ( New Window )
Link - ( New Window )
He was considered a top prospect in the 2015 MLB draft. He could have gone off and played baseball immediately out of high school and had a nice payday. Instead, he opts to go to college and play football.
Then, in 2018, he was selected with the #9 overall pick in the MLB draft and signed a $4.4M contract with the A's. He still decides he is willing to risk that by going to play a full season of D1 college football in the Big 12. So, he clearly loves the game of football! He barely played at all before the 2018 season and once he was drafted by an MLB team he could have just walked away from football and been a millionaire. Instead he played football just for the love of the game, and he went and won a Heisman trophy.
My point is this: If this kid already went out and played a full season of D1 football FOR FREE at the risk of getting injured and losing his baseball career (running around "undersized" and at risk of injuring his "slight frame"), why the hell would he now pass up MILLIONS OF DOLLARS in guaranteed money to play the sport he loves on the biggest stage of all? A first round pick, no less, and not to mention he plays the position he plays is far and away the most lucrative of all positions in the NFL.
I don't see this kid passing up on the sport he loves NOW,at this point, when he could make tons of money doing it, after he ALREADY has done it for free at the risk of losing his baseball $ and career. I don't buy the idea that he will be convinced that he's all of a sudden going to get injured (even though he's never been injured playing football) just because NFL defenders are so big and fast and scary. It's not about what anyone else says, it's about what he feels he's capable of doing, and from everything this kid has done I don't see him backing down now just to make the more conservative "business decision".
I am not sure what I think on how he will translate to the NFL, but he is not just a great runner, he throws a GREAT long ball. I would be both terrified and ecstatic at drafting him... lol
The Combine will tell all, but even Oklahoma's team website, and team websites are always known to be generous, only lists him at 5'10.
Quote:
He is not slight he is actually fairly muscular. I have seen people calling him 5'9 here and I don't think he is that short.
The Combine will tell all, but even Oklahoma's team website, and team websites are always known to be generous, only lists him at 5'10.
For sure, but just looking at him next to other players on his team I am thinking 5'10 seems likely correct. Anyway don't they list him at 5'11? He doesn't look much shorter to me than Russell Wilson or even Drew Brees. Wilson is definitely beefier though, especially in the legs.
Not sure what I think about drafting him though. Like I said I can totally see getting excited about drafting him.. but yeah his size does have to give you concern.
Quote:
In comment 14267822 Johnny5 said:
Quote:
He is not slight he is actually fairly muscular. I have seen people calling him 5'9 here and I don't think he is that short.
The Combine will tell all, but even Oklahoma's team website, and team websites are always known to be generous, only lists him at 5'10.
For sure, but just looking at him next to other players on his team I am thinking 5'10 seems likely correct. Anyway don't they list him at 5'11? He doesn't look much shorter to me than Russell Wilson or even Drew Brees. Wilson is definitely beefier though, especially in the legs.
Not sure what I think about drafting him though. Like I said I can totally see getting excited about drafting him.. but yeah his size does have to give you concern.
They list him at 5'11", yes. Baker Mayfield is 6'1" and seeing them stand next to each other I don't see a huge height difference. There is no way Baker is 4 inches taller than Murray, NO WAY. My prediction is Murray will measure at 5'10" and change, no shorter than 5'10" even, though.
That RPO would just be insane. Saquon would rush for 2000 yards.
Coming out of the first with Devin White and Kylar Murray would be amazing.
Coming out of the first with Devin White and Kylar Murray would be amazing.
As much as I would love that, we need an OL with 1 of the first 2 picks. Of course maybe FA we get a player or 2 and that thinking changes. I do think the Giants have to come away with either Haskins or Murray in this draft.
To be honest. I wouldn't mind going Murray at 6 and RT in the second. I think that would turn this team around.
2) If they don't keep him in the pocket and he runs, he will frequently get tackled by one or more 300 lb. guys
3) Even if he stays healthy and mostly runs to extend plays and throw, he may still decide to play a sport where 300lb guys don't keep trying to knock him down.
2) If they don't keep him in the pocket and he runs, he will frequently get tackled by one or more 300 lb. guys
3) Even if he stays healthy and mostly runs to extend plays and throw, he may still decide to play a sport where 300lb guys don't keep trying to knock him down.
1.) is a bit of a reach NFL is all about throwing lanes, no defense just rushes side by side with their arms up. Eli is 6'4 and has multiple balls batted down. If Murray has the ability to feel pressure and slide to open lanes he'll be fine. Brees and Wilson are great at that.
2 and 3.) This is where smarts come in, getting down and running out of bounds will be important. Is Murray able to understand this or will he always attempt to take unnecessary hits.
The talent is there, the guy can flat out play football, this isn't a gaudy stat QB without NFL ability. Besides size Murray can make every NFL throw.
The number of them who are bucking the odds and succeeding in the NFL despite being too short or slight in very small.
Murray often runs after his first read. Not sure how that checks the boxes off.
Pass...
I definitely don’t think round one. Round two feels closer, but still a stretch.
Maybe round three?
Pass...
Same here.
Somehow I just can't see DG who loves his Hog Mollies in the trenches, liking a player of Murray's stature leading his offense.
Quote:
If you can read defenses, have great pocket awareness, and make throws, you will succeed.
Murray often runs after his first read. Not sure how that checks the boxes off.
No I realize it's difficult if the Giants scouting department feel Murray can do all the things I mentioned, I would not hesitate to pick him due to his size. Obviously it's a good debate size vs skill. I think he can make the read and the throws. It wasn't like Oklahoma had some small line he could see over, they averaged 6'5. To me Murray is a slightly smaller Mayfield with better speed and no off the field antics. But, time will tell.
The number of them who are bucking the odds and succeeding in the NFL despite being too short or slight in very small.
Yeah but you forgot something. The number of guys who played NCAA football at the level Kyler Murray played at last year you could count on the fingers of one or at most two hands. He wasn't just GOOD at NCAA level ball. His size won't be the issue IMO.
His body didn't hold up. I see the same thing happening to Murray, would not draft him.