Your Giants' Mt. Suckmore - 4 Only

Ray Handley
CC Brown
Trey Junkin
Ereck Flowers
Jeff Triplette is alternate

4 Scott Brunners

.

.

Herman Moore
Lavar Arrington
Clint Sintim

1-Bob Gibson

2-Tommy Maddox

3-Rocky Thompson

4-RH

Always a Giant.

Don't like trashing Giants unless for lack of effort in games or some crime in real life.

1. Matt Dodge (obvious reasons)
2. Luke Petitgout (idk, growing up I just always remember him getting false starts)
3. Tiki (he was my FAVORITE player as a kid, but after he ran his mouth it was just too much)
4. Ereck Flowers (obvious)

FLOWERS
ROSS from the front office
HANDLEY
WILLIAM JOSEPH

I'm probably forgetting someone from way back that was worse but off the top of my head this is what I got.

1)Dave Brown
2)Derek Brown
3)Ron Dayne
4) Cedric Jones

In comment 14495369 HoodieGelo said:

Quote:

1. Matt Dodge (obvious reasons) 2. Luke Petitgout (idk, growing up I just always remember him getting false starts) 3. Tiki (he was my FAVORITE player as a kid, but after he ran his mouth it was just too much) 4. Ereck Flowers (obvious)

Tiki? At least for a few more seasons, he's arguably the Giants best RB and skill player ever.

Petitgout was a false start machine, but he's not even in the bottom 5 of worst OL over the last decade...

for Curtis Riley?

I think we should just put up the entire 2017 team.

...he was worse.

1. Goliath.
2. El Gigante.
3. Giant Silva.
4. Hong-Man Choi.

Shockey
Eli
Beckham
Collins

- Go Terps

In comment 14495377 djm said:

Quote:

...he was worse.

It was a toss up for me. Could go with either one IMO, but I decided to go with Handley. At least McAdoo had 1 good season.

Handley, McAdoo, Brandon Myers, CC Brown

on it
Link - ( New Window )

Yeah, he goes on Rushmore but that fat bastard could have set us up with Belichek, instead he sets us back a fucking decade with HANDLEY.

Joe Pisarcik. If it weren't against the Eagles, we'd be laughing about it today. But it was, and we're not.

Randy Dean. Because he was second string behind Pisarcik.
Jerry Goldsteyn. Because he was behind Dean.

In comment 14495373 Kevin(formerly Tiki4Six) said:

Quote:

1)Dave Brown 2)Derek Brown 3)Ron Dayne 4) Cedric Jones

Maddox was way worse than Brown. Brown showed up every Sunday and played his ass off under shitty circumstances so I'll never bash the guy

- Trey Junkin
- Ian Allen
- CC Brown
- Joe Pisarcik

Honorable mention: Brian Mitchell just because fuck him.

Every player on the Giants' roster from 1973-1978 is a viable candidate.

In comment 14495369 HoodieGelo said:

Quote:

1. Matt Dodge (obvious reasons) 2. Luke Petitgout (idk, growing up I just always remember him getting false starts) 3. Tiki (he was my FAVORITE player as a kid, but after he ran his mouth it was just too much) 4. Ereck Flowers (obvious)

Tiki was a great Giant, period. It is hardly shocking that some of the older Giants didn't embrace Eli. I'm surprised really that there are any left holding grudges, Christ he retired 13 years ago!

Matt Dodge
Dave Brown
Ereck Flowers
Ron Dayne

In comment 14495404 George said:

Quote:

Every player on the Giants' roster from 1973-1978 is a viable candidate.

Most of those defenses were good to very good units.

I agree on offense.

Eric Dorsey
CC Brown
Matt Dodge
Otto Brown

In comment 14495363 figgy2989 said:

Quote:

Herman Moore Lavar Arrington Clint Sintim

I know he's a punchline on BBI, but Ron Dayne was far, FAR from the worst Giants, even if you limit the conversation to his position. You want to talk about first-round picks that were misspent on running backs? Tucker Frederickson was a worse pick, taken #1 overall. Guys taken after him included Dick Butkus, Gayle Sayers, Joe Namath, Mike Curtis and a bunch of other very good to great players.

Dayne was lousy, but he was just ordinary lousy, not a monumental example of suckitude.

In comment 14495396 x meadowlander said:

Quote:

Yeah, he goes on Rushmore but that fat bastard could have set us up with Belichek, instead he sets us back a fucking decade with HANDLEY.

George Young is the one who didn't want Little Bill as head coach. Don't blame Parcells for that error.

don't even bother carving the rest of the mountain.

Handley
Cedric Jones
Derek Brown
Ereck Flowers
Thomas Lewis

Complete wastes.

Dave Brown.

Who puts Macdoo on this list is insane. Yes, his 2nd year was an absolute train wreck and he should have been fired twice but top4 worst of all time. The guy made the playoffs as a head coach. That automatically takes him out of the running

Ian Allen
Thomas Lewis
Rocky Thompson

Honorable mention to Joe Don Looney

In comment 14495424 Mr. Bungle said:

Quote:

don't even bother carving the rest of the mountain.

Ditto to that

and Trey Junkin and Matt Dodge

Trey Junkin
Matt Dodge
Jeremy Lincoln
and
Dave Brown

CC Brown
Coleman Rudolph
Charles Brown
Markus Kuhn

Tito Wooten
Jarrod Bunch
Ron Dayne
Tyrone Wheatley

And Bunch was a good player who got hurt.

Wooten was a safety.

Butch Woolfolk....


and i dont Jarrod Bunch was ever any good, but we will agree to disagree

In comment 14495444 cjac said:

Quote:

Tito Wooten Jarrod Bunch Ron Dayne Tyrone Wheatley

Did you mean Tyrone Wheatley? Or Butch Woolfolk? Woolfolk was worse than Wheatley, though neither was much good as a Giant.

And he was a decent lead blocker. Then he blew out his knee the next year and that was all she wrote.

Woolfolk

In comment 14495382 giants#1 said:

Quote:

Shockey Eli Beckham Collins - Go Terps

That's actually pretty unfair on Terps and I've disagreed with him on plenty.

But McAdoo is at the top of my list followed closely by Reese ...

instead of Wooten

but i'd keep Wheatley on my list

he was ok, but a disappointment

Was a DB who sucked

LOL.

In comment 14495443 Greg from LI said:

Quote:

CC Brown Coleman Rudolph Charles Brown Markus Kuhn

Markus Kuhn was a 7th round pick, I'm not sure how much greatness (or even mediocrity) could be expected of him...

In comment 14495457 English Alaister said:

Quote:

In comment 14495382 giants#1 said: Quote: Shockey Eli Beckham Collins - Go Terps That's actually pretty unfair on Terps and I've disagreed with him on plenty.

The only thing that's "unfair" is that Plaxico isn't on the list...