2019 New York Giants mock draft

Unfortunately Bosa, Allen, Quinnen & Gary were gone.

In comment 14335343 Big Rick in FL said:

Quote:

Unfortunately Bosa, Allen, Quinnen & Gary were gone.

And Murray won't be gone? Good job except Murray won't be there and I wouldn't draft the RB at 132 - I'd load up on oline and throw a center in there somewhere.

In comment 14335345 section125 said:
[quote] In comment 14335343 Big Rick in FL said:


Quote:


Unfortunately Bosa, Allen, Quinnen & Gary were gone.



And Murray won't be gone? Good job except Murray won't be there and I wouldn't draft the RB at 132 - I'd load up on oline and throw a center in there somewhere. [/quote

Well it's a simulated draft and he was still there. So at that point he has to be considered BPA.

I think the value on Rodney Anderson is too good to pass up at that point. He's got first round talent, but he got injured his final season in college. Also with the news coming out that the Giants want to run the ball more they are going to need someone to spell Saquon. I know we have Gallman, but that was a Reese pick. So if the Giants replaced him I wouldn't be surprised.

Offense with the first three picks when our defense is absolute trash?

In comment 14335353 Keaton028 said:

Quote:

Offense with the first three picks when our defense is absolute trash?

Value wasn't there and I'm not going to take defensive players just for the sake of it. All 3 of those positions are just as big of needs as the defense is.

In comment 14335352 Big Rick in FL said:

Quote:

Well it's a simulated draft and he was still there. So at that point he has to be considered BPA. I think the value on Rodney Anderson is too good to pass up at that point. He's got first round talent, but he got injured his final season in college. Also with the news coming out that the Giants want to run the ball more they are going to need someone to spell Saquon. I know we have Gallman, but that was a Reese pick. So if the Giants replaced him I wouldn't be surprised.

I'm pretty certain Gallman stays. He looked very good spelling Barkley. But I guess you need 3 RBs in addition to Penny.
Still think DG drafts a bunch of OL with those 4ths and 5ths.
Sooooo many holes, so few picks.

Anyway, DG will fix the oline as he said he would and since he pointedly said the defense is awful, you can bet he gets at least two guys to get after the QB, whether it is a DE or OLB.

In comment 14335357 section125 said:

Quote:

In comment 14335352 Big Rick in FL said: Quote: Well it's a simulated draft and he was still there. So at that point he has to be considered BPA. I think the value on Rodney Anderson is too good to pass up at that point. He's got first round talent, but he got injured his final season in college. Also with the news coming out that the Giants want to run the ball more they are going to need someone to spell Saquon. I know we have Gallman, but that was a Reese pick. So if the Giants replaced him I wouldn't be surprised. I'm pretty certain Gallman stays. He looked very good spelling Barkley. But I guess you need 3 RBs in addition to Penny. Still think DG drafts a bunch of OL with those 4ths and 5ths. Sooooo many holes, so few picks. Anyway, DG will fix the oline as he said he would and since he pointedly said the defense is awful, you can bet he gets at least two guys to get after the QB, whether it is a DE or OLB.

Yeah there are a ton of holes. Luckily we have 12 picks. I'm so used to having 6-7 picks. This draft should be a big help in assembling a good roster.

Or Haskins? Or White?

Was Khalen Saunders available at the slot you took Wise?

I like Samuel at 37, and don't know enough about the rest, really.

to take an OG at 17. One position the Giants DON'T need.

You might link the site so others can try?

I do about 2 mocks a week.

In comment 14335410 BlueLou'sBack said:

Quote:

to take an OG at 17. One position the Giants DON'T need. You might link the site so others can try?

Link - ( New Window )

In comment 14335410 BlueLou'sBack said:

Quote:

to take an OG at 17. One position the Giants DON'T need. You might link the site so others can try?

I think Cody Ford is a RT and that's why I drafted him.

In comment 14335473 Big Rick in FL said:

Quote:

In comment 14335410 BlueLou'sBack said: Quote: to take an OG at 17. One position the Giants DON'T need. You might link the site so others can try? I think Cody Ford is a RT and that's why I drafted him.

I agree. He did say teams asked about his play inside. Some sites view him as a guard, that is why it says IOL.

6


Montez Sweat

, EDGE
Mississippi State

17


Devin Bush Jr.

, LB
Michigan

37


Dexter Lawrence

, IDL
Clemson

95


Daniel Jones

, QB
Duke

108


Justice Hill

, RB
Oklahoma State

132


David Sills V

, WR
West Virginia

142


Chuma Edoga

, OT
USC

143


Stanley Morgan Jr.

, WR
Nebraska

171


Saivion Smith

, CB
Alabama

180


Isaiah Prince

, OT Ohio State

232


Lil' Jordan Humphrey

, WR
Texas

245


Mitch Hyatt

, OT
Clemson

.

Giants just need to get best available player. Really hope we get a passrusher at first though

In comment 14335532 barens said:

Quote:

6 Montez Sweat , EDGE Mississippi State 17 Devin Bush Jr. , LB Michigan 37 Dexter Lawrence , IDL Clemson 95 Daniel Jones , QB Duke 108 Justice Hill , RB Oklahoma State 132 David Sills V , WR West Virginia 142 Chuma Edoga , OT USC 143 Stanley Morgan Jr. , WR Nebraska 171 Saivion Smith , CB Alabama 180 Isaiah Prince , OT Ohio State 232 Lil' Jordan Humphrey , WR Texas 245 Mitch Hyatt , OT Clemson

Love that draft, even I don't like Jones I'll take him at 95...

more defense early.

I remember watching Anderson a couple of seasons back and being
impressed with his skill set. Big play ability. Natural catching the
ball.

Injury history is a red flag, but also the reason he would come cheap.

If we had that draft....especially 1-3

He's going to be TROUBLE for whoever takes him.

In comment 14336402 Red Dog said:

Quote:

He's going to be TROUBLE for whoever takes him.

I agree

6


Montez Sweat

, EDGE
Mississippi State

17


Drew Lock

, QB
Missouri

37


Jeffery Simmons

, IDL
Mississippi State

95


L.J. Collier

, EDGE
TCU

108


Tytus Howard

, OT
Alabama State

132


Justin Layne

, CB
Michigan State

142


Preston Williams

, WR
Colorado State

143


Amani Hooker

, CB
Iowa

171


Deshaun Davis

, LB
Auburn

180


Hunter Renfrow

, WR
Clemson

232


Byron Cowart

, EDGE
Maryland

245


JoJo McIntosh

, S
Washington

Did 5 or 6 mocks through 5 rounds and a couple through 6.

Clearly the availability of some prospects changes mock to mock, but consistently found QBs I wanted much later than expected! Here are my last 3 side by side...

6 ER Sweat or ER Gary or Sweat
17 DL Wilkens or Wilkens or Wilkens
37 DL Simmons or Simmons or Simmons
95 QB Lock or Lock or WR Arciega-Whiteside
108 CB K Boyd or OT T. Howard or QB Will Grier
132 WR D Slayton or OL Benzschawel or Benzschawel
142 WR D Sills or Sills or Sills
143 LB G. Johnson or WR S. Morgan or OL Piersbacher
171 OL I Prince or CB I. Thompson or OT Oli Udoh
180 N/A or RB Darwin Thompson, (Utah State)

The easiest thing to note was that the QBs in these mocks drop. Both Murray and Haskins wre ALWAYS available at 6.

I could wait until slot 142 and still pick up 2 WR with starting type ability and upside.

Likewise there were good solid OL available in the mid reounds.

This draft is thin at CB and S and LBs.
ERs go high!!!