1) Phil Simms 2) Ron Johnson 3) Harry Carson 4) Rob Carpenter ...
I'm gonna have to think about #5. LT, Joe Morris, Tiki... I liked Bob Tucker and Tarkenton when I was a kid... Eli, Bavaro... and those three receivers whose careers were too short: Steve Smith, Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz. Hmm
#1 - LT of course. The best I ever saw.
#2 - Tuck. A monster. Fuck Flozell Adams btw.
#3 - Tiki. Really was a horse his last 3 yrs. Carried them.
#4 - Shockey. Brought attitude and a monster game w him.
#5 - Cruz. 2011 alone was magical. The SF game. OMG.
When one stops to think about it the Giants have had in incredible number of tough heroic players over the past 30 years. The fans really don't appreciate the the success this franchise has enjoyed compared to most others.
2. LT
3. Bradshaw
4. Bavaro
5. Armstead
LT
Strahan
Bavaro
Justin Tuck
Eli
Cruz
Hampton
Armstead
**LT was awesome but he was winding down when I followed so closely.
I'm gonna have to think about #5. LT, Joe Morris, Tiki... I liked Bob Tucker and Tarkenton when I was a kid... Eli, Bavaro... and those three receivers whose careers were too short: Steve Smith, Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz. Hmm
2. Mark Collins (who i am getting to know now)
3 Eli Manning
4 Phil Simms
5. Carl Banks
2. LT
3. Strahan
4. Toomer
5. Mckenzie
Simms
Eli
Bavaro
2-LT
3-Erich Barnes
4-Spider Lockhart
5a-Frank Gifford
5b-Tittle
Howard cross
Eli
Bavaro
...and the usual suspects
2) Mark Bavaro
3) Phil Simms
4) Bob Tucker
5) Ron Johnson
Simms
LT
Carson
Strahan
#2 - Tuck. A monster. Fuck Flozell Adams btw.
#3 - Tiki. Really was a horse his last 3 yrs. Carried them.
#4 - Shockey. Brought attitude and a monster game w him.
#5 - Cruz. 2011 alone was magical. The SF game. OMG.
#3 Homer Jones
#4 Joe Morris
#5 Dave Meggett
80s: LT
90s: Jessie Armstead
00s: Michael Strahan
10s: Eli Manning
Armstead
Jacobs
Rolle
2. Tiki
3. Jacobs
4. Shockey
5. Barkley
Loved watching the LT the player, but I can't put a child rapist on a pedestal. It is sickening to me to see fans parade around in their LT jersey.
Next 5 would probably be Hampton, Jacobs, Toomer, Armstead, and Jacobs.
1) Phil Simms
2) Rob Carpenter
3) Jessie Armstead
4) Ottis Anderson
5) Rodney Hampton
I can envision Saquon Barkley up there one day.
2)Eli
3)Strahan
4)Simms
5)Bavaro
5a)Barkley - hopefully #1 someday
Bavaro - Silent killer
Strahan - Smile and passion for the game
Jumbo Elliot - name alone
Saquon - Gives hope where little has been
Jacobs
Will Allen (hung out a couple times....great guy)
Jeff Hostetler
Jonas Seawright 😂
3. Simms
4. Tuck
5. Snee
Strahan
Sehorn
Barnes
LT
Armstead
Tiki
Jacobs
Might be different now because Tiki turned out to be kind of a douche. But he was awesome 2000-2006, and I sure as shit routed for him then!
Simms
Banks
Bavaro
Eli
#1 Eli
#2 Carson
#3 Tuck
#4 and #5: Some combination of LT, Strahan, Van Pelt, Jacobs, Bavaro, and some days Osi
Before too long, I think Barkley will be on this list.
Saquon could rise to 1a alongside LT very soon
2) Frank Gifford
3) Mark Bavaro
4) Joe Morrison
5) Eli Manning
5b)Sam Huff
My others: LT, Simms, Eli, YA. Hard to leave so many guys off; Bavaro, Spider, Snee, Carson, Strahan, Rocky Thompson.
2. Brandon Jacobs
3. David Tyree
4. Eli Manning
5. Tied between Antonio Pierce/Shaun O'Hara
2. Eli
3. Strahan
4. Bavaro
5. Saquon (Yes already one of my favorites)
Simms
LT
Banks
Tyree (I hope this fucking guy lives 1,000 years of a happy life)
2. Bavaro
3. Rosey Brown - best tackle in Giants history
4. Charley Connely - original Ole Miss QB
5. Strahan