The obvious thing was the TD throw. As soon as he threw it, I knew it was right on the mark, but man, that was a perfect pass.
But what REALLY impressed me was how he kept his composure after the two fumbles. I can't tell you how many young (and some old) quarterbacks I've seen through the years let adversity like that affect them for the rest of the game.
That's what Gettleman was talking about when he judged the QBs in this draft. Daniel Jones just shook it off.
No way to tell who gives the Giants the best chance to win from these games. Right now I would say Eli based on experience. But that could change very quickly.
Jones is far far ahead of where Eli wa was a rookie. But that means next to nothing in the big picture.
You can say what you will about the starting oline but his time vs Jets the Jets has 3/4 of their starting lb core on the field including both edge rushers as well as Q Williams..who the Jets list as a “backup”
The WR's that Jones is playing with are the backups and some that won't make the team yet they are significantly better than the WR's Jones had in college. He looks outstanding so far playing with the backups. Imagine what he will look like playing with top end talent.
yeah, i am sure that won't happen...
Agreed. Jones has been the recipient of some very clean pockets for his pass attempts, too. Which is good in the big picture for the OL development. So a clean pocket, ample time, vanilla Ds should translate to a high rate of completions in today’s game.
Feel like there is sort of a batting practice feel to Jones’s work thus far...
Quote:
Facing backups playing vanilla defense. We’re really getting ahead of ourselves here. He’s not seen the challenges that break QBs in the NFL. I’ve no doubt Jones will not be a bust and will be NYG QB of the future. But is he a top 10 - 12 guy or simply a guy you can get by with if you have the pieces around him. We have no idea.
Agreed. Jones has been the recipient of some very clean pockets for his pass attempts, too. Which is good in the big picture for the OL development. So a clean pocket, ample time, vanilla Ds should translate to a high rate of completions in today’s game.
Feel like there is sort of a batting practice feel to Jones’s work thus far...
You forgot good ball placement and looking off defenders.
Agreed. Jones has been the recipient of some very clean pockets for his pass attempts, too. Which is good in the big picture for the OL development. So a clean pocket, ample time, vanilla Ds should translate to a high rate of completions in today’s game.
Feel like there is sort of a batting practice feel to Jones’s work thus far...
You forgot good ball placement and looking off defenders.
That’s what a pro QB is supposed to do, right?
I don’t quite get this vibe that Jones is doing these high level/plus things. Yes, he’s made some nice throws and he doesn’t look like an incompetent fool. But for me these are classic, fundamental NFL throws so far.
Quote:
Agreed. Jones has been the recipient of some very clean pockets for his pass attempts, too. Which is good in the big picture for the OL development. So a clean pocket, ample time, vanilla Ds should translate to a high rate of completions in today’s game.
Feel like there is sort of a batting practice feel to Jones’s work thus far...
You forgot good ball placement and looking off defenders.
That’s what a pro QB is supposed to do, right?
I don’t quite get this vibe that Jones is doing these high level/plus things. Yes, he’s made some nice throws and he doesn’t look like an incompetent fool. But for me these are classic, fundamental NFL throws so far.
Have you seen a better rookie this summer?
That’s what a pro QB is supposed to do, right?
I don’t quite get this vibe that Jones is doing these high level/plus things. Yes, he’s made some nice throws and he doesn’t look like an incompetent fool. But for me these are classic, fundamental NFL throws so far.
How many rookies do this on day 1? Very disingenuous to say 'NFL QBs are supposed to do this' when more than a few VETS can't / don't, much less rookies their 1st game. Small sample, yes, but as good as you can hope for
Also some of those throws were far from normal / easy, esp the TD if not a slew of shorter ones perfectly in stride (like the short crosser that went for a big play). Even the fade 1st game, imperfect maybe, yet not some easy throw even for NFL QBs
Pressure has been little, sure. But have you seen Duke games? He's faced plenty. Doesn't mean he'll be the greatest but the experience is a plus to predict his transition. And few college guys would have survived, much less produce to make it to the NFL as a top prospect no less
Actually, it's not a 100% match, but a TON of what EA was talking about w/ Eli. Which is why I'm baffled so many ignore it. Toughness, even-temperament, ability to shake off a big hit, bad play, repeat failings of teammates and move on to the next play, football IQ, prep / work ethic etc
Otherwise it's not much of an analysis if we ignore such enormously important traits for QBs no matter which side you of the fence you're on
Quote:
Agreed. Jones has been the recipient of some very clean pockets for his pass attempts, too. Which is good in the big picture for the OL development. So a clean pocket, ample time, vanilla Ds should translate to a high rate of completions in today’s game.
Feel like there is sort of a batting practice feel to Jones’s work thus far...
You forgot good ball placement and looking off defenders.
That’s what a pro QB is supposed to do, right?
I don’t quite get this vibe that Jones is doing these high level/plus things. Yes, he’s made some nice throws and he doesn’t look like an incompetent fool. But for me these are classic, fundamental NFL throws so far.
Classic fundamental NFL throws? Wow, first cris Carter says that the td pass against would have been intercepted if Jamal Adams was back there and now we get they are just classic, fundamental NFL throws. Kind of funny that the criticism is that he doesn't wow you.
Maybe we should send a notice to the pat shurmur and the NFL that Jones can only throw to wide receivers that are triple covered by hall of Famers with one arm tied behind his back. Maybe that will impress you?
Some of the posts on here are just beyond ridiculous
Quote:
Agreed. Jones has been the recipient of some very clean pockets for his pass attempts, too. Which is good in the big picture for the OL development. So a clean pocket, ample time, vanilla Ds should translate to a high rate of completions in today’s game.
Feel like there is sort of a batting practice feel to Jones’s work thus far...
You forgot good ball placement and looking off defenders.
That’s what a pro QB is supposed to do, right?
I don’t quite get this vibe that Jones is doing these high level/plus things. Yes, he’s made some nice throws and he doesn’t look like an incompetent fool. But for me these are classic, fundamental NFL throws so far.
Players picked high like Jones are supposed to do a lot of things and never do. Jones is showing signs that he isn't a wasted pick like many have said, something this franchise can ill afford.
Have you seen a better rookie this summer?
I guess no. Then again I haven’t consumed many preseason games.
How many rookies do this on day 1? Very disingenuous to say 'NFL QBs are supposed to do this' when more than a few VETS can't / don't, much less rookies their 1st game. Small sample, yes, but as good as you can hope for
Also some of those throws were far from normal / easy, esp the TD if not a slew of shorter ones perfectly in stride (like the short crosser that went for a big play). Even the fade 1st game, imperfect maybe, yet not some easy throw even for NFL QBs
Pressure has been little, sure. But have you seen Duke games? He's faced plenty. Doesn't mean he'll be the greatest but the experience is a plus to predict his transition. And few college guys would have survived, much less produce to make it to the NFL as a top prospect no less
Honestly, my recollection of great preseason starts is basically void. It’s a completely different game than those play from September to December.
In total, I think I watched 5 Duke games. One in full - Clemson.
Players picked high like Jones are supposed to do a lot of things and never do. Jones is showing signs that he isn't a wasted pick like many have said, something this franchise can ill afford.
In preseason games, he has looked very solid - absolutely.
Trying to build a case that preseason results suddenly confirm the pick is a good old fashioned switching of the horse and the cart...
Classic fundamental NFL throws? Wow, first cris Carter says that the td pass against would have been intercepted if Jamal Adams was back there and now we get they are just classic, fundamental NFL throws. Kind of funny that the criticism is that he doesn't wow you.
Maybe we should send a notice to the pat shurmur and the NFL that Jones can only throw to wide receivers that are triple covered by hall of Famers with one arm tied behind his back. Maybe that will impress you?
Some of the posts on here are just beyond ridiculous
I agree some of the posts here are ridiculous.
Jones has looked very solid in preseason. Now, it’s certainly better that he doesn’t look like a deer in the headlights, and he isn’t pissing all over himself - true.
But the difference in preseason and regular season isn’t even worth discussing.
Even Crick's last post is nothing cart b4 horse. Just the signs are there after all the shit piled on the pick to now...
Then you again say preseason 'isn't worth discussing' while criticizing specific throws by DJ? Which is it?
Quote:
Players picked high like Jones are supposed to do a lot of things and never do. Jones is showing signs that he isn't a wasted pick like many have said, something this franchise can ill afford.
In preseason games, he has looked very solid - absolutely.
Trying to build a case that preseason results suddenly confirm the pick is a good old fashioned switching of the horse and the cart...
But I'm not trying to confirm anything. I am pleasantly happy with the results so far.
I've watched football closely enough to know things aren't always what they seem whether good or not so good. He certainly has a lot of improvement to do. One, if not the biggest key is how he handles real game situations with dc attacking his weaknesses. How many areas of weakness can the player overcome? Once you overcome one weakness the gifted brains in the league will attack the next weakness and so forth. How many levels can the player climb before hitting the ceiling? That's what a player's career is, and I am excited to see it.
One last thing about Jones, like Manning he seems to be an articulate guy who wants to get better and knows he has to get better. One pitfall in this league is a player either being satisfied where they are, or too arrogant to improve their game.
Even Crick's last post is nothing cart b4 horse. Just the signs are there after all the shit piled on the pick to now...
Then you again say preseason 'isn't worth discussing' while criticizing specific throws by DJ? Which is it?
When I see productivity and Ws in real game action then we can broach the topic of the pick being justified. Hell, some of sound like you want to renegotiate an extension already...
I’ve got to be honest, I’d be shocked if every starting QB, and most backups, in the NFL couldn’t make that throw by Jones to Jones. That’s sort of a red zone 101 play in the NFL. Is it a good sign that he made it very comfortably? Absolutely.
Here’s the thing. I want Jones to start. I’ve been hawking that since he was drafted. Despite my doubts about Jones, he’s much more the prototype for Shurmur’s O than Eli. And a back like Barkley can certainly be a very reliable security blanket for a rookie QB.
So I think it’s worth the stretch to gamble on Jones from the get-go. The sooner we find out who Jones really is, the quicker we can get onto the future post-Eli.
Somehow you're misconstruing that into contract extensions (your words). Even Crick said "showing signs" to which you replied with the "cart b4 horse" stuff...clearly NOT what was said, nor in the last several posts
And it really makes no sense to watch games or discuss this so much when you're so adamant preseason doesn't matter
What this is, is that he is still checking all the boxes.
It's still preseason. Teams aren't game planning and mixing up coverages yet.
But its far better to be checking the boxes than not.
Regarding the sack fumble, yes bad job by the line, but that was coming right at him. He has to be able to see that pressure and turn and move the ball out of danger. Rookie mistake, you hope it's a learning opportunity.