Ok, so which QB do we want to draft this year

No thanks to the rest.

At least to me..:)

I personally like Drew Lock the most, but there is nobody that I would take at 6 or 17 with the quality at DL/EDGE/LB/OL in the draft. If he fell to Round 2 (like what happened with Geno Smith), it would be a different story.

is the only one I want in the first round. Third round I would not mind Ryan Finley.

build up the lines and get one of the QBs next year.

He is over Lock, but I do not like him as much as Mayfield or Darnold from last year's class.

none

.

In comment 14333058 Mike in NY said:

Quote:

I personally like Drew Lock the most, but there is nobody that I would take at 6 or 17 with the quality at DL/EDGE/LB/OL in the draft. If he fell to Round 2 (like what happened with Geno Smith), it would be a different story.

Not suggesting, but would you (or anyone else here) give a 17 for Russell Wilson?

But either of these in the second...Finley or Grier (assuming Lock and Haskins are gone in round one).

I wouldn't touch Daniel Jones at all. I've really soured on him.

I'm finding Thorson and Stidham more and more interesting.

I don't really know how good he is and I don't think there are more than a few here who really know either way. He can sling the rock for sure.

In comment 14333069 Big Blue '56 said:

Quote:

In comment 14333058 Mike in NY said: Quote: I personally like Drew Lock the most, but there is nobody that I would take at 6 or 17 with the quality at DL/EDGE/LB/OL in the draft. If he fell to Round 2 (like what happened with Geno Smith), it would be a different story. Not suggesting, but would you (or anyone else here) give a 17 for Russell Wilson?

That is a tough one for me. His intelligence and ability to avoid hits makes me think he can last longer than other running QB's. My biggest concern is the contract figure. Will he do well enough to justify using that high of a percentage of the cap?

In comment 14333069 Big Blue '56 said:

Quote:

In comment 14333058 Mike in NY said: Quote: I personally like Drew Lock the most, but there is nobody that I would take at 6 or 17 with the quality at DL/EDGE/LB/OL in the draft. If he fell to Round 2 (like what happened with Geno Smith), it would be a different story. Not suggesting, but would you (or anyone else here) give a 17 for Russell Wilson?

In about two seconds! A pro bowl QB seems like a good investment for #17.

since Murray won't be possible without a major premium.

Lock acceptable too.

Not drafting one of these guys (or not getting Rosen) would be a 7.0 on the Richter Scale.

Drafting any other QB, particularly Daniel Jones with either 1st rounder would be an 8.0.

-

Haskins at #6, but I would prefer an edge rusher.

I’d love Murray or Haskins, but our idiotic front office is apparently going to sign Eli to an extension.

No one with any honesty ca assure me Haskins and Murray are true Franchise guys.

There are 3 to 5 true franchise guys in the NFL. IMO. Mitch Trubisky will most likely play in same amount of Superbowls as I have. That term is so Watered down its sad. Nick Foles won a Super Bowl and still the urban legend you can’t win without picking a guy in top 5 of RD 1 lives in and on.

I'm hurling the proverbial remote

I'm terrified at the idea of Haskins at #6 or Jones/Lock at #17 or #37

Start running the Ravens's offense. Who do you want to tackle TJax, Barkley, or E. Penny? haha half kidding

or no one.

No Reaching

but his conditioning level at the combine was somewhat of a concern.

Threw it beautifully though.

Wait for next spring.

If they do though. I would want Lock or Grier (if he is there at 17)

Then sign Gardner Minshew as a street walk on and see if he has the stuff to be a pro QB and not just another product of Mike Leach's system.

and wouldn't be surprised if we didn't, I personally like Jones. If he fell to us in the 2nd, I'd be elated.

I prefer tall, pocket QB's with a giant football brain. There cannot be enough said about the importance of a cerebral gift to that game of football. Athleticism is nice, but the problem with that is it's too easy for them to ditch the mental aspect of the high speed chess game and take off on their own. Those players are short lived for taking too many hits.

With a great offensive line, a 6'4" or 6'5" pocket QB can destroy a defense. Just my take on things.

I believe our first round picks need to be making a haul of this stacked defensive draft. The defensive studs will be well picked over by round 2

I think is the guy DG wants. just no to Haskins at all.

In comment 14333068 Bold Ruler said:

Quote:

.

Same here.

In comment 14333713 BigBlueCane said:

Quote:

I think is the guy DG wants. just no to Haskins at all.

Your obsession of Jones is getting close to Milton's for Rosen.

I have settled on him as my annual QB flyer.

In comment 14333364 Scott in Montreal said:

Quote:

If they do though. I would want Lock or Grier (if he is there at 17) Then sign Gardner Minshew as a street walk on and see if he has the stuff to be a pro QB and not just another product of Mike Leach's system.

Shit, I'd sign up for Minshew and replacing Shurmur with Leach.

In comment 14333068 Bold Ruler said:

Quote:

.

^This.

b/c he fits the model of what Mara is looking for.

Kyle Shurmur

Daniel Jones.

.

Nada

Eli is the QB for 2019 for better or worse, and worse gets the Giants a better draft in 2020.

In comment 14333965 adambear said:

Quote:

Daniel Jones.

If they draft Dave Brown II higher than the third round I'm switching to the goddamn Eagles or something.

In comment 14333965 adambear said:

Quote:

Daniel Jones.

Oh, dear God.

.

.

Because why keep a HOF receiver when your newly drafted QB can throw to Russell Sheppard?

Then waiting to see who among the QBs falls to 95 or even later. Grier? Stidham?

Personally Id take Haskins or Lock at 6 and be done with it.