SY what would your picks be?

But I would go:
Defense
Defense
Offensive Tackle

He said he would trade the #6 pick for Rosen.

My offer for Rosen
Sy'56 : 6:57 pm : link : reply : Delete
NYG gives

#6

ARI gives

QB Rosen
#37 overall (2nd)
#140 overall (5th)

Then NYG makes an aggressive trade up from #17 to get their defender. Only reason I think it has to be this...MIA and WAS offering their #1 is a real possibility.

Before he becomes a GM. He needs to work on his negotiateding skills.

But Sy always does a "counter-draft" after the draft, showing who he would have taken at every spot.

In comment 14406106 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

My offer for Rosen Sy'56 : 6:57 pm : link : reply : Delete NYG gives #6 ARI gives QB Rosen #37 overall (2nd) #140 overall (5th) Then NYG makes an aggressive trade up from #17 to get their defender. Only reason I think it has to be this...MIA and WAS offering their #1 is a real possibility.

It would have to be pick 33, we have 37.

Could be had substitute #6 to #17 in same picks coming back

In comment 14406106 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

My offer for Rosen Sy'56 : 6:57 pm : link : reply : Delete NYG gives #6 ARI gives QB Rosen #37 overall (2nd) #140 overall (5th) Then NYG makes an aggressive trade up from #17 to get their defender. Only reason I think it has to be this...MIA and WAS offering their #1 is a real possibility.

Why on Earth would give up the 6th pick for a player that can most likely be gotten with the 37th?

Losing the 6th pick for a player that a team wants to get rid of after 1 year is insanity to me. Give them next years #1 we have a shot at getting a stud on D with that pick.

He explained why.

In comment 14406161 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

He explained why.

yes, because he can't be had for #37.

He has lost value. He was ranked one of the worst QBs in 2018. He was drafted with the 10th overall pick. He's like a used car that has side damage. His value has decreased a ton. That's why no one has offered a 1st rounder for him. He's simply not worth that anymore. Heck, several teams passed on him in last year's draft. That just shows you how other GMs viewed him. When a crop of 5 QBs get drafted in the first round. Several are going to be busts. Just the law of averages.

will be posted in the discussion threads when NYG is on the clock.

I will say right now that Jonah Williams will likely be my guy at 6. And depending on how top 16 shakes out, I am looking at defensive front 7...unless Rosen can be had.

In comment 14406183 nowturnyourheadandcoughlin said:

Quote:

He has lost value. He was ranked one of the worst QBs in 2018. He was drafted with the 10th overall pick. He's like a used car that has side damage. His value has decreased a ton. That's why no one has offered a 1st rounder for him. He's simply not worth that anymore. Heck, several teams passed on him in last year's draft. That just shows you how other GMs viewed him. When a crop of 5 QBs get drafted in the first round. Several are going to be busts. Just the law of averages.

Oh shit, I thought you got banned last night after your stereotypical tirade over Haskins. Ughhhh.

In comment 14406118 George from PA said:

Quote:

Before he becomes a GM. He needs to work on his negotiateding skills.

He isn’t negotiating. He’s basing his price on supposed offers from other teams.