No explanation needed. No pros or cons. Just go on record with your QB rankings, as it pertains to fitting in with the Giants. For this exercise, use your top 4 QBs from this draft, whoever they may be, and include Josh Rosen, if he stacks up to the other guys. You don’t have to include him, if you aren’t a fan. Take draft capital, contract terms and personality (that we know of) into account as well, if you’d like
Mine
1. Josh Rosen (Willing to part with #37, if need be)
2. Dwayne Haskins
3. Drew Lock
4. Kyler Murray
5. Daniel Jones
Go!
Haskins
Lock
Murray
2. None of them
3. None of them
4. None of them
5. None of them
I'll say this, though. While I would prefer that the Giants not draft a QB this year, if they do (or if they trade for Rosen), I'll root like hell for the guy. After all, I didn't want them to trade for Eli back in 2004, and that turned out okay.
Lock
Haskins
Grier
Finley
And i prefer Lock over Jones.
Hasksins
Rosen
Grier
Lock
Jackson
Lock
Murray
Haskins
Jones
Finley
Lock
Haskins
Grier
I'll say this, though. While I would prefer that the Giants not draft a QB this year, if they do (or if they trade for Rosen), I'll root like hell for the guy. After all, I didn't want them to trade for Eli back in 2004, and that turned out okay.
I'm sorry Sir, that kind of measured response is not welcome here, especially on draft day. You should be busy marinating your torch in pitch and sharpening your pitchfork.
2) Lock
3) Jones
4) Finley
5) Haskins
6) Murray
2- Murray has an uncorrectable handicap but take a chance.
3- Jones. Does he really have a weak arm?
4- tie Haskins, Lock both have footwork problems but good skills
6- tie Grier, Finley
Lock
Jones
Haskins
I swing for the fences with my future QB, I don’t want to settle.
Haskins strikes me as “fine”, Rosen is the best and Murray/Lock have the most natural “talent”. I like a lot about Jones, although there isn’t much “elite” about him.
Rosen in trade or wait until next year. Mid rounder on Tyree Jackson in the meantime
2.Jones
3.Haskins
4.Murray
5.Grier
2) Lock
3) Rosen
4) Jones
5) Haskins
6) Grier
Starters:
1 Kyler Murray - comp = some combo of Wilson/Vick; may not be quite on that level
2/2a Dwayne Haskins = Warren Moon with less mobility
Drew Lock = Matt Stafford
Backups that could be mediocre starters in time:
4 Ryan Finley = Nick Foles
5 Daniel Jones = Ryan Tannehill
6 Brett Rypien = Andy Dalton
Strictly backups:
7 Easton Stick = Drew Stanton
8 Will Grier = Teddy Bridgewater
9 Jarret Stidham = Jimmy Clausen
Maybe a backup, but more likely a career in coaching:
10 Trace McSorely = Colt McKoy
11 Gardner Minshew = Brian Hoyer
Not NFL caliber:
11 Tyree Jackson
12 Clayton Thorson
13 Jake Browning
14 Kyle Shurmur
Talent wise, I'd slot Rosen after Murray but factoring relative cost, above Murray.
2.) Murray
3.) Wait until 2020
This would be a good move.
2) Everyone else
2. None of them
3. None of them
4. None of them
5. None of them
Thanks for contributing that.
3 Jones
4 Haskins
5 Finley
6 Lock
Quote:
I depend on guys like Sy'56, Dave-Te' Thomas, and a dozen other scouts/analysts for that.
I'll say this, though. While I would prefer that the Giants not draft a QB this year, if they do (or if they trade for Rosen), I'll root like hell for the guy. After all, I didn't want them to trade for Eli back in 2004, and that turned out okay.
I'm sorry Sir, that kind of measured response is not welcome here, especially on draft day. You should be busy marinating your torch in pitch and sharpening your pitchfork.
My pistols are charged, my saber is sharpened, my horse is saddled, and I'm prepared to ride to Nashville on a moment's notice.
2. Haskins
3. Murray
Not too interested beyond that
Haskins
Jones
Murray
Lock
2020 QB's
Murray
Lock
Jones
Haskins
Trading for Rosen
Grier
Lock
Round 2- Jones
Round 3- Finley
Round 4- Stidham/Grier
Round 5- Jackson/Thorson
If I can't do that...
Daniel Jones
Dwayne Haskins
Ryan Finley
-----Would not draft-----
Drew Lock - just got taken off of draft board because of personality concerns...too much smoke here that he is another Cutler, which is a shame because he has all the physical tools.
Kyler Murray - I just can't commit to a 5'10" QB who is a little slight of frame. Feel like he has a lot of great attributes when it comes to agility, speed, and arm talent, but it's not the package I'm looking for to play QB for the Giants. I think you're always going to be holding your breath when he takes the hits.
Will Grier - Don't trust his arm from a strength or accuracy perspective.
ALL OTHER QBs in 2020 Draft.
Last on the list:
Josh Rosen
Quote:
In comment 14404064 Klaatu said:
Quote:
I depend on guys like Sy'56, Dave-Te' Thomas, and a dozen other scouts/analysts for that.
I'll say this, though. While I would prefer that the Giants not draft a QB this year, if they do (or if they trade for Rosen), I'll root like hell for the guy. After all, I didn't want them to trade for Eli back in 2004, and that turned out okay.
I'm sorry Sir, that kind of measured response is not welcome here, especially on draft day. You should be busy marinating your torch in pitch and sharpening your pitchfork.
My pistols are charged, my saber is sharpened, my horse is saddled, and I'm prepared to ride to Nashville on a moment's notice.
Atta boy, thats more like it