for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

what would it take to go from 17 to 9

floridagiantsfan : 4/18/2019 4:58 pm
Most of us would love to fix the dl/er, ol, and qb in the first three picks. I think the consensus is that we go dl/er with six since this is the strength of the draft and fills a huge need.

The problem becomes how to get our first choice at qb since all four first round grade qb's will probably be gone at 17.

If we like jones or locke or even haskins we probably need to trade to 9 in front of Denver, cincy, and wash. JT has alluded to this possibility. What would this cost us?

Of course we could stay at 17 and get a quality ol but signs point to us signing remmers which would make this less urgent for the upcoming year
I think it would likely take our 2nd rounder, or a 2 next year and a 4  
yatqb : 4/18/2019 5:00 pm : link
this year.
It took a 3 and a 5  
Giantsfanincuse : 4/18/2019 5:03 pm : link
For Arizona to go from 15 to 10 last year- but of course each year is different.
Each year is different, but a few examples from last year  
kash94 : 4/18/2019 5:09 pm : link
-Arizona moved to 10 for the 15th pick, a 3rd, and a 5th rounder
-Bills traded to 9 for the 12th pick and two second rounders
-Saints went from to 14 for the 27th pick, an additional first rounder, and a 4th rounder

Hopefully 17, a 3rd, and a fourth can do it?
RE: Each year is different, but a few examples from last year  
robbieballs2003 : 4/18/2019 5:12 pm : link
In comment 14392522 kash94 said:
Quote:
-Arizona moved to 10 for the 15th pick, a 3rd, and a 5th rounder
-Bills traded to 9 for the 12th pick and two second rounders
-Saints went from to 14 for the 27th pick, an additional first rounder, and a 4th rounder

Hopefully 17, a 3rd, and a fourth can do it?


Did you even read your own post? Do you really believe that the last pick in the third round before comp picks and a 4th is getting this done?
Dave Te' said theres going to be a lot of trades this year  
Platos : 4/18/2019 5:28 pm : link
so value might be all over the place compared to previous years.
If the Giants do trade the 6th or 17th, it is likely to move down  
SGMen : 4/18/2019 5:31 pm : link
DG, FO, PS and JB all know this team has A LOT of holes. DG did a great job drafting last year, I think, even if QB Lauletta never works out. Yeah, this assumes McIntosh becomes a force (my gut tells me he plays a LOT this year) and CB Beal pans out and starts at least at some point this year & for good reason.

My prayer all along has been that a blue chipper falls to us because QB's go #1 and #3 (Jets trade down for a nice haul, perhaps?) and DL Bosa, Williams or LB J. Allen are there at #6. If not, we trade the 6th pick to maybe Denver or even New England for players and picks (assuming QB Jones is there and he simply isn't high on our draft board).

But in the end, DG will stick to his draft board and most likely the draft will go (no trades):

1. Murray
2. Bosa
3. Allen
4. Williams
5. D. White / Ed Oliver
6. E. Oliver / D. White

Oliver could end up as big of a stud as the others before him, but in a pass rush sense. He isn't as strong, not nearly as strong, as Donaldson who is so freaking quick like Oliver but also has pure power behind him too. Oliver is not quite that guy BUT has that burst you can't teach.
D. White starts all 5 years and likely probowls. He is the goods & can cover and play 4 downs (every snap).

But imagina if the Giants trade Denver their #6 for Denver's #1, #2 and #3 for our #5 too? Or something like that? You'd have to be happy even though that trade only happens if a QB is there that Denver really wants to build on. We'd be passing two years in a row on a QB of note. Scary "cross your fingers" move that could impact the team for decades POSITIVELY or NEGATIVELY, depending upon how the QB develops and plays, of course.

Go Giants: viva la "Best Player Available" all day and every day!
An old not that good RT with a bad back  
Diver_Down : 4/18/2019 5:36 pm : link
isn't an urgent need (to replace)? BBI has gone crazy. First we wanted Daryl Williams who blew out his knee last season. He had to settle for a 1 year prove it deal in Carolina cause he couldn't pass a physical. Now, we want a guy who can't pass a physical because of a bad back?
RE: RE: Each year is different, but a few examples from last year  
kash94 : 4/18/2019 5:37 pm : link
In comment 14392529 robbieballs2003 said:
Quote:
In comment 14392522 kash94 said:


Quote:


-Arizona moved to 10 for the 15th pick, a 3rd, and a 5th rounder
-Bills traded to 9 for the 12th pick and two second rounders
-Saints went from to 14 for the 27th pick, an additional first rounder, and a 4th rounder

Hopefully 17, a 3rd, and a fourth can do it?



Did you even read your own post? Do you really believe that the last pick in the third round before comp picks and a 4th is getting this done?


I mean - was going more off of the Rosen trade I guess since it's somewhat similar to the OP's scenario (15 to 10 vs 17 to 9). That said, forgot that the 3rd round pick is significantly lower than where Arizona's was last year.
17 to 8 .....  
MotownGIANTS : 4/18/2019 5:38 pm : link
Detroit actively trying to trade down .... I think they'd take 17, 2nd next yr and a pair of 4ths this year
if its for your QB  
stoneman : 4/18/2019 5:40 pm : link
then next years 2nd would do and - and be worth it. This of course would take you out of the running for any of next years fun :)
Per the draft value chart  
Gregorio : 4/19/2019 8:49 am : link
400 points. 9 is 1350, 17 is 950. Pick 45 in round 2 is valued at 400.
Trading up for a QB  
GothamGiants : 4/19/2019 9:26 am : link
is the dumbest move they could possibly make.

Stand pat and draft 2 immediate defensive starters or trade down for more 2020 ammo (NE moving up for a TE perhaps)
Back to the Corner