1 week away: What would YOU give up to get Murray?

I think his upside represents to much, but I wouldn't be surprised if he isn't on our board at all. Size and personality concerns.

In comment 14391701 UberAlias said:

Quote:

I’m going to tell you all I told you so. ...and if he doesn’t, most likely you’ll have forgotten I said anything, lol.

Haha I was thinking the same thing.

.

and is a pass first qb who is as mobile as a 3rd down running back.

In comment 14391707 Giants38 said:

Quote:

A lot. I think Matt from SGS suggested a while back that it may cost the 6, 17, 95, and a 2020 2nd. I’d be fine with that.

That's a lot, even for a top QB prospect — but if they think he's their guy, they should go get him, they way they went and got Eli.

I don't have strong feelings about Murray. He was amazing in college but it's a different game in the NFL.

I have a sense he'll be there at 6 and we pass on him.

Easy pass here.

so we can see how many people here embarrassed themselves with their shortsighted and unresearched opinion. This thread will end up looking a lot like the pre-draft Patrick Mahomes thread for a couple of years ago. Murray is going to an absolute stud and I'd give up 6, 17, and our 2nd rounder to get him.

But if he fell to 3 or 4 (Jets/Oak) and one of those teams would take 6, 37 and one of the 4s or 5s, I would do it. (But it would likely take more.)

I think Murray has a chance to be a star in the NFL and I'm a "gamble on greatness" type of drafter.

In comment 14391558 Big Blue '56 said:

Quote:

In comment 14391546 jtgiants said: Quote: You know I love you. No disrespect intended Oh please..Your post is fine. I was just interested to see what people who really like Murray would trade to get him.. Now Fat Mara, he’s another thing.

You were just waiting to use Fat-Mara!!

To quote a guy here - MURDERER!!

In comment 14391554 jayg5 said:

Quote:

Nothing

Not even the $20,000 for the gaming license, which I would appreciate if you would put up personally.

In comment 14391536 twostepgiants said:

Quote:

Cannot respect the wishes of the OP who has been on this website since 2001 and clearly laid it out in the OP.

I have seen this in other threads as well. Some people perhaps just skim when they read

In comment 14391787 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

In comment 14391558 Big Blue '56 said: Quote: In comment 14391546 jtgiants said: Quote: You know I love you. No disrespect intended Oh please..Your post is fine. I was just interested to see what people who really like Murray would trade to get him.. Now Fat Mara, he’s another thing. You were just waiting to use Fat-Mara!! To quote a guy here - MURDERER!!

You do realize, that’s the best contribution to this site bw central has ever made, yes?

You remember Fran Tarkenton. This kid is Tark with a rocket engine.

In comment 14391853 Manny in CA said:

Quote:

You remember Fran Tarkenton. This kid is Tark with a rocket engine.

Except Tarkenton was never a runner. He scrambled to keep a play alive or to go out of bounds. Murray is a runner. He, like all runners, are far more susceptible to the big hit than a scrambler is

Him before Rd 3. Not an NFL QB

Are you saying that Rivers is better? Not in my book. So we threw in a pick used on a kicker and I believe a busy edge rusher. I’ll take Eli and our two championships.

One big hit away from disaster. But, if he's the next Russel Wilson - he can deliver a Lombardi Trophy.

I'd prefer to give up just 6 and either 17 or 37 in a trade up.

I think it's a moot point because Arizona is going to take him.

the Giants have enough points with picks 6, 17 and 37 to trade up to the first pick - that's if they go according the the Trade Value Chart. Actually we have 80 extra points. Could that have been a small factor in the Beckham trade?
Trade Value Chart - ( New Window )

because if I move up I want one of the big 3 lock stud Def players. However if AZ passed on Murray and he fell to 4 then I would give up my 3rd this year and 2nd next year.

Here is how I try and judge players. If you put Daniel Jones or Dwayne Haskins or Lock on Oklahoma they would better, but wouldn't match Kyler Murray in numbers with exception of Haskins. If you put Kyler Murray on Mizz, Duke, Ohio State, etc he would beat their stats outside of maybe Haskins.

He is the best QB in this draft and special.

I’m not losing any sleep to get Murray. Same as last year, I didn’t care about any of the qbs and definitely preferred Barkley.

I’d give up the 6, the 17, next year’s 1 and 3 if Mike Leach is coming along in the deal to teach the Air Raid to the Giants offense in the few May/June walk throughs and no contact practices, and during the padded practice restrictions during trading camp and the pre-season. :-]

6, 17 and the 2ND rounder although initial offer would be 6, 17 and 3Rd rounder.
Yeah, there's other holes to fill however the QB situation must be addressed. If not this year then next. Worry about plugging the holes next year with your full allotment if draft picks and all the cap money you'll have.

..