New York Giants - Arizona Cardinals Game Discussion Thread

hire a proven scout just for OL. My God - since Snee - we have only one decent pick in Hernandez. That's over a decade of drafts

In comment 14636274 Justlurking said:

Quote:

And the O-Line is a disgrace.

Scariest part of this is we were coming off a Thursday night game with more than the normal time to plan, and the Cards had to travel here!

to Kliff Kingsbury and Herve Villechaize at QB - a team traveling east for a 1pm game - is embarrassing.

Are there any positives at all from today’s game?
And I don’t mean negative lessons learned, e.g. that we need a new head coach.

coaching have to do with it?

But it is still the offensive line that is the biggest problem. Eight sacks with three holding penalties and our quarterback hurried or hit on just about every throw. Shurmur and this staff are awful but this is Dave Gettleman's team. Isn't this the guy that said priority number 1 is to fix the o-line? He has signed two players(one to a HUGE contract),traded for another, and used a very high(#2 in the round)to pick another. The result? You guys know what it is. Gettleman is a disaster. Posters here rave about his draft picks. Give me a break. Barkley is great but a very debatable selection. Hindsight is 20/20 but the choice should have been Nelson or Darnold. The rest of his picks? Who knows? I haven't seen many impact plays by his draft picks. We can't fire Mara but IMO, everyone else needs to go. we are 2-5,and should be 1-6 but wither way, this team won't win more then 5 games, if that. Sound familiar?

In comment 14636415 Gruber said:

Quote:

Are there any positives at all from today’s game?

Barkley isn't dead.

In comment 14636416 bc4life said:

Quote:

coaching have to do with it?

Hey, I've been questioning the hiring of Hal Hunter since he was hired.

He should have his entry card confiscated immediately.

Then the GM the year after. Hopefully we will know about the QB in 3 more year. Barkley will be 27 by then.....

I really wish the Maras would just go away.

that DJ audibles to that draw play to Saquon. Maybe his original play call sucked.

In comment 14636415 Gruber said:

Quote:

Are there any positives at all from today’s game? And I don’t mean negative lessons learned, e.g. that we need a new head coach.

Baker at CB. The kid is a player and we hardly see him or hear his name called lately.

In comment 14636485 Jim in Hoboken said:

Quote:

Then the GM the year after. Hopefully we will know about the QB in 3 more year. Barkley will be 27 by then..... I really wish the Maras would just go away.

Agreed

In comment 14636294 Joey from GlenCove said:

Quote:

In comment 14636262 Default said: Quote: In comment 14636224 Coach Red Beaulieu said: Quote: Is the common denominator. Oh shut the fuck up. They get shutout with Eli starting. Disagree I think Eli wins this... and wow you’re pathetic

And you’re not living in reality. SMD

In comment 14636294 Joey from GlenCove said:

Quote:

In comment 14636262 Default said: Quote: In comment 14636224 Coach Red Beaulieu said: Quote: Is the common denominator. Oh shut the fuck up. They get shutout with Eli starting. Disagree I think Eli wins this... and wow you’re pathetic

Yeah, Eli's really done well the past couple of years with a bad OL and facing a strong pass rush.

Don’t see Hernandez progressing, Or Halapio. The tackles are helpless and they STILL can’t handle a stunt. Screams “shitty”!coaching.

In comment 14636485 Jim in Hoboken said:

Quote:

Then the GM the year after. Hopefully we will know about the QB in 3 more year. Barkley will be 27 by then..... I really wish the Maras would just go away.

If we have to live through PS next year too I'm not sure I'll make it through. Good thing my life insurance is paid up and my kids and grand kids will be able to enjoy the Giants future coach.

In comment 14636329 AndyMilligan said:

Quote:

In comment 14636300 crick n NC said: Quote: In comment 14636259 PhiPsi125 said: Quote: But I’m sure we’ll get a ton of shit threads this week about how DJ is a bust. SMH Eh, he's not a bust, but there are some real ball security issues as well as pocket presence. management needs to have its eyes open. I'm still hopeful about DJ but there is a non-zero chance he is not the answer.

Can you repost that in English so we can understand what the hell you're trying to say? I get the first part about management but after that it's kinda tough

In comment 14636368 bc4life said:

Quote:

and "Jones is a bust" do not belong in same sentence

CB blitz never even saw it coming .... in a pro league!

lost their starting jobs when the team goes on to win like 10 games in a row without them; like when Tim Tebow got the start and held it when he took his team to the playoffs. Or like when Brady got the nod over Bledsoe. This team still is horrible without Eli. 2-4 now. 2-3 with Jones. I like how evryone is like well "you have to get this guy some help out there" like it was OK to waste prime Eli on a shit team?

We should spend some assets on an o line change. Not so we can be competitive, but to keep jones healthy. He’s going to end up like Carr in Texas.