with the Giants having 12 picks in this year's draft, they will have plenty of opportunities to improve the roster. We all have a pretty good idea who owe'd like them to select in the first 2 or 3 rounds. Who are some decent mid-round players that you'd like to see the Giants draft?
I like Ryquell Armstead, RB, Temple and think he could make this team as a 4th or 5th rounder. I am aware RB isn't on the list of Giants' needs, but watching him run really reminds me of Ahmad Bradshaw. It's funny because some articles have mentioned how he seems to "run angry" which is exactly how AB was described. He would be a nice addition to Saquon & Gallman
pre-combine article - (
New Window )
link - ( New Window )
Jalen Hurd, WR, Baylor
Terronne Prescod, OG, North Carolina State
Jesper Horsted, WR, Princeton
I would be ecstatic to get any of these guys on day 3
It's hard to guess where RB's will get taken in the draft, as teams often seem to have very different views of the same guy. Armstead could hang around until the 4th or 5th or even later, but I could also see him going early in the 3rd. He had a really good final year at Temple with over 1,000 yards and a 5.2 average. And he tested very well at the Combine.
I was initially interested in him as I'm still looking for a short yardage RB specialist, and while not a huge guy, he's good at it. But he's good at tough yardage in general, and can also pick up yardage in chunks. Still, he may be a luxury the Giants can't afford to add to their roster given Barkley and Gallman being solid, with some promise behind them.
I'd be surprised if he's not on the Eagle's radar.
Um gallman?
Could still bring back Stewart.
::ducks::
For safety -- Sheldrick Redwine
For WR --- DaMarkus Lodge
For NT -- Daylon Mack
For ILB -- Joe Giles Harris
Major sleeper
G Alex Bars Notre Dame
G/RT Max Scharping Northern Illinois
OT Tytus Howard Alabama St
OT/G Oli Udoh
Pipkins is raw but he stood out during the east west shrine practices which was impressive considering the big jump in competition. He would be an ideal developmental OT behind Solder. Scharping could provide depth at RT and G but eventually take over at RG in a couple of seasons.
Quote:
somewhere in the 4th or 5th. we're thin at the position after barkely god forbid something happens to him.
Um gallman?
ok... and?
Homer is a highly athletic downhill RB who runs tough despite appearing as more of a sprinter. He's also a great special teamer, capable in pass pro, and a good receiver out of the backfield. He's similar to Gallman in style, but a lot more explosive. Instead of being a 4.6 guy he's a 4.4 guy. Gallman's vert was 29 inches, Homers was 39. I'd guess he ends up a 4th/5th rounder as well.
You are a dope. Barkley and Gallman may be the best 1/2 RB tandem in the league.
S. Redwine, Miami could be in play in the 4th (#108 or #132)
E. Worthington, Colorado; W. Harris, Boston College; K. Willis, Mich St all should be worth a look if still available after the 4th round
LB, Khalil Hodge, Buffalo
OT, Trey Pipkins, Sioux Falls
ST-Edge, Sutton Smith, Northern Illinois University
DL-Edge, John Cominsky, Charleston
Late Round Sleeper
WR, Ashton Dulin, Malone University
G Alex Bars Notre Dame
G/RT Max Scharping Northern Illinois
OT Tytus Howard Alabama St
OT/G Oli Udoh
Pipkins is raw but he stood out during the east west shrine practices which was impressive considering the big jump in competition. He would be an ideal developmental OT behind Solder. Scharping could provide depth at RT and G but eventually take over at RG in a couple of seasons.
howard <3
Like 3 of them to try to leverage the outcome and as depth guards.
4th round? Free safeties. Pile of 'em.
Quote:
In comment 14356137 Platos said:
Quote:
somewhere in the 4th or 5th. we're thin at the position after barkely god forbid something happens to him.
Um gallman?
ok... and?
You shouldn't need to use a 4th or 5th rd pick on a 3rd string RB. That's UDFA territory.
Quote:
somewhere in the 4th or 5th. we're thin at the position after barkely god forbid something happens to him.
You are a dope. Barkley and Gallman may be the best 1/2 RB tandem in the league.
Bill, you're forgetting that there may be media/fan backlash if they don't take a RB in the middle rounds. That's why DG would do it, since we know Platos feels that's what informs DG's decisions.
You shouldn't need to use a 4th or 5th rd pick on a 3rd string RB. That's UDFA territory.
Amen to that. First off, if Barkley goes down his skill set is simply irreplaceable, even if we burned our first round pick on a RB. Secondly, Gallman will become our lead back over anyone we get after the first couple of rounds. Backup RBs are "plug and play" type and they are everywhere and available. They can do the job behind a good line, but are not game changers.
Lastly, we need a lot of good defensive players battling it out so that the cream comes to the top. Dittos with WRs and O-linemen. Finding a gem or two in a CB, S, DT, LB, OG, OT, etc., is far more important than finding a perceived gem of a RB who will rarely, if ever, see the field except on the sidelines.
Damien Harris in the 3rd WOULD be a bargain, as many sites show him as going in the 2nd. And he is likely going to be a starting RB, and that would be somewhat redundant behind Barkley. We've already got one better than average RB who can't get enough touches in Gallman.
There is zero reason for a Sproles type when Barkley is already the best pass catching RB in the league. He should be out there every down unless you are giving him a rest. You certainly don't draft that type of player when you have a Barkley. Maybe you look through some UDFAs or people on other team's practice squads.
LB Gary Johnson
DL Isaiah Buggs (Alabama, overshadowed by Q. Will)
DE Joe Jackson
IOL Mike Jordan
OC Ross Pierschbacher
OT Tytus Howard
WR DeMarkus Lodge
WR Miles Boykin (absolutely killed it at the combine, don't know why no one is talking about that. His shuttle and cone drills were actually top notch compared to DK Metcalf who sucked in those measurements)
OT Mitch Hyatt
WR David Sills
WR Mecole Hardman (from Georgia, one of the most explosive players in the draft, will be a much better pro than college player I believe)
CB Kendall Sheffield
S Mike Edwards
DE Jordan Brailford
DL Chris Slayton (from Syracuse, perfect DL for 3-4)
RB Benny Snell (battering ram who can take the pressure of Saquon on short yardage runs)
S Malik Gant (I think he can be had very late in the draft)
L.J. Scott
Bennie Snell Jr
Elijah Holyfield
Or David Montgomery
Would be my guys.
Quote:
somewhere in the 4th or 5th. we're thin at the position after barkely god forbid something happens to him.
You are a dope. Barkley and Gallman may be the best 1/2 RB tandem in the league.
Gallman is only under contract for two more years and he only rushed for 3.5 ypc last year.
They could use one of their 8 day 3 picks on a RB...
Quote:
somewhere in the 4th or 5th. we're thin at the position after barkely god forbid something happens to him.
Um gallman?
And Martin. Both are legit back ups w borderline starter ability. Not worried about back up RB. you can pick up a vet back up relatively cheap.
I think the idea was to list some middle round players you like. Not all of them. Not all of the players in college.
ILB Germaine Pratt from NC State could be a great replacement for Ogletree. Pratt is a former safety who is still learning the position but he is great in coverage. He is exactly what this teams needs. Pratt would be a great choice in round 3 if he is still on the board.
ILB Germaine Pratt from NC State could be a great replacement for Ogletree. Pratt is a former safety who is still learning the position but he is great in coverage. He is exactly what this teams needs. Pratt would be a great choice in round 3 if he is still on the board.
FWIW the Giants scouted Sutton Smith multiple times during the year.
After the first two or three rounds, the draft is about acquiring talent. You don't fill needs with 5th round draft picks. If DG takes a running back in the middle rounds I'm fine with it. Just make sure he's good.
WR Mecole Hardman
WR Hunter Renfro (late)
Edge Jonathan Ledbetter
Edge Porter Gustin
Edge Jalen Jelks
Jalen Hurd 2018 Highlight Video - ( New Window )
Any of those Oklahoma or Wisconsin OL who don't go in rounds 1 -3. Evans, Samia, Powers, Benzschawel, Dieter, Edwards...
Hoping some of these well coached hog mollies make it into the 4th for the Giants. Particularly Dieter, a LT who's now projected as an OG, just a nasty widebody guy who knows how to use his hands.
Video - ( New Window )
WR Mecole Hardman
WR Hunter Renfro (late)
Edge Jonathan Ledbetter
Edge Porter Gustin
Edge Jalen Jelks
Isabella may very well go in the top 50 picks, especially after the combine validated his on-field productivity - I don't know if he qualifies in the context of this discussion simply because he will probably be drafted before the middle rounds.