1994-2019. In no particular order
*Made pro bowl as a giant
1. Eli Manning*
2. Tiki Barber*
3. Amani Toomer
4. Jeremy Shockey*
5. Michael Strahan*
6. Justin Tuck*
7. Osi Umenyiora*
8. Antonio Pierce*
9. Corey Webster
10. Jason Sehorn
11. Keith Hamilton
12. Ike Hilliard
13. Chris Snee*
14. Odell Beckham Jr.*
15. Rich Seubert
16. Jesse Armstead*
17. Damon Harrison*
18. Landon Collins*
19. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie*
20. Steve Smith
21. Plaxico Burress
22. Kevin Boss
23. David Diehl*
24. Shaun O'Hara*
25. Ahmad Bradshaw
26. Brandon Jacobs
27. Mathias Kiwanuka
28. Sterling Shepard
29. Saquon Barkley*
30. Janoris Jenkins*
31. Cornelius Griffin
32. Corey Webster
33. Will Allen
34. Olivier Vernon
35. Jason Pierre-Paul*
36. Evan Engram
37. Hakeem Nicks
38. Mario Manningham
39. Victor Cruz*
40. Will Beatty
41. Antrel Rolle*
42. Kenny Phillips
43. Terrell Thomas
44. Linval Joseph\
45. Kareem McKenzie
46. Chris Canty
47. Barry Cofield
48. Fred Robbins
49. Luke Petigout
50. Ron Stone*
51. Gibril Wilson
52. Will Peterson
53. Shaun Williams
Who would i be missing?
Yes, and wasn't he the holder because the pro-bowl kicker was a Giant?
CB Terrell Thomas ---> Phillippi Sparks (better corner)
OT Will Beatty ---> Jumbo Elliott (better LT; 1 Pro Bowl)
I think I'd have to go Feagles at punter(who did make the pro bowl in 2008 with the G-Men), although don't get me wrong I do love me some Weatherford.
At kicker it's hard to go against Tynes considering he had *TWO* NFCCG-winning kicks, both in OT, which is pretty amazing, but Rosas did make a pro bowl and I can't remember the last Giants kicker to do so before him, so that's a tough one. I think I go Tynes since he was here for 6 years and with us making clutch kicks in both super bowl runs we had during said 25 year span. I remember really liking Daluiso, too (honorable mention there).
CB Terrell Thomas ---> Phillippi Sparks (better corner)
OT Will Beatty ---> Jumbo Elliott (better LT; 1 Pro Bowl)
I was just about to remind you about hte 25 year window and, sure enough, those three barely squeeze in. Nice call on those.
CB Terrell Thomas ---> Phillippi Sparks (better corner)
OT Will Beatty ---> Jumbo Elliott (better LT; 1 Pro Bowl)
No way Beatty was better than Elliot. And maybe Sparks and Thomas make it but not one over the other.
RBs: Tiki, Barkley, Bradshaw, Jacobs
WRs: Toomer, Nicks, Burress, Hilliard, Beckham, Steve Smith, Shepard, Nicks, Manningham, Cruz
TEs: Shockey, Boss, Engram
OCs: O'Hara
OGs: Snee, Seubert, Stone
OTs: Diehl, Beatty, McKenzie, Petitgout
DEs: Strahan, Tuck, Osi, Kiwi, Vernon, JPP
DTs: Hamilton, Harrison, Griffin, Joseph, Canty, Cofield, Robbins
ILB: Pierce
OLB: Armstead
CB: Webster, Sehorn, DRC, Jenkins, Will Allen, Thomas, Peterson
SS: Collins, Wilson
FS: Rolle, Phillips, Williams
So you're definitely missing some LBs, K, P, and backup QB. Way too WR and DT heavy.
Quote:
but Zac DeOssie may have earned a spot somewhere.
Yes, and wasn't he the holder because the pro-bowl kicker was a Giant?
I'm not sure.
RB- Saquon, Tiki, Bradshaw, Jacobs
FB- Hynoski
WR- Odell, Plax, Toomer, Cruz, Nicks
TE- Shockey, Boss, Engram
OT- Diehl, McKenzie, Petigout
OG- Snee, Seubert, Ron Stone
C- O'Hara
DE- Strahan, Tuck, Osi, JPP
DT- Hamilton, Snacks, Robbins, Coefield
LB- Armstead, Pierce, Boley, Barrow, Kiwi
CB- Sehorn, Webster, DRC, Jackrabbit, Ross
S- Rolle, Collins, Phillips, S. Williams
Some of these guys you have to think of at their peaks and not at the tail end of their time here (Jackrabbit, Diehl, Petigout, Collins etc)
Joe Jurevicious
Charles Way
Bad Chad Bratzke
But very good list overall. Shows how weak the drafting was in certain periods