the highest leverage situations for a matter of a couple seconds. He hit two iconic kicks on the road to send his team to the Super Bowl where they ended up winning both.
He doesn't make those kicks, the Giants don't win either game.
the highest leverage situations for a matter of a couple seconds. He hit two iconic kicks on the road to send his team to the Super Bowl where they ended up winning both.
He doesn't make those kicks, the Giants don't win either game.
So, yes. He's in, imo.
He missed the first two in GB, if you recall.
Yes he his kick put them in, but...
Hostetler is another guy that absolutely should be on it Â
that a ROH is based om career accomplishments. Hoss had
a moment as a Giant, yep it culminated in a SB, much appreciated...ROH, I think not. What else did he do with
the NYG? That is not how a ROH works, nor should it be.
That's not a career accomplishment? That's potentially less valuable than playing 10 years and winning nothing?
That was great moment, but it takes more than that for
a ROH, that's how it works. It is an overall career, not a great moment.
Moment? It wasn't just one great play like making a clutch kick.
He led them through the playoffs and was a SB winning QB having some great moments along the way, Without him the Giants have one less Lombardi and that's why they play, to win it all.
That run and SB win are what makes him worthy of being honored IMO.
That's not a career accomplishment? That's potentially less valuable than playing 10 years and winning nothing?
That was great moment, but it takes more than that for
a ROH, that's how it works. It is an overall career, not a great moment.
Moment? It wasn't just one great play like making a clutch kick.
He led them through the playoffs and was a SB winning QB having some great moments along the way, Without him the Giants have one less Lombardi and that's why they play, to win it all.
That run and SB win are what makes him worthy of being honored IMO.
.
A moment is a figure of speech, I forget the age gaps on
here, not literally a moment. I am saying a few games,
that culminated in a SB win is not worthy of ROH.
If he had done something with the Giants either before or
after that particular SB as a Giant, that would be a different scenario. The fact is he didn't, after the SB, left in free agency to the Raiders, and prior, he did nothing. I view a ROH on a distinguished career overall.
I believe that's how the Giants organization looks at it as well. You can disagree folks if you like.
As I said above, it was much appreciated what he did.
Hoss is a great, great call.
We should put fucking Matt Stover in the ring of honor
He doesn't make those kicks, the Giants don't win either game.
So, yes. He's in, imo.
Quote:
Shockey, Joe Morris, Jumbo Elliot and Jeff Hostetler
Hoss is a great, great call.
Shockey isn't
No to all these and definitely no to Tynes. But loved Hoss.
What is this a 3rd grade town recreation league where every kid gets a trophy by participating...
He doesn't make those kicks, the Giants don't win either game.
So, yes. He's in, imo.
He missed the first two in GB, if you recall.
Yes he his kick put them in, but...
Agreed 100%.
I'm not sure how he isn't already.
a moment as a Giant, yep it culminated in a SB, much appreciated...ROH, I think not. What else did he do with
the NYG? That is not how a ROH works, nor should it be.
That was great moment, but it takes more than that for
a ROH, that's how it works. It is an overall career, not a great moment.
Quote:
That's not a career accomplishment? That's potentially less valuable than playing 10 years and winning nothing?
.
That was great moment, but it takes more than that for
a ROH, that's how it works. It is an overall career, not a great moment.
That's how it works? Says who?
Quote:
That's not a career accomplishment? That's potentially less valuable than playing 10 years and winning nothing?
That was great moment, but it takes more than that for
a ROH, that's how it works. It is an overall career, not a great moment.
Moment? It wasn't just one great play like making a clutch kick.
He led them through the playoffs and was a SB winning QB having some great moments along the way, Without him the Giants have one less Lombardi and that's why they play, to win it all.
That run and SB win are what makes him worthy of being honored IMO.
Quote:
In comment 14282245 Go Terps said:
Quote:
That's not a career accomplishment? That's potentially less valuable than playing 10 years and winning nothing?
That was great moment, but it takes more than that for
a ROH, that's how it works. It is an overall career, not a great moment.
Moment? It wasn't just one great play like making a clutch kick.
He led them through the playoffs and was a SB winning QB having some great moments along the way, Without him the Giants have one less Lombardi and that's why they play, to win it all.
That run and SB win are what makes him worthy of being honored IMO.
A moment is a figure of speech, I forget the age gaps on
here, not literally a moment. I am saying a few games,
that culminated in a SB win is not worthy of ROH.
If he had done something with the Giants either before or
after that particular SB as a Giant, that would be a different scenario. The fact is he didn't, after the SB, left in free agency to the Raiders, and prior, he did nothing. I view a ROH on a distinguished career overall.
I believe that's how the Giants organization looks at it as well. You can disagree folks if you like.
As I said above, it was much appreciated what he did.
Good players don’t qualify, Great players do. Longevity must be factor as well