NFT: Forget politics. Let's talk COOKIES!

double chocolate or orange chocolate are my favorites.

but texture wise it needs to be crispy/harder. Really don’t like soft cookies.

I'm partial to gingerbread cookies. Oatmeal raisin is always good. Tried and true chocolate chip is a winner.

I prefer crispy.

.

Other favorites - good fig filled cookies (Fig Newtons are OK but far, far, far from the best), oatmeal cookies are my long-time favorite, and good snickerdoodles are great, too.

Underscoring my usual position as outside the mainstream, I really don't care for chocolate chip cookies.

NOTHING still beats a really good chocolate chip cookie.

If you're on the NY Thruway pretty much from the Plattekill rest stop to Albany, the oatmeal raisin and chocolate chip cookies at the Gray Mouse Farm booths outside (Under the Taste of NY tents) are the best cookies of all time.

Rainbow cookies are the best

It turns out that they have like a hundred flavors and every time a new one hits the shelf, I have to try it. A couple of weeks ago it was S'mores, last week latte, this week megastuff....

But I really like coconut macaroons. Also, peanut butter cookies.

In comment 14497365 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

NOTHING still beats a really good chocolate chip cookie.

Agreed. I especially like them if they are hot, so that the chocolate is slightly melted and soft.

She also makes these graham cracker and apple cookies that are awesome, as well as molasses.

not even close imo

Double dark chocolate are the best. Black and white I like. However, on the west coast they are not available.

with real home made Maple Creme Frosting. Outstanding!

Choc chip or oatmeal raisin

..

In comment 14497416 uncledave said:

Quote:

not even close imo

I like your style.

anymore and I was never a big sweets fan.

But, when I was a kid and I ate cookies my favorites were:

Store bought: chips ahoy. regular, original.

Home made: my mothers peanut blossoms, but if magic bars count as cookies they win in a landslide - those were my exception to not liking sweets.

Christmas was a month long event, my mother would make trays of christmas cookies and bring them to half the world.

Peanut blossoms, chocolate chip, anginettes, sugar cookies pressed into christmas shapes, snowballs (these cookies covered in confectioners sugar), etc. etc..

Has always been my favorite. Although a chewy chocolate chip is alway great
Underrated back in the day
Archway brand molasses or oatmeal cookies I loved. Used to eat the whole 8 cookie package and one time. Mmm!
I am going to gym. Then I am stopping at some bakery!

In comment 14497377 Bill L said:

Quote:

It turns out that they have like a hundred flavors and every time a new one hits the shelf, I have to try it. A couple of weeks ago it was S'mores, last week latte, this week megastuff....

Ever try mint Oreos? Mint cream in the middle......oh man!!

almost 2 1/2 hours, and only RUSS has excellent taste: coconut macaroons and peanut butter cookies.

I would also nominate my wife's large oatmeal cookies with chocolate and white chocolate chunks.

chocolate chip cookie that I can't resist each 2 or 10. They are out of this world.

In comment 14497523 superspynyg said:

Quote:

In comment 14497377 Bill L said: Quote: It turns out that they have like a hundred flavors and every time a new one hits the shelf, I have to try it. A couple of weeks ago it was S'mores, last week latte, this week megastuff.... Ever try mint Oreos? Mint cream in the middle......oh man!!

yup. Mint, lemon, coconut.... haven't tried carrot cake or red velvet cake but they are out there.

Is tremendous

The Kirkland brand combo pack (Oatmeal, Chocolate Chip, White Choc Macadamia) is extremely underrated.

Great cookie at a very good price point

Man the chocolate chip in that pack is practically perfect

Black and White cookies. What’s up with that?!

chocolate chip. My pet cookie peeve- when you end up with a f'ing raisin cookie cause it's not labeled and it looks like chocolate chip. Nowadays you've gotta be really careful- I went to a buffet recently when they had carob chip, sugarless chocolate chips, gluten free cc, low fat choco chip. disgusting

Double stuffed oreos ain't bad either...surprisingly good with beer!

Mint Milano's are not bad...

Italian cookies from the bakery are the best.

Nothing better. cold milk, warm cookies..

boom.a good breakfast cookie to boot.

(Hey, I'm getting oatmeal,right?)

I probably would agree with almost all of them! But my favorite on is Oatmeal Raisin. Prefer it soft but I take a crispy one!

raisins.

we had a Chinese bakery near our apartment that made the most amazing crumbly crisp almond cookies with a chocolate dollop in the center. They looked something like this:

Chocolate Chip

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Black & Whites
Rainbow Cookies
Thin Mints
Homemade Pignoli Nut cookies as I prefer cookie softer and store bought always seems to harden

Fig bar (that's a cookie, right?)

In comment 14497742 Bill in UT said:

Quote:

chocolate chip. My pet cookie peeve- when you end up with a f'ing raisin cookie cause it's not labeled and it looks like chocolate chip. Nowadays you've gotta be really careful- I went to a buffet recently when they had carob chip, sugarless chocolate chips, gluten free cc, low fat choco chip. disgusting

The accidental raisin cookie grab when expecting a chocolate chip cookie has to be the biggest letdown in the cookie kingdom

Promotes segregation! No one is allowed on one side or the other, that is why Jerry got a stomachache when he ate the cookie!

right on brother with peanut butter and Hershey kiss cookies

end of story

In comment 14497495 Payasdaddy said:

Quote:

Has always been my favorite. Although a chewy chocolate chip is alway great Underrated back in the day Archway brand molasses or oatmeal cookies I loved. Used to eat the whole 8 cookie package and one time. Mmm! I am going to gym. Then I am stopping at some bakery!

I always feel bad for the guys in orange jumpsuits who don't have access to cookies. Amirite?

Two of my favorites are in the work vending machine. I'm glad I cut out sugar and carbs because I'd be 300 pounds. I'm talking about Milanos and Fudge Stripe. For my birthday I'll have one of the two, have resisted temptation for the first 6 months.

Called Calabresi con Noci that is absolutely fantastic. Problem is I can't find anything online that resembles it. It's got no real formed shape, just kind of spooned onto a baking sheet it looks like, it's a chocolate cookie with walnuts mixed in and looks like it's dusted with sugar

In comment 14497365 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

NOTHING still beats a really good chocolate chip cookie.

End of thread.

And anything from Levain's of course.