Pat Leonard
& #8207;Verified account @PLeonardNYDN
19m19 minutes ago
Some news: According to a league source, the #Giants have talked to reps for Patriots free agent WR Chris Hogan recently. Hogan, 31, a two-time Super Bowl champ, of course out of N.J.'s Ramapo High School & Monmouth U.
He's a FA
He's a free agent. Pats didn't resign him. He doesn't stink. At least he didn't for the Pats.Cheap money short term I'd take him.
Actually, he was with Buffalo for several years before he went to NE.
I think he's a free agent.
Maybe they are looking at bringing in a Golden Tate?
They jut re-signed Dorsett as well.
Draft a WR in the middle rounds. We can get a 35 reception/500 yard/3TD guy with one of our 4ths and he'll cost peanuts
Quote:
This is what the 2nd and 3rd wave of free agency looks like guys. Lower your expectations. I think he's a good target at WR. I'd much rather go for a reliable high floor guy like Hogan than an underachiever like a Perriman if we're going this route.
Draft a WR in the middle rounds. We can get a 35 reception/500 yard/3TD guy with one of our 4ths and he'll cost peanuts
You can do both. And there are no guarantees that even a 1st round WR gives you that production his rookie year.
Quote:
Who else do they have at WR besides Edelman?
.
Maybe they are looking at bringing in a Golden Tate?
They jut re-signed Dorsett as well.
Golden Tate has not done dick in two years and is on the wrong side of 30. He freakin averaged over $200,000 a reception last year
He has rings, he has played with a group of winners. If he costs a couple Mill for 2 years then this would be a decent pick up.
Better question would be, is he an upgrade over Cody Latimer or Benny Fowler? If the answer is yes, than I wouldn't mind if the Giants sign him.
Something like 2 years, and about 5 mill is my guess.
He is what he is, okay, nothing special.
A good locker room guy as well.
Unless you think Corey Coleman suddenly grows up.
Hogan is faster than people think, has better hands than people think, and runs better routes than people think. The one thing he's not is shifty. I also don't know much about his contribution in run blocking but I'd be surprised if he wasn't giving full effort.
He's an underrated player and would be a nice get.
Having said that, the contract should be inconsequential, not the kind of deal they gave Stewart to play the same role but to get paid like he could contribute. Based on skill alone you can get this guy at 22 years old in the 5th round.
It's a process. It takes character and often some compromises, and here we are.
So...2 years $8 million?
Agreed. And I expect that we'll draft a few WRs this year whether we bring in guys like this or not.
Which Is why Im confused there are rumors on here of
Big things to happen.
Quote:
In comment 14335855 DavidinBMNY said:
Quote:
Who else do they have at WR besides Edelman?
.
Maybe they are looking at bringing in a Golden Tate?
They jut re-signed Dorsett as well.
Golden Tate has not done dick in two years and is on the wrong side of 30. He freakin averaged over $200,000 a reception last year
They have a QB named Brady there too.
Calm down young man. Do you know what the Pats are thinking?
It's a process. It takes character and often some compromises, and here we are.
^This. I think the time to compete is probably 2021.
Just be happy you got that 2nd rounder in the FF trade we made along with hogan and Jared Cook. All for the decaying corpse of Demarco Murray!! You ripped me off!
You can do worse than hogan. Eli will get the most out of him like he always does.
Thats right Im going there
Which Is why Im confused there are rumors on here of
Big things to happen.
I don't know what's going on on that front. My guess is a short extension for Eli, perhaps they're working to tee up an edge rusher on a short deal as well. Golden/Houston?
He would be a good addition..
Quote:
Absolutely correct
Which Is why Im confused there are rumors on here of
Big things to happen.
I don't know what's going on on that front. My guess is a short extension for Eli, perhaps they're working to tee up an edge rusher on a short deal as well. Golden/Houston?
In what planet would Eli get a short term extension
at 38 y/o, with an obvious rebuild going on?
C'mon that is silly talk. If they decide to keep him
for this year, which looks the case, that's it.
I am hoping the Cardinals draft Murray myself,
and then the Giants can try and trade for Rosen.
Lol what
Works the middle well, great team guy, and is a standout special teams player. Good blocker at the WR position.
If he is signed, do not be shocked if you see him playing X receiver on the outside, especially in 12 personnel. He can block and he can work win one on one battles with his frame, wing span, and good hands. He'd be a good inexpensive signing. Lots of value for not a lot of cash.
I'm not opposed to signing him to a cheap deal, some good reasons above, but when I watched, he really struggled on 50/50 balls.
at that time, sure, sign him up.
Love the way the journeyman is automatically considered an upgrade to the culture. Because he landed on the Pats for 2 years? If we signed Dorsett instead would people say the same thing?
Quote:
This guy disappears for months at a time...he averages around 35 catches per YEAR over his career. He had more than 2 receptions only once over the last 9 games last season, and had zero in 4 of those. He's less than a JAG.
Just be happy you got that 2nd rounder in the FF trade we made along with hogan and Jared Cook. All for the decaying corpse of Demarco Murray!! You ripped me off!
You can do worse than hogan. Eli will get the most out of him like he always does.
Thats right Im going there
Lol, YOU proposed that one!
In 2018 he averaged 15.2. Beckham's was 13.7.
Certainly is!
This guy has been flying under the radar for years. All he did in Buffalo was catch everything thrown his way and make plays in the clutch. I'd certainly never call him a starting caliber WR, and he's not going to be a 800 yd+ type of contributor, but New England brought him in for a reason. He's an excellent number 3 or 4 WR, contributes very well on specials, gets open, runs good routes, and has good hands. He's a football player, who happens to be a WR.
He'd be a good fit
It's easy when you only catch 30 balls a year.
Not saying that's a sole reason to bring him in, but it is an attribute that doesn't show up on the stat sheet that will be appreciated when Barkley breaks free.
I have looked, Eric. He's steady as a rock through his career, including spending time injured nearly every season. He's been a tease his entire career. Look at his playoff production: All-Pro one game, Non-Existent the next. What, exactly, IS he? To me, a plug in when required who can occasionally have a good game. I'm not sure what role we'd be looking at for him, but he's certainly NOT a #1 WR. Maybe an outside #2 possession guy but even then, he's no Bouldin or even Crabtree.
And to repeat, He caught 12 balls over the last nine games last year, and 6 came in the season finale against the Jets.
Works the middle well, great team guy, and is a standout special teams player. Good blocker at the WR position.
If he is signed, do not be shocked if you see him playing X receiver on the outside, especially in 12 personnel. He can block and he can work win one on one battles with his frame, wing span, and good hands. He'd be a good inexpensive signing. Lots of value for not a lot of cash.
All good points. Good post.
But at this poiont, it is just a rumor and getting upset over rumors is silly since most of them prove untrue.
Where Bill & Tom just "plug & play", and everything works, no matter who they bring in (because they're smarter than everybody else). We're like the other 32 teams in the NFL - we need a true "X", a guy who scares the crap out of the opponent ...
We had one (arguably the best one), now we're relegated to "dink n' dunk".
Shep is set at slot, Engram (who could be excellent as #2 is stuck at TE). Coleman, as noted has all the tools but is in a deep sleep.
As William Bendix used to say - "what a revolting development" !
Hogan is a lbig guy and deep threat. Elite athlete. NE sent him on deep routes all day.
Stokley? A little slot WR with quickness.
No similarities at all. And Hogan isnt finished like Stokley was when he got here. He has plenty left. He could help.
Hogan is a lbig guy and deep threat. Elite athlete. NE sent him on deep routes all day.
Stokley? A little slot WR with quickness.
No similarities at all. And Hogan isnt finished like Stokley was when he got here. He has plenty left. He could help.
If not for Stokely being finished (and injured) there most likely is no Cruz.:)
Can he fulfill Shep's production? Need a slight bump in total yards, but the TD receptions are equal. The reason I ask is that if the Giants aren't planning on signing Shep to an extension, then he might draw interest in trade. Not necessarily for this April's draft, but before the trade deadline for next year's draft.
I was thinking overnight that there aren't too many players that carry trade value that were selected by Reese. Right or wrong, DG isn't trading his guys that he drafted or traded for recently. I like Shep's game. I love his willingness to block. But if there is no future here, then he might be candidate to be traded. The other player that I think doesn't fit a run-first offense is Engram. Every year, we are waiting for Engram to "take over". Also, every year is the debate to move him to WR. Grabbing Hockenson at #17 solves the blocking/receiving TE dilemma.
Hogan is a lbig guy and deep threat. Elite athlete. NE sent him on deep routes all day.
Stokley? A little slot WR with quickness.
No similarities at all. And Hogan isnt finished like Stokley was when he got here. He has plenty left. He could help.
I was pretty clear in my comment stating that the similarity I was referring too was they are products of two of the greatest QB's ever that make them look better then they really are.
Quote:
It has passed my mind that re-signing Shepard is going to be an issue. I would not be shocked if he were traded.
I would have a stroke if on draft day we traded our #6, #17 and Shepard for AZ's #1 & Murray. I mean, can you see something like that??? Scares me cause I'm just not sold on him as a true, NFL QB. Not just his size but his style scares me as NFL defenders will crush you.
I don't see any blockbuster package to trade up not this year. Besides, Shep's value has to be pegged at a 3rd rounder. If he leaves in FA after this season, then he would likely be a factor in a comp pick formula for the following year. The problem is with an estimated $90M in cap space next year we are likely signing more players than negate the value of those that leave.
Engram on the other hand has 2 years remaining on his contract. He should garner a 2nd.
I'll give him this - he's very clutch. That third down reception on the game tying drive against at Atlanta in the SB - where the Pats were deep in their own end - was a thing of beauty. He ran a terrific out pattern and Brady made an extraordinary throw.
But even with Odell they lacked secondary options.
H: 15, 12, 18. O: 14, 12, 14 (rounded)
2. Hogan has a slightly higher completion to target % than O
H: 64, 58, 66. O: 62, 61, 60
3. O has many more targets than H.
O has 124, 41, 169. Hogan has 55, 59, 58
4. O has more tds: 19-12
For whatever these stats are worth...
Odell gets so many more targets which obviously means more catches, yards, and tds. If the targets were equal, the numbers show Hogan can do just as well as Odell.
Of course Odells one hand grabs are highlight stuff. Im sure Hogan isnt as flashy.
Hogan - ( New Window )
I'll give him this - he's very clutch. That third down reception on the game tying drive against at Atlanta in the SB - where the Pats were deep in their own end - was a thing of beauty. He ran a terrific out pattern and Brady made an extraordinary throw.
You are right, he is certainly clutch.
Tell you what, he got open plenty in Buffalo too when he was there, which says a lot about his ability to run routes and read coverages. He earned the nickname 7/11 (cause he's always open) when he was a Bill.
Funny how its the same people on this theead as every other just shitting on everything without any sensible alternative. Many of them the same ones who bitched and moaned for months last offseason because the Giants went with a RB instead of their precious QB.
A flock of annoying pigeons that just sit around BBI with blank looks on their faces, shitting everywhere.
Funny how its the same people on this theead as every other just shitting on everything without any sensible alternative. Many of them the same ones who bitched and moaned for months last offseason because the Giants went with a RB instead of their precious QB.
A flock of annoying pigeons that just sit around BBI with blank looks on their faces, shitting everywhere.
Nothing. Id rather turn to the draft
Quote:
What in the hell do you expect at this point? There arent any good wideouts available, and they have a huge hole at wideout.
Funny how its the same people on this theead as every other just shitting on everything without any sensible alternative. Many of them the same ones who bitched and moaned for months last offseason because the Giants went with a RB instead of their precious QB.
A flock of annoying pigeons that just sit around BBI with blank looks on their faces, shitting everywhere.
Nothing. Id rather turn to the draft
That wasnt directed at you. 👍
Funny how its the same people on this theead as every other just shitting on everything without any sensible alternative. Many of them the same ones who bitched and moaned for months last offseason because the Giants went with a RB instead of their precious QB.
A flock of annoying pigeons that just sit around BBI with blank looks on their faces, shitting everywhere.
I think he would be a fine addition. We need solid team leaders as well as playmakers. Keep in mind the Giants seemed to be pushing EE towards the end of the season back to the outside more. I think he can be seen as a Hybrid TE/WR in this going BIG offense. Hogan is a taller WR with smarts and reliability who can also play special teams.
Good call, Ron, and that's precisely what makes Beckham so special. He can lose defenders. Can Tate or Hogan? If not, Eli will be tossing a few more INT's than he normally does, assuming he's still the guy behind center.
Quote:
In comment 14335887 rnargi said:
Quote:
This guy disappears for months at a time...he averages around 35 catches per YEAR over his career. He had more than 2 receptions only once over the last 9 games last season, and had zero in 4 of those. He's less than a JAG.
Just be happy you got that 2nd rounder in the FF trade we made along with hogan and Jared Cook. All for the decaying corpse of Demarco Murray!! You ripped me off!
You can do worse than hogan. Eli will get the most out of him like he always does.
Thats right Im going there
Lol, YOU proposed that one!
Oh Yes I did. Drats