2018 NFL Re-Draft - Gettleman Did Amazing

but I think he did a great job. Hopefully the 3rd round CB is also a hit.

Your comments don't match the redraft at all. The only thing he said about the Giants was that the Barkley pick will be debated for years. Did i miss something.

Let’s hope it happens again with the boatload of picks we have this year.

In comment 14392979 Giants_Rock said:

Quote:

Your comments don't match the redraft at all. The only thing he said about the Giants was that the Barkley pick will be debated for years. Did i miss something.

He has Hill and Hernandez getting drafted at the back end of round 1

In comment 14392982 eric2425ny said:

Quote:

In comment 14392979 Giants_Rock said: Quote: Your comments don't match the redraft at all. The only thing he said about the Giants was that the Barkley pick will be debated for years. Did i miss something. He has Hill and Hernandez getting drafted at the back end of round 1

That's correct. He has BJ Hill and Hernandez as being drafted in the 1st round. BJ Hill was a 3rd round selection. Tons of value in that pick.

Heck, I think R.J. McIntosh could play too if they needed it.

In comment 14393000 nowturnyourheadandcoughlin said:

Quote:

In comment 14392982 eric2425ny said: Quote: In comment 14392979 Giants_Rock said: Quote: Your comments don't match the redraft at all. The only thing he said about the Giants was that the Barkley pick will be debated for years. Did i miss something. He has Hill and Hernandez getting drafted at the back end of round 1 That's correct. He has BJ Hill and Hernandez as being drafted in the 1st round. BJ Hill was a 3rd round selection. Tons of value in that pick. Heck, I think R.J. McIntosh could play too if they needed it.

I missed that. Ok, I stand corrected.

...


... Pat Douchebag Leonard

In comment 14392982 eric2425ny said:

Quote:

In comment 14392979 Giants_Rock said: Quote: Your comments don't match the redraft at all. The only thing he said about the Giants was that the Barkley pick will be debated for years. Did i miss something. He has Hill and Hernandez getting drafted at the back end of round 1

To be fair, Hernandez at 30 is only a few picks ahead of where we did take him. It's not quite like the Colts getting Leonard in the 2nd.

Hill on the other hand was an absolute steal in the 3rd.

Redraft - the Giants have picks 2, 26, & 30.

Maybe DG isn't as awful as many on BBI claim.
Let's hope he can do as well this year with 12 picks.

In comment 14393059 ZogZerg said:

Quote:

... ... Pat Douchebag Leonard

In all honesty I'm guessing they leaned heavily on Shurmur for his assessment on Lauletta.

Beal and McIntosh are also very promising under the radar additions. Obviously need to show it on the field, but those 2 have a ton of talent/“upside”.

Lorenzo Carter’s development is at the top of my “watch list” this summer ... overall last year looks like 1 of the best drafts in a long, long time. I think Carter could be a force in this scheme - looking forward to how he’s unleashed this year.

Another haul like last year and this team is going to surprise a lot of people this year - especially with that soft schedule.

which I think is a silly exercise after only 1 year.

You have Lamar Jackson that high...uh, ok. And Kemoko Turay? No Braden Smith, no Christian Kirk, no Dallas Goedert, all who probably more deserving than Turay. Jordan Whitehead (4th round pick from Bucs) is more deserving than Turay, who admittedly still has some promise and potential.

But that's not to say that DG doesn't deserve some credit...my IDEAL scenario coming into the draft was to somehow come away with Saquon Barkley and Will Hernandez in the first two picks...and that happened. B.J. Hill was a tremendous pick, and I think Lo Carter was a good pick as well.

In comment 14393325 allstarjim said:

Quote:

no Dallas Goedert

PICK 31: Dallas Goedert, TE