The other thread got me thinking about the top 10:
1. Lawrence Taylor
2. Mel Hein
3. Roosevelt Brown
4. Emlen Tunnell
5. Michael Strahan
6. Harry Carson
7. Frank Gifford
8. Eli Manning
9. Charlie Conerly
10. Phil Simms
Honorable Mentions
Sam Huff
Andy Robustelli
YA Tittle
Tiki Barber
Amani Toomer
2. Mel Hein
3. Tuffy Leemans
4. Frank Gifford
5. Roosevelt Brown
6. Sam Huff
7. Phil Simms
8. Lawrence Taylor
9. Michael Strahan
10. Eli Manning
The Giants have had too many great players, I'd have trouble coming up with a Top-20 I'd be happy with. I wanted Benny Friedman, Ward Cuff, Harry Carson, Mark Bavaro and a bunch of others on here but there just isn't enough room for them all.
Tuck was a very good player who came up big in both Super Bowls, however he was never dominant for any length of time. Strahan was and had a Hall of Fame career.
Katcavage
Rosie Brown
LT
Carson
Simms
Eli
Bavaro
Tuck
Strahan
Gifford
Huff
Manning
Simms
Rosey Brown
Emlen Tunnell
Homer Jones
Al Blozis
Strahan