Please DO NOT list 5 or more or even ties. JUST 4..
I am trying to make it as difficult as possible and of course there are no rights or wrongs, simply our opinion.
You can put a player, or coach or owner in your top 4, but again, ONLY 4 or please don’t participate.
It took me the full 60 minutes on my Stairmaster to settle on 4. You can imagine how many times I went back and forth.
My heads on Mt. Rushmore, in no order:
1-L.T.
2-Eli
3-Parcells
4-Rosy Brown
And go:
Gifford
Hein
2- Eli
3- Wellington Mara
4- Frank Gifford
2) Gifford
3) Strahan
4) Hein
1. Eli
2. Strahan
3. LT
4. Harry Carson
2- Eli
3- Wellington Mara
4- Frank Gifford
^This.
1) LT
2) Eli
3) Strathan
4) Parcells
2) Eli
3) Strahan
4) Parcells
2)Mara
3)Parcells
4)Tie between Carson/Gifford/Strahan would probably choose Strahan though.
Eli Manning
Wellington Mara
Saquon Barkley (a 'hunch' tells me he'll have an 'alright' career here.)
Parcells
Eli
LT
LT, Parcells, GY, and Rozelle. GY and Rozelle saved this franchise. Mara is a joke.
Just players: LT, Simms, Strahan, Bavaro.
Agree, that was a dickish comment by him.
2) Eli
3) Bavaro
4) Carson
2. Eli Manning
3. Michael Strahan
4. Scott Norwood
2. Parcells
3. Strahan
4. LT
5. Gifford
Greatest coaches: obviously Parcells and Owen.
Just missed the cut: Gifford, Carson, Rosy Brown.
Changed the game: LT, Benny Friedman (changed the game forever with the development of the forward pass)
1. LT
2. Carson
3. Eli
4. The NO GM who drafted George Rodgers.
As for Mara.... Well... I respect opinions but he was honestly one of the worst owners on the history of the game. Young had to be forced on him.
As other mentioned Parcells, The Duke, Little Bill.
Phil Simms
Eli Manning
Bill Parcells
LT
Eli
Strahan
Parcells
but as at least one other poster mentioned, I would save a spot for Saquon.
LT
Bavaro
Strahan
Carson
2. Parcells
3. Strahan
4. LT
5. Gifford
I’d drop Eli and add Tittle and maybe Bavaro
2. Strahan
3. Carson
4. Eli
2-4 was tough, I have 5 other guys that could go in there. Bavaro, Jacobs, Banks, Marshall and Parcells. Barkley will one day be in there, possibly as high as #2
Harry Carson
Y. A. Tittle
Joe Morrison
Emlen Tunnell
2. Frank Gifford.
3. Lawrence Taylor.
4. Eli Manning.
Strahan
Gifford
I thought hard about that.
If he had retired a year later and won the Super Bowl he’d be a lock for Rushmore and the HOF.
George Young
Eli
LT
Eli
Strahan
Hard to leave off Gifford, Robustelli, Tunnell and Carson.
2. Phil Simms
3. Frank Gifford (before my time but worthy)
4. Michael Strahan
I agree it is tough to keep it at four.
2) LT
3) Bill Parcells
4) Harry Carson
Rosie Brown
Emlen Tunnell
Michael Strahan
Hard to leave Gifford, Carson and Eli off.
Simms
Eli
Strahan
1925-1949 - Mel Hein
1950-1979 - Frank Gifford
1980-2004 - Lawrence Taylor
2005-present - Eli Manning
1925-1949 - Mel Hein
1950-1979 - Frank Gifford
1980-2004 - Lawrence Taylor
2005-present - Eli Manning
You're a wise man, Larry.