What do you think the Giants do at #6?
IMO its gonna come down to three guys. Josh Allen, Clelin Ferrell, and Montez Sweat. In that order. Whichever of these guys is available at #6 will probably be the pick.
I also see the 2nd round pick being a DB. At CB I like Amani Oruwariye, Joejuan Williams, and Julian Love.
At S I like Deionte Thompson, Juan Thornhill, and Chauncey Gardner-Johnson.
I see them picking up a OL in the 4th/5th rounds like Dru Samia as I think they make one splash signing on the OL in FA (Daryl Williams) and roll with Halapio and Brown at C and RG.
Doubt the Giants go CB in the 2nd. Odds are it will be OL or another DL if a talented guy slips.
J Bosa - V Likely Gone By 6
Q Williams - V Likely Gone By 6
J Allen - V Likely Gone By 6
So one of :
G Williams
R Gary
D White
J Williams
J Taylor
C Ferrell
Ill guess J Williams, who will play RG or C due to short arms.
Round 2 will be OL. I think we take 3 OL's in this draft!
If Allen Bosa or Q Williams are there then you pick one. Guys like Ferrell Wilkins Sweat Greedy all have question marks like Haskins but play positions that are deep in this year's draft.
White is my dark horse given our need and he's flashed at least as much as the other names on this thread.
DH has a good arm and all signs point to elite mental processing and leadership. Don't overthink it we need someone to learn from Eli and we aren't a contender this year or next but are a threat to end up with the 20th pick next year and the only way to move up that far without trading the tops of MULTIPLE drafts would be moving OBJ.
Who HATES to lose? Who grinds it out play after play? Who never gives up and gives it their all? Who brings an "attitude" to their position? That is who the Giants will draft.
I'm not up on the college draft but I know that whoever the Giants draft, they will bring these qualities to the table.
Who is that person?
I thought Kuechly was drafted the year before DG took over as the Panthers GM. I'm pretty sure you are mistaken.
2 years? Is Lauletta your projected starter in 2020?
My guess is that we take Christian Wilkins.
I think Wilkins is exactly the type of guy that both Bettcher and Gettleman like.
Wilkins may not be as flashy as some of the other guys, but he is very experienced, disruptive, versatile with excellent intangibles. I think Bettcher could use him in a similar way to how he used Calais Campell.
Wilkins toolset complements Tomlinson and Hill nicely. I could see Gettleman pulling the trigger on Wilkins at 6 if we stay put.
Rashan Gary
Jonah Williams
Not sure the order, yet....
Haskins
Bosa
Allen
The next Group of guys may or may not be around:
G Williams
Q Williams
Oliver
White
Ferrell
I believe the Giants take the best pass rusher that is left of this bunch. For arguments sake, I'm saying that is going to be Quinnen Williams.
My guess is that we take Christian Wilkins.
I think Wilkins is exactly the type of guy that both Bettcher and Gettleman like.
Wilkins may not be as flashy as some of the other guys, but he is very experienced, disruptive, versatile with excellent intangibles. I think Bettcher could use him in a similar way to how he used Calais Campell.
Wilkins toolset complements Tomlinson and Hill nicely. I could see Gettleman pulling the trigger on Wilkins at 6 if we stay put.
Pete,
You forgot to mention Christian's favorite role: Fullback! The NYG need help at the goal line and it would be fantastic to see the second coming of Clemson's Refrigerator Perry! (smile)
In all seriousness, I think he would be a great addition for the intangibles, especially if the Giants traded back a few slots and CW dropped. Not likely, but.....
Not only is BPA Gettleman's core philosophy, it's pretty much what he's been saying he's gonna do: Pick the BPA. Fix the Defense. Connect those two concepts, and there you are.
Sure, he'll listen to offers. But I doubt he'll move unless the offer is unreal. He's gonna have some very good, players available at 6, and my guess is that he'd rather have one blue-chipper than two red-chips.
I don't think he'll take Haskins or any QB at 6 (and I hope he doesn't). If he wanted to reach for a QB, he could have done that last year from a far better class, and he didn't.
Unlike the fans and the media, I don't think DG's even remotely worrying about getting a QB in this draft.
People seem to forget he drafted one last year, just not early. And if it wasn't early, it didn't happen. To fans and media, Kyle Lauletta doesn't exist. To the Giants, he's a young guy who now has a year in the system. Doesn't mean Lauletta is the answer or the eventually successor, but they don't need the successor THIS YEAR.
Further, it'd be recklessly stupid to play a rookie QB until they fix the OL, anyway.
1. Josh Allen
2. Dwayne Haskins
3. Clelin Ferrell
4. Drew Lock
5. Montez Sweat
There is a possibility that either Oliver or Gary could be the guy because the 5 Tech position is usually considers a pass rush position in the 3-4.
I would love Allen but to me he will be gone. I think Haskins is a very good prospect.
A trade up for Haskins (👎🏽)
Gary
White
Oliver
If Haskins isn't an option I think it's Gary. Also fits the prototype on the otherside.
If he's gone, I would not be shocked if they selected TJ Hockenson.
I think what they do in free agency may have a major influence this year, it had no influence last year by comparison.
Haskins is the perfect candidate to sit and learn for the whole season or even 7-10 games similar to what Goff did in 2016. There are merits to starting right away, but you also see what good it can do to sit and learn for a bit. This team isn't ready to win a Super Bowl next year.
If Gettleman doesn't settle the question of the successor to Manning, he's going to hear about it after every loss, every Interception, every incomplete pass.
This is New York. You can't let the big stuff fester.
vs
WASH Rose Bowl
comp-att yds TD Rating QBR
W 28-23 25-37 253 67.6% 3 151.3 79.0
NW Championship
W 45-24 34-41 499 82.9% 5 220.5 93.8
Rivalry MICH
W 62-39 20-31 396 64.5% 6 235.7 97.5
I think they fall in love with physical tools and big game performances.
That's a remote thrower for me
Quote:
.
That's a remote thrower for me
Likewise.
Hes actually my least liked QB in a class I loathe as a whole. Needless to say, I would be monumentally disappointed.
2. Haskins is taken before we pick
3. Murray is completely off our board before the draft even starts
4. We're left picking between Jones and Lock, and Jones is considered the safer pick and closest to Eli 2.0
What I'd like to see is the Giants take a chance on Kyler Murray. Really swing for the fences with the immense upside.
2. Haskins is taken before we pick
3. Murray is completely off our board before the draft even starts
4. We're left picking between Jones and Lock, and Jones is considered the safer pick and closest to Eli 2.0
I odn't think it's easy to envision.
There Giants had every opportunity to reach for a QB last year and did not. There is nothing in DG's statements or history to suggest that he would reach, and especially to a low tier prospect, this year. Your cynicism has you turning your fantasy into (what should be a qualified) prediction.
Quote:
1. Jones performs well at the Combine and pro day
2. Haskins is taken before we pick
3. Murray is completely off our board before the draft even starts
4. We're left picking between Jones and Lock, and Jones is considered the safer pick and closest to Eli 2.0
I odn't think it's easy to envision.
There Giants had every opportunity to reach for a QB last year and did not. There is nothing in DG's statements or history to suggest that he would reach, and especially to a low tier prospect, this year. Your cynicism has you turning your fantasy into (what should be a qualified) prediction.
QBs tend to shoot up boards as drafts approach. And if we don't go QB, then who? Are there 3-4 edge rushers that make sense high in this draft?
Quote:
In comment 14296628 Go Terps said:
Quote:
1. Jones performs well at the Combine and pro day
2. Haskins is taken before we pick
3. Murray is completely off our board before the draft even starts
4. We're left picking between Jones and Lock, and Jones is considered the safer pick and closest to Eli 2.0
I odn't think it's easy to envision.
There Giants had every opportunity to reach for a QB last year and did not. There is nothing in DG's statements or history to suggest that he would reach, and especially to a low tier prospect, this year. Your cynicism has you turning your fantasy into (what should be a qualified) prediction.
QBs tend to shoot up boards as drafts approach. And if we don't go QB, then who? Are there 3-4 edge rushers that make sense high in this draft?
Based on the rankings so far and the mock drafts...yes.
We've seen reports that they want Eli to mentor the next QB. If this is Eli's last season, and they don't believe in Lauletta, it probably increases the likelihood of a QB being taken. Maybe that means a QB in the second round (my preferred route if a QB has to be taken in this draft), but QBs always move up as the draft approaches.
My best guess is that Giants will take next highest value position and pick QB at #6. Both Haskins and Murray played well in big college programs, but Giants generally put more stock on combine and player interviews to determine who they like. My only hope is they avoid picking some brainiac like Dave Brown and go for someone more battle-tested like Eli. Getting a young core of talent on offense can sustain teams in long run, but only if the QB is at peak performance. I like Murray's athleticism but my thought is Giants will be conservative and take Haskins.
They need a pass rush.
I like Allen and Ferrell. But I gotta say, when you watch Polite he looks like a freak with his quick first step and rip move. I don't think he is worth the 6th pick.
They need a pass rush.
The draft is for the future. Jenkins won't be here forever. Take him out of the mix and our CB stable is trash. Beal is an unknown. Do we settle for the 4th best Edge rusher or the best CB? Same question can apply to OL. It needs to be fixed. Take a flyer on Daryl Williams who spent last year on IR with a busted knee? Rely on a reputation of DG finding late round gems and consequently relying on the Giants developing that gem when we haven't been able to develop any lineman in the past decade? Or do you continue to build the OL with young, healthy, fundamentally sound technician that is rated as the best? Or should we still settle for the 4th rated highest Edge?
And then they trade up from round 2 and draft Daniel jones mid to late round 1.
this only works if you truly feel the team can win with Eli, I don't, Eli is just draining money from the team ..
That gives us shot at one of top 5 players, not a QB. Pretty confident Williams & Evans will be gone, Maybe Oliver. Think Ferrell will be gone too - somebody grabbin him as 4-3 DE.
Edge because some guys can play both 4-3 DE and 3-4 OLB.
Khalil Mack comes to mind as having played both.
Quote:
It being either Haskins or Lock. My dark horse pick is Devin White out of LSU. He has literally no weaknesses to his game, can fit in any scheme. Hes Luke kuechly 2.0 and Im almost sure it was DG who drafted kuechly if Im not mistaken
I thought Kuechly was drafted the year before DG took over as the Panthers GM. I'm pretty sure you are mistaken.
Yes I like White at #6. With Tomlinson and B.J. Hill having good years in 2018 the LB'ing core needs to be upgraded. If Josh Allen is sitting there then I'd pick him otherwise White's a great pick.
Haskins reminds me of Cardale Jones. I'm not taking a QB that played only 1 year at #6. Murray, Jones, Lock all have 2+ years of experience. Murray is a shorter version of Baker Mayfield but only more dangerous in the run game. Murray brings more to the table then Haskins.
Jones is probably the favorite because he was coach by Cuttlif who coached both Mannings in College. That's a big plus.
I didn't warm up to any of the QBs last year -- but Haskins has a bunch of things going for him that the big three last year didn't
He's strong -- I mean really strong. He has a great physical, mental, and mature presence. He shows up big in big time games. He stands tall in the pocket and makes strikes when he's got someone coming at him. He has terrific will power that shows in some plays like the play Eli made in getting out of the grasp and getting the ball to Tyree in Super Bowl 42. He also gets the ball out fast, decisively and accurately. He spreads the ball around. He's got both power and can make a screen pass work. I like him.
If the Giants really like Haskins then they have to move up this year to get him - imo
I'm hoping for one of Bosa, Quinnen, Kyler or Haskins.
I didn't warm up to any of the QBs last year -- but Haskins has a bunch of things going for him that the big three last year didn't
He's strong -- I mean really strong. He has a great physical, mental, and mature presence. He shows up big in big time games. He stands tall in the pocket and makes strikes when he's got someone coming at him. He has terrific will power that shows in some plays like the play Eli made in getting out of the grasp and getting the ball to Tyree in Super Bowl 42. He also gets the ball out fast, decisively and accurately. He spreads the ball around. He's got both power and can make a screen pass work. I like him.
If the Giants really like Haskins then they have to move up this year to get him - imo
I've warmed up to Haskins too. But only to the extent that if he gets picked at #6, I won't retch. I still prefer to go for elite talent, which will only be DL at that spot. It's not only a need but also a strategy to build a team by getting the best players with the idea that next year, even with an uncomfortable package in trade, we can get a better QB that can slip right in because the supporting cast will be in place.
The reports last year from almost all the 'plugged-in' reporters all kept pointing away from QB. And many pointed toward Barkley. They were right. This team generally doesn't go heavy playing the misdirection game. This year we are hearing quite a few reports from the plugged in guys saying they WILL go after a Qb and likely via the draft.
If Foles goes to the Jags (they probably want a vet because they think their team is close to a legit contender) then the legit competition for a Qb dies down even more. And then add in the Broncos at 10 trading for Flacco. Though this isnt last years draft we are in pretty good shape at 6 to get one of these guys. Now of course with the premium on the position we could see a team willing to sell the farm to move into the top 5 but the Giants at #6 could also be willing to offer their better pick to move up to make sure they get their QB.
Quote:
I'm warming up to Haskins
I didn't warm up to any of the QBs last year -- but Haskins has a bunch of things going for him that the big three last year didn't
He's strong -- I mean really strong. He has a great physical, mental, and mature presence. He shows up big in big time games. He stands tall in the pocket and makes strikes when he's got someone coming at him. He has terrific will power that shows in some plays like the play Eli made in getting out of the grasp and getting the ball to Tyree in Super Bowl 42. He also gets the ball out fast, decisively and accurately. He spreads the ball around. He's got both power and can make a screen pass work. I like him.
If the Giants really like Haskins then they have to move up this year to get him - imo
I've warmed up to Haskins too. But only to the extent that if he gets picked at #6, I won't retch. I still prefer to go for elite talent, which will only be DL at that spot. It's not only a need but also a strategy to build a team by getting the best players with the idea that next year, even with an uncomfortable package in trade, we can get a better QB that can slip right in because the supporting cast will be in place.
Great year for DE in FA. I see us going after a vet guy or two for Bettcher. We infused some young talent last year with Hill and Carter now bring in some vets. This is not to say we won't go DL in the draft but I do think it's QB as Plan A in round 1.
Link - ( New Window )