We have a QB. Mara has to pull trigger to get new HC

Hire the dude from University of Minnesota and call it good.

But how do you say thank you for our future QB but see you later? That kind of contradicts itself doesn't it?

just not a good head coach. what the fuck has he shown here to make anyone say he's a good coordinator?

In comment 14674146 robbieballs2003 said:

Quote:

But how do you say thank you for our future QB but see you later? That kind of contradicts itself doesn't it?

Yup


Gettleman has to take responsibility, 95% of it, for the defense being what it is.

The defense is the biggest weak link on this team that’s causing more losses than anything else


It was the same weak link when spags was DC.
The oline is very bad— bottom third of the league in terms of play

But the defense is bottom 3 for 2 straight years and has been bottom third for every year since our last Super Bowl

Oline means nothing when you let a team averaging 14 ppg score 34. That’s happened twice this year


Bettcher can only play the guys he’s given. same can be said for shurmur. You ought to ask yourself

IS THIS DEFENSE UNDERPERFORMING given the roster?? Can anyone here with a straight face say that it is?? There are 4-7 starters on this defense that are playing 50 snaps a game that would not even sniff 10 snaps on a 15th ranked defense.

And we got 4 to 7 of these players.

Whose fault is that??? Bettcher???


Nope

It’s Dave Gettleman.

In comment 14674148 japanhead said:

Quote:

just not a good head coach. what the fuck has he shown here to make anyone say he's a good coordinator?

Every QB he’s coached in the last 5 years put up career or above avg years. Including Eli.

In comment 14674159 huygens20 said:

Quote:

In comment 14674146 robbieballs2003 said: Quote: But how do you say thank you for our future QB but see you later? That kind of contradicts itself doesn't it? Yup Gettleman has to take responsibility, 95% of it, for the defense being what it is. The defense is the biggest weak link on this team that’s causing more losses than anything else It was the same weak link when spags was DC. The oline is very bad— bottom third of the league in terms of play But the defense is bottom 3 for 2 straight years and has been bottom third for every year since our last Super Bowl Oline means nothing when you let a team averaging 14 ppg score 34. That’s happened twice this year Bettcher can only play the guys he’s given. same can be said for shurmur. You ought to ask yourself IS THIS DEFENSE UNDERPERFORMING given the roster?? Can anyone here with a straight face say that it is?? There are 4-7 starters on this defense that are playing 50 snaps a game that would not even sniff 10 snaps on a 15th ranked defense. And we got 4 to 7 of these players. Whose fault is that??? Bettcher??? Nope It’s Dave Gettleman.

And why was he brought in? We were underperforming and 9ur cap was a mess. This was always a e year rebuild. We had to take hits to our salary cap the last two years to rid ourselves of these contracts. It could not have been done in one year. He gets a minimum of 3 years to start to see the improvement. And, yes, Bettcher is fuckin awful.

a number of them in garbage time. that is a career year for him? give me a break. barkely had one yard rushing today. you really think he's done a good job with the offense this year?

In comment 14674174 japanhead said:

Quote:

a number of them in garbage time. that is a career year for him? give me a break. barkely had one yard rushing today. you really think he's done a good job with the offense this year?

Eli put up better numbers under shurmur than he did with mcadoo

As a 37 year old qb


Where the trend line of his performance continued to go down


Shurmur went in and helped Eli put up his best year in 3.


Then look at case Keemun
Nick foles


Shurmur sucks as a HC. But the evidence says he’s very good at getting qbs to perform

In comment 14674181 huygens20 said:

Quote:

In comment 14674174 japanhead said: Quote: a number of them in garbage time. that is a career year for him? give me a break. barkely had one yard rushing today. you really think he's done a good job with the offense this year? Eli put up better numbers under shurmur than he did with mcadoo As a 37 year old qb Where the trend line of his performance continued to go down Shurmur went in and helped Eli put up his best year in 3. Then look at case Keemun Nick foles Shurmur sucks as a HC. But the evidence says he’s very good at getting qbs to perform

dude eli threw 26 TDs in 2016 in mcadoo's offense, and was throwing dimes all over the field in the lambeau playoff game.

i don't give a fuck what keenum and foles did on different teams in different years. foles won the superbowl MVP without shurmur.

what has shurmur done HERE to show that he is some offensive genius? that he got eli to throw 20 TDs last year en route to a five-win season? i guess my bar for great offensive coordinator is different than yours.

In comment 14674143 I am Ninja said:

Quote:

Hire the dude from University of Minnesota and call it good.

Boy do I like that guy

To get a promising HC candidate in here with Daniel Jones playing well. I think there was some hesitation previously because coaches were worried about being stuck with Eli and the cupboard being bare. That is no longer the case, so long as they like DJ as a prospect.

I think many of the play calls suck along with clock management.