Report: Giants not interested in scouting Dwayne Haskins

him via reports and game film

In comment 14341061 Big Blue '56 said:

Quote:

In comment 14341054 Bill in UT said: Quote: means anything Agree

Anybody ever thought that they show no interest to signal to other teams, who are thinking of jumping in front of them? Interested or not, you can't show any interest. This information also goes against Oliver's asshat info. Not believing anything, until it happens.

In comment 14341066 Dave on the UWS said:

Quote:

Let’s see who shows up Wed at the Ohio st pro day

They'll have a contingent there for sure since there are other OSU players they will be scouting in any event.

-

Screw the ELI haters. MO

that everybody lies this time of year. And every other time for that matter.

“It May be Murray or bust”

Little contradictory

In comment 14341120 ajr2456 said:

Quote:

“It May be Murray or bust” Little contradictory

The won't get Murray at 6.

Don’t want Byron Leftwich 2.0.

Get our QB in 20.

Of course I want that sexy blonde beast from Clemson, but he's not coming out till 21.

In comment 14341043 Go Terps said:

Quote:

I've already seen Kerry Collins play QB here. Don't need to run it back.

He does kind of remind me of Collins... can’t argue there. What we won’t know until he plays is how he progresses throughout his career. Collins pretty much hit a ceiling early on, then bottomed out with all the off the field crap, got rescued, reached a ceiling again and never got any better. Time will tell.

In comment 14341086 TMS said:

Quote:

Screw the ELI haters. MO

I really have no problem with either direction as long as they get a beast. To me it’s murray, who won’t be there or defensive bpa at pick 6. I can live with either. I can also live with Eli if the OL is fixed, and it’s very close.

In comment 14341054 Bill in UT said:

Quote:

means anything

agreed

Smart move Giants. Go get Rosen and don't bother with this shit 2019 QB class

....

In the low rent zone.

I want nothing to do with Haskins either just be patient and go after a Qb in the 20 class there will be at least 3 studs to go after.

Unless they’re picking high enough to draft one. Here’s a news flash: they aren’t tanking.

Murray would be great, but probably not available. Rosen is the one they should be in on, but sounds like they’re not.

With not drafting a QB at all this year and beefing up the Lines and our secondary. If we draft well enough this year then we can package whatever picks we need come next draft and get our QB then. But right now we have a lot of holes. The only movement we should do is maybe a few trade BACKS.

Smart on their part

In comment 14341043 Go Terps said:

Quote:

I've already seen Kerry Collins play QB here. Don't need to run it back.

Perfect analogy

The Giants, who need a QB, aren't scouting one of the 3 QBs expected to go in the 1st round?

I'm not suggesting they're necessarily high on him (or not) but not interested in scouting him? I'm calling bullshit.

In comment 14341246 yatqb said:

Quote:

The Giants, who need a QB, aren't scouting one of the 3 QBs expected to go in the 1st round? I'm not suggesting they're necessarily high on him (or not) but not interested in scouting him? I'm calling bullshit.

Same here, if anything this may mean they are more interested in him and this could be a smoke screen to keep teams from jumping ahead of them.

In comment 14341131 WillVAB said:

Quote:

Don’t want Byron Leftwich 2.0.

I don’t teally want Haskins but the leftwich comp is crap

In comment 14341236 montanagiant said:

Quote:

In comment 14341043 Go Terps said: Quote: I've already seen Kerry Collins play QB here. Don't need to run it back. Perfect analogy

Collins was a decent QB here. If Haskins is as good as Collins I have no issue drafting him. Collins didn’t have a RB anything like Barkley (he had young Tiki who coughed up the ball a lot in the Fassel era).

there is fire

If the Giants aren't scouting one of the better QBs in a year they have a top 10 pick, and an aging QB, that should worry everyone.

In comment 14341043 Go Terps said:

Quote:

I've already seen Kerry Collins play QB here. Don't need to run it back.

Kerry got us to a super bowl. I would mind running back to that.

In comment 14341371 christian said:

Quote:

If the Giants aren't scouting one of the better QBs in a year they have a top 10 pick, and an aging QB, that should worry everyone.

unless they don’t think he is one of the top QBs in the draft—or have decided not to draft him under any circumstances. If they don’t like his game that is entirely possible.

serviceable QB for us and was the bridge between Simms and the utter shit that followed Simms.

If Haskins turns out to be Kerry Collins, that’s severely underwhelming

...be there and won't meet with him afterward? This is so fucking stupid. Of course they will.

will be interested in seeing what professional scouting departments and teams think of him when it’s money on the table, not words to the media.

was saying this yesterday on his radio show, too.

He said he heard that the Giants really don’t have him on their board anymore. That they’ve moved on from him as a top round prospect.

In comment 14341054 Bill in UT said:

Quote:

means anything

Ding ding! This is the same reporter who wrote a few days ago, before they traded for pick 17, that the Giants were definitely drafting a defender at 6. This new assertion means very, very little.

In comment 14341436 bw in dc said:

Quote:

was saying this yesterday on his radio show, too. He said he heard that the Giants really don’t have him on their board anymore. That they’ve moved on from him as a top round prospect.

What is the reasoning? That he can't run? I didn't hear the show. I think Haskins is going to be a stud. But what I think doesn't matter in the Giants' selection process.

In comment 14341444 Giants38 said:

Quote:

In comment 14341436 bw in dc said: Quote: was saying this yesterday on his radio show, too. He said he heard that the Giants really don’t have him on their board anymore. That they’ve moved on from him as a top round prospect. What is the reasoning? That he can't run? I didn't hear the show. I think Haskins is going to be a stud. But what I think doesn't matter in the Giants' selection process.

I sort of caught the tail end. So I didn’t get the full context.

I think it centered around the Combine and the Giants came away just not blown away. Whether that was his work in drills and/or the interview, I don’t know.

In comment 14341207 UberAlias said:

Quote:

In the low rent zone.

That's what she is saying more or less. There have been rumors about their interest in Stidham. And of course Jones if he drops some, like to 37 or better yet 95. Then you have Grier and Finley and Rypien. Not to mention my pet pick Lock.

Isn't one of Shurmur's strengths his ability to develop QBs? Lauletta appears to be pissing away his chances, but if they think Eli still has it, why wouldn't they toss a mid round pick into the QB pond once again?

Of course that directly contradicts what Gettleman said before the combine, but he's getting known to prevaricate a bit now and then.

In comment 14341049 Banks said:

Quote:

Don't like any qb at 6. Hope this is true

Yea, don’t want to create any quarterback controversy if Eli struggles, “Paul Dottino school of thought “

I just don’t like this QB crop. Although I’d take a shot on Lock at 17.

In comment 14341086 TMS said:

Quote:

Screw the ELI haters. MO

Yea anyone that would like to get a younger quarterback to begin the transition is an Eli hater.

I live Eli, what I hate is so called Giants fans who are bigger Eli fans than Giants fans

This is no surprise to me & the worst thing the Giants could do is take QB because they feel they have to. My concern is they will have a ton of competition in 2020 for QB’s.

Not to revisit this debate, but this was the risk with not taking Darnold last year. It’s a hard position to fill.

In comment 14341502 jeff57 said:

Quote:

I just don’t like this QB crop. Although I’d take a shot on Lock at 17.

I wouldn't mind Lock there as well. Lock is probably getting taken by Denver.

In comment 14341451 BlueLou'sBack said:

Quote:

In comment 14341207 UberAlias said: Quote: In the low rent zone. That's what she is saying more or less. There have been rumors about their interest in Stidham. And of course Jones if he drops some, like to 37 or better yet 95. Then you have Grier and Finley and Rypien. Not to mention my pet pick Lock. Isn't one of Shurmur's strengths his ability to develop QBs? Lauletta appears to be pissing away his chances, but if they think Eli still has it, why wouldn't they toss a mid round pick into the QB pond once again? Of course that directly contradicts what Gettleman said before the combine, but he's getting known to prevaricate a bit now and then.

If they’re passing on Haskins to waste a pick on Stidham, Grier, Finley or Rypien we’re in a lot of trouble.

Stop trying to turn mid round QBs into franchise QBs

Jones at their 2nd would also. I don't buy this report. The Giants had dinner with Haskins the Fri nite at the combine and reports were they were impressed. Lets see how he does Wed at his pro day.

Haskins is basically just a younger version of the current Eli. No way I'd draft him.

Haskins is as mobile as a dead tree and has one year of true experience, most of that in a dink and dunk offense.

I wouldn't take him at #6 or anywhere else .

Hmm.
Haskins - ( New Window )

As a fan I like that. Everybody else is doing the same. So far I am loving the job they have done. We will see if it is all an illusion. Think where we were last year. Except we will certainly miss those OBJ high lights.