for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: Going to learn guitar

DaddyM89 : 11/25/2019 5:34 pm
Not musically inclined at all (played drums for a year in elementary school and was horrible.) But come form a musically inclined family (dad and uncles.) Have always wanted to learn.

Any advice on best practices, best way to learn, and what type of guitar to start with etc. Thanks in advance!
I too am curious  
superspynyg : 11/25/2019 5:42 pm : link
I’d it better to start with an acoustic or electric guitar?
Should have plenty of time to practice  
Sec 103 : 11/25/2019 5:43 pm : link
instead of watching the crap that the Giants put on the field every Sunday/ Monday/ Thursday.... And BTW- Next year same as last.
Learning to play guitar...  
EricJ : 11/25/2019 5:44 pm : link
is a great distraction from watching the Giants.
Get a few lessons  
phil in arizona : 11/25/2019 5:56 pm : link
Best way to get better is to learn from people that are better than you.

Get a decent guitar (something that at one point retailed for around $400-$500, Made in Mexico strat/tele, etc). Have it set up by a guitar tech.

Buy a used acoustic on Craigslist  
Overseer : 11/25/2019 6:03 pm : link
you can get a decent one (Seagull S6 or Yamaha FG830) for ~200.

Then - and I cannot stress this enough for a beginner - get it professionally set up (patronize an independent store vs Guitar Center). ~$80.

They will, among other things, lower the "action" (space between strings & fretboard) for you which will make it much more playable. A beginner learning bar chords with high action will tear his hair out, get frustrated, and sabotage progress.

Then you suffer through the same 3-6 months all of us suffered through of learning your chords and switching smoothly without thinking between them. Google "Justin Guitar" and "Marty Music" for some good instructional videos. Pick some songs from artists you like (I played a lot of Neil Young when I started out) and it will help you with chords, strumming patterns, tempo, etc.

There's no such thing as "musically inclined". Great musicians got there because they practiced, practiced, practiced. Then when they were done with that, they practiced some more.

Good luck.
Don’t go overboard...  
Chris in Philly : 11/25/2019 6:17 pm : link
and spend a fortune on a first guitar, but also don’t get some piece of shit that you won’t enjoy playing. Taking a couple of lessons is good advice, but if you don’t want to do that then there are a lot of resources online to learn the basic major and minor chords. Buy an electronic tuner so you can keep your guitar in tune easily. They aren’t that expensive.
I highly recommend Steve Krenz's Learn and Master Guitar series  
DC Gmen Fan : 11/25/2019 6:24 pm : link
I used it and still do to this day. He has a good mix of theory and practical exercises, jam alongs, lessons, etc. Again I highly recommend it. He's an outstanding teacher.
L & M Guitar - ( New Window )
Play to Learn how to Play  
Rafflee : 11/25/2019 6:49 pm : link
If you're an adult, and you don't want to START by being Segovia or Steve Vai, you may have a great advantage---a huge musical library in your head.

I would start by learning some chords...along with some simple skill sets....it will get your fingers moving, and it will enable you to PLAY SONGS QUICKLY.

Name 10 songs you'd like to play...... do you want to play "the song" or The Lead? Do you want to sing or be accompanied by a singer?

Take it from a terrible guitar player.  
Thankyoueli : 11/25/2019 7:25 pm : link
1000% start on electric, easier to play by a longshot. I'd reccomend a fender squier which is like $100 and is pretty much the classic go-to for beginners. Has a great feel for inexperienced hands, definitely stay away from anything with a bulky neck like a gibson/epiphone.

As far as lessons, figure out the style that interests you and youtube youtube youtube.

When I started playing I was 23 years old (I'm 29 today), had zero musical ability and never once touched an instrument. I knew going into it that I would never be good by virtually any standard. Well guess what.. I was right lol HOWEVER where I have FAR exceeded any expectation I had for myself especially after being absolutely nowhere a year into it.

I get so much satisfaction coming home, throwing on a backing track and just improvising over it. That's pretty much all i ever wanted to do. I can put on a jam in any key and just play over it endlessly.

The beginning wont always be fun, it will be frustrating as hell at times and you'll look at some things and say jesus christ I'll never be able to do that. If you watch Steve Vai, Frank Zappa, Buckethead etc. yeah you probably wont. But there are plenty of things that you'll see and one day be shocked at how easy it actually is despite how impossibly daunting it seemed through a beginner's lens. It's such a cliche, one that you will surely hear a billion times over but it really is all about sticking to it. You WILL go further than you couldve imagined. Just focus on having fun.

One last thing, something I wish I was told as a beginner: SMALL movements= speed. If you aspire to be a shred god, sit down and pretend like your drawing the worlds smallest "I" just go up and down and up and down, literally like 2 centimeters of range as fast as you can while keeping your forearm completely stationary.

As for your left hand, when your fingers release a note they are naturally gonna want to flare way the fuck out. It's good to try and focus on making sure your fingers are always bent instead of being dead straight and are good position to press the note.

If you remember nothing else, remember this. TINY TINY range of motions is everything. Play as relaxed as possible, limit the tension.

I just wanted to explain that because if you're like most the first thing you will do after you get a guitar is try to learn a simple song you know from a YouTube lesson.. which is perfect, however they will teach you the NOTES but they often leave out the nuances that I wish someone had told me when I first started to really play RIGHT.

Anyway good luck on your journey and most importantly, enjoy!
Actually starting on an Acoustic is probably best  
Simms11 : 11/25/2019 7:37 pm : link
as it’s harder on the fingers. It will strengthen your fingers and create the calluses you’ll need to develop. Lastly, if you can master that, it’ll make playing an electric easier IMHO.
We all know why  
Mark from Jersey : 11/25/2019 8:29 pm : link
guys start wanting to play the guitar. Dont beat around the bush...no pun intended.

This is a must have accessory for any new guitar player. See link
Pedal - Link - ( New Window )
RE: Actually starting on an Acoustic is probably best  
DC Gmen Fan : 11/25/2019 8:46 pm : link
In comment 14691951 Simms11 said:
Quote:
as it’s harder on the fingers. It will strengthen your fingers and create the calluses you’ll need to develop. Lastly, if you can master that, it’ll make playing an electric easier IMHO.


^^^ this.

Start on an acoustic. Taylor, Yamaha, Martin, and Gibson make affordable good quality entry-level guitars.
Best advice I got when I started?  
dannysection 313 : 11/25/2019 8:57 pm : link
Leave the guitar out of the case....buy a guitar stand. You're much more likely to pick it up.

I'm in the start with an acoustic crowd and definitely buy an inexpensive one online-lot's of guitars sitting in people's closets after they purchased good guitars and gave up on learning.

I've been playing for years, what a great choice I happen to make years ago, inspired by Jerry, Duane, Clapton, Carlton, etc., so many opportunities to interact with people I never would have otherwise, and learning music theory is actually fun.

Yes, and the ladies love guitar players...
One more caveat to the acoustic vs electric debate  
Thankyoueli : 11/25/2019 9:15 pm : link
Which would you enjoy more? Are you a country kinda guy who wants to play over a campfire? Or are you a rocker who just wants to plug in, crank it up to 10, and fuckin jam?

As for the aspect of difficulty, which we all agree acoustic is much harder on beginner hands.. personally I think no matter what you're trying to learn it's best to start on the lowest difficulty level. Just like you would start by learning nirvana rather than dream theatre. Of course if you learn to ride a motor cycle you'll be able to ride a bicycle with training wheels, but its prob best to start on the latter lol that's just me.

Start on an acoustic.  
BigBlueBuff : 11/25/2019 9:40 pm : link
There are two types, the classical nylon string which has wider strings but easier action and the steel string acoustic. Get the latter, it will be harder on the fingers but is more versatile and will make any switch later seem really easy.

Also, get lessons. I'm a professional musician (not a guitaris) and having someone who knows what they are doing will save you a ton of time and effort in the long run. Even if you just get 5 or 6 to get started it will be invaluable.
I'm a big fan of Rocksmith  
santacruzom : 11/26/2019 1:47 am : link
It comes with a generous library across multiple genres, and there is also a community that has created hundreds of custom content (of admittedly variable quality). It's ultimately Guitar Hero that allows you to use an actual guitar. You can practice particular sections of a song at a slower speed and easy difficulty, and it will gradually speed up and increase difficulty as you are ready. It also has several arcade-style games that focus on particular technique development.

The best part, though, is that it absolutely nails the actual tones you hear in the songs you learn. It has a massive amount of very accurate effect and amplifier simulations, and when your tone approximates the real deal as you learn a song I find it much more inspiring.
start on acoustic  
Sonic Youth : 11/26/2019 1:56 am : link
learn songs you enjoy to listen to that are simple, that'll like to play. this speeds up the process.

don't give up and write your own music.

don't be afraid to jam out in your room when nobodys looking. like seriously, pretend you're on stage. this is supposed to be fun
Best piece of advice  
HoodieGelo : 11/26/2019 9:24 am : link
I can give is DON'T GIVE UP. It can get extremely frustrating but if you stick with it I promise it gets easier.

I say start with acoustic. Electric is easier to play but if you can get the fundamentals down on acoustic then you'll have a much better base and skill set.
Also,  
HoodieGelo : 11/26/2019 9:26 am : link
don't just learn songs. Knowing how to play "Blackbird" is not knowing how to play guitar, it's knowing how to play "Blackbird."

You want to learn the fundamentals so you know what you're playing and why.
Lots of great advice here...  
x meadowlander : 11/26/2019 9:39 am : link
...I WOULD recommend bringing a good guitarist with you when you buy - you want a guitar with GOOD ACTION foremost. Guitars that are hard to play turn players off. Go with light-gauge strings initially too.

I envy new players today. I WISH there was YouTube and all the awesome digital applications that are now available - I wish the quality of guitars was as good. Back in the 80's, cheap guitars were garbage. Nowadays, you can buy very good instruments under $300, even under $100 if you have a good eye and good luck.

Enjoy!!!
once you get guitar  
bc4life : 11/26/2019 10:02 am : link
pick it uo and do something with it for at least 15-20 minutes per day. then build from there.

pick a few guitarists that you like an do a lot of listening.

be humble, be very patient, it's a process
RE: Also,  
Sonic Youth : 11/26/2019 10:07 am : link
In comment 14692553 HoodieGelo said:
Quote:
don't just learn songs. Knowing how to play "Blackbird" is not knowing how to play guitar, it's knowing how to play "Blackbird."

You want to learn the fundamentals so you know what you're playing and why.
I really strongly disagree with this, especially at first.

If memory serves me correct, DaddyM89 is my age (30 - easy to remember the guys my age that were here since when we went to college there weren't many college guys on the board). At this point, getting music lessons or learning the theory behind songs isn't going to help get over the steep learning curve when time is limited in adult life.

Important thing is to have fun, learn songs you enjoy and are going to be 1) motivated to learn, and 2) play over and over again because you're having a good time.

What I WILL say is that definitely do not just learn riffs or parts of songs. Learn the whole thing and play the whole thing through.
RE: Lots of great advice here...  
Sonic Youth : 11/26/2019 10:09 am : link
In comment 14692578 x meadowlander said:
Quote:
...I WOULD recommend bringing a good guitarist with you when you buy - you want a guitar with GOOD ACTION foremost. Guitars that are hard to play turn players off. Go with light-gauge strings initially too.

I envy new players today. I WISH there was YouTube and all the awesome digital applications that are now available - I wish the quality of guitars was as good. Back in the 80's, cheap guitars were garbage. Nowadays, you can buy very good instruments under $300, even under $100 if you have a good eye and good luck.

Enjoy!!!

Light gauge strings is really in conflict with the vast majority of advice here saying to learn on an acoustic.

But honestly, while learning acoustic is better long term, if you're trying to get up and off the ground, learning on an easy to play electric guitar (low action) with 9 gauge strings is probably a better move.

I also disagree with the advice of buying guitars online. For your first few, and ESPECIALLY you're first one, you need to be in a store and play it in your hands.
RE: RE: Also,  
HoodieGelo : 11/26/2019 10:14 am : link
In comment 14692632 Sonic Youth said:
Quote:
In comment 14692553 HoodieGelo said:


Quote:


don't just learn songs. Knowing how to play "Blackbird" is not knowing how to play guitar, it's knowing how to play "Blackbird."

You want to learn the fundamentals so you know what you're playing and why.

I really strongly disagree with this, especially at first.

If memory serves me correct, DaddyM89 is my age (30 - easy to remember the guys my age that were here since when we went to college there weren't many college guys on the board). At this point, getting music lessons or learning the theory behind songs isn't going to help get over the steep learning curve when time is limited in adult life.

Important thing is to have fun, learn songs you enjoy and are going to be 1) motivated to learn, and 2) play over and over again because you're having a good time.

What I WILL say is that definitely do not just learn riffs or parts of songs. Learn the whole thing and play the whole thing through.


Oh 100%...I meant don't JUST learn to play songs. You want to get the basics down too. Obviously, one of the most fun and motivating things as a beginner is to play actual songs. I just meant don't go online and go through tutorials without knowing what the guy is talking about and just doing what he does.
RE: RE: Actually starting on an Acoustic is probably best  
Sonic Youth : 11/26/2019 10:30 am : link
In comment 14692039 DC Gmen Fan said:
Quote:
In comment 14691951 Simms11 said:


Quote:


as it’s harder on the fingers. It will strengthen your fingers and create the calluses you’ll need to develop. Lastly, if you can master that, it’ll make playing an electric easier IMHO.



^^^ this.

Start on an acoustic. Taylor, Yamaha, Martin, and Gibson make affordable good quality entry-level guitars.

It's been years since I worked at GC but isn't the lowest level Taylor (110) like already $650? Pricey for a beginner, though I guess you could snag one for $400 used.
I'm agnostic on the acoustic vs electric thing  
santacruzom : 11/26/2019 10:41 am : link
I would suggest just buying whichever is most suited towards the material you want to learn. If you want to learn how to play like, say, the Edge or David Gilmour, I don't see much benefit in trying to play their highly effected upper register riffs on acoustic just so you'll find it easier once you actually switch to electric.

I also am not sure about buying cheap just to buy cheap. There definitely have been improvements made in the quality of cheaper instruments, but if you (or yournfriend) try out an entry level Epiphone Les Paul and it just isn't doing it for you nearly as much as the Epiphone Les Paul standard that's 300 dollars more, get the latter. If it doesn't take, sell it.
RE: I'm agnostic on the acoustic vs electric thing  
Sonic Youth : 11/26/2019 10:52 am : link
In comment 14692719 santacruzom said:
Quote:
I would suggest just buying whichever is most suited towards the material you want to learn. If you want to learn how to play like, say, the Edge or David Gilmour, I don't see much benefit in trying to play their highly effected upper register riffs on acoustic just so you'll find it easier once you actually switch to electric.

I also am not sure about buying cheap just to buy cheap. There definitely have been improvements made in the quality of cheaper instruments, but if you (or yournfriend) try out an entry level Epiphone Les Paul and it just isn't doing it for you nearly as much as the Epiphone Les Paul standard that's 300 dollars more, get the latter. If it doesn't take, sell it.
I think acoustic vs electric matters more when you're learning as a kid, since it does actually help long term (IMO).

It also makes those first few open chords sound way better, which is inspiring.

Side note: If you go electric, get a cheap modeling amp with a footswitch so you can play around with some effects and get different sounds. You can get one for under $300, hell even under $100 if you go with a really small and used one.
I recommend light gauge strings because difficult axes...  
x meadowlander : 11/26/2019 10:59 am : link
...can turn beginners off.

That said, it's hard to find something truly difficult to play these days.

I learned on a nylon stringed Hondo, about the softest strings you could play, and even those left blisters initially.
I am a big proponent  
Rick5 : 11/26/2019 2:26 pm : link
of taking lessons with a really good teacher. I have been playing for 40 years now and play in a jazz quintet, and I still take monthly lessons (although always from top jazz pros now through skype). The online stuff is great, but (imo), there is nothing like having things individually tailored by a great teacher (and especially someone who stops bad technique habits from ever forming).
Some great advice on this thread  
Mike in Marin : 11/26/2019 2:49 pm : link
I get asked this a lot. I've been playing for about 40 years and play lead guitar in a professional Grateful Dead tribute band.

Here are a few thoughts (mostly echoing others):

1. Get a used acoustic on Craigslist, if possible. Spend about $2-300. The world is filled with guitars no one uses. Get someone you know who knows guitars to help you try it out. If money is not an issue, feel free to spend more of course. If you cannot get someone you know locally to help, consider other options like emailing people on here a link to the ads, going to a music store that has a great reputation, asking around for help.

2. I'd suggest getting something on the smaller side, just for ease of handling. OM or OOO size. OOO has slightly shorter scale length which makes strings easier to fret than an OM. Yamaha, Fender, Breedlove, Ibanez are potentially good brands for this range.

3. It's best to take lessons from someone because it will help motivate and keep you accountable to your goals. You can do a ton of free, extra studying online through YouTube, etc. But only once you have a bit of a foundation and understanding of a bit of musical theory.

4. Find a couple of easy songs that you really love early on. This will go a huge way towards keeping you motivated and falling in love with the instrument. Balance this with your less fun practicing for your lessons.

5. Try to practice daily for 20 minutes. Don't just noodle. Get a solid practice routine (take notes at lessons or ask teacher to clearly write down so you know exactly what to practice). These will be the building blocks to get you to your goals.

6. Don't get an electric guitar until you have gotten a lot better. It's a distraction, too easy to play sloppily (especially with distortion), and will distract you towards making noise rather than playing the guitar properly.

7. Find a great teacher by asking around a lot. They might be able to help with #1.

Good luck !



Thanks everyone for the advice!  
DaddyM89 : 11/26/2019 10:32 pm : link
I will be looking over this and trying to make the most educated decision on where to go from here. Realistically will probably start out in January after the Holidays when everything calms down. Thanks again BBI comes through yet again!
by the way sonic youth  
DaddyM89 : 11/26/2019 10:37 pm : link
you nailed It - 30 on the dot! Thanks for being such a good dude throughout the years!
Start with the acoustic  
LeftHook : 11/27/2019 11:31 am : link
You should start with an acoustic guitar because it is harder to play and will make you hands and fingers stronger much more quickly. Learn your basic chords and rock TFO. I use Ultimate Guitar website to look at songs you want to learn. They have some great forums for beginners. Once you learn basic chords. Check out The Nashville number system, it will show how songs are structured, using chord progressions in all keys. Rock on my brother. Advancing on you'll jump right into scales. Also check out JGuitar web sight.
before starting  
mdc1 : 11/28/2019 1:46 pm : link
know your goals and level of commitment.
if low, just enjoy the experience

if serious, avoid advertised methods and shortcuts, learn all the notes on the guitar, learn the major scale forms with index finger, middle, ring, pinky, for every target root on the fingerboard. The rest of the scales are derived from that (pentatonics, minor, melodic minor).

Learn to read rhythms. Learning triads, chords and beyond (intervals). btw chords are scales and vice versa. Learn to play melodies and phase and not play shred exercises. As an example, just learning one beginner piece out of the Jazz real book will teach you more about guitar than 100's of dollars worth method books.

Once you do that you can pretty much pick up just about anything reasonable and play it. Otherwise you will change how you play things so many times. A really good teacher can help with this, but not a guy/gal that is opinionated with their "kung fu" of guitar.

RE: Buy a used acoustic on Craigslist  
Defense56 : 11/28/2019 3:37 pm : link
In comment 14691871 Overseer said:
Quote:
you can get a decent one (Seagull S6 or Yamaha FG830) for ~200.

Then - and I cannot stress this enough for a beginner - get it professionally set up (patronize an independent store vs Guitar Center). ~$80.

They will, among other things, lower the "action" (space between strings & fretboard) for you which will make it much more playable. A beginner learning bar chords with high action will tear his hair out, get frustrated, and sabotage progress.

Then you suffer through the same 3-6 months all of us suffered through of learning your chords and switching smoothly without thinking between them. Google "Justin Guitar" and "Marty Music" for some good instructional videos. Pick some songs from artists you like (I played a lot of Neil Young when I started out) and it will help you with chords, strumming patterns, tempo, etc.

There's no such thing as "musically inclined". Great musicians got there because they practiced, practiced, practiced. Then when they were done with that, they practiced some more.

Good luck.


Marty Music is great. He's a fantastic teacher.
RE: before starting  
Rick5 : 11/30/2019 8:57 am : link
In comment 14694691 mdc1 said:
Quote:
know your goals and level of commitment.
if low, just enjoy the experience

if serious, avoid advertised methods and shortcuts, learn all the notes on the guitar, learn the major scale forms with index finger, middle, ring, pinky, for every target root on the fingerboard. The rest of the scales are derived from that (pentatonics, minor, melodic minor).

Learn to read rhythms. Learning triads, chords and beyond (intervals). btw chords are scales and vice versa. Learn to play melodies and phase and not play shred exercises. As an example, just learning one beginner piece out of the Jazz real book will teach you more about guitar than 100's of dollars worth method books.

Once you do that you can pretty much pick up just about anything reasonable and play it. Otherwise you will change how you play things so many times. A really good teacher can help with this, but not a guy/gal that is opinionated with their "kung fu" of guitar.


+1. The 2nd path requires at least two hours per day of practice though (which is what I get during the week with a little more on weekends). Are you still working through Bret Willmott's Harmony and Voicing book? It is in my regular practice rotation. I have picked up so many cool new voicing ideas, but that book has 15 lifetimes worth of material in it.
RE: RE: before starting  
mdc1 : 12/1/2019 11:47 am : link
In comment 14695721 Rick5 said:
Quote:
In comment 14694691 mdc1 said:


Quote:


know your goals and level of commitment.
if low, just enjoy the experience

if serious, avoid advertised methods and shortcuts, learn all the notes on the guitar, learn the major scale forms with index finger, middle, ring, pinky, for every target root on the fingerboard. The rest of the scales are derived from that (pentatonics, minor, melodic minor).

Learn to read rhythms. Learning triads, chords and beyond (intervals). btw chords are scales and vice versa. Learn to play melodies and phase and not play shred exercises. As an example, just learning one beginner piece out of the Jazz real book will teach you more about guitar than 100's of dollars worth method books.

Once you do that you can pretty much pick up just about anything reasonable and play it. Otherwise you will change how you play things so many times. A really good teacher can help with this, but not a guy/gal that is opinionated with their "kung fu" of guitar.




+1. The 2nd path requires at least two hours per day of practice though (which is what I get during the week with a little more on weekends). Are you still working through Bret Willmott's Harmony and Voicing book? It is in my regular practice rotation. I have picked up so many cool new voicing ideas, but that book has 15 lifetimes worth of material in it.


Yes, that book is a forever book. Good to hear you are working with that one as well. Check some of Garrison Fewells books, good upper extension solo basics and techniques from a melodic perspective to nail those changes with altered and other chord types.
RE: RE: RE: before starting  
Rick5 : 12/1/2019 9:49 pm : link
In comment 14696457 mdc1 said:
Quote:
In comment 14695721 Rick5 said:


Quote:


In comment 14694691 mdc1 said:


Quote:


know your goals and level of commitment.
if low, just enjoy the experience

if serious, avoid advertised methods and shortcuts, learn all the notes on the guitar, learn the major scale forms with index finger, middle, ring, pinky, for every target root on the fingerboard. The rest of the scales are derived from that (pentatonics, minor, melodic minor).

Learn to read rhythms. Learning triads, chords and beyond (intervals). btw chords are scales and vice versa. Learn to play melodies and phase and not play shred exercises. As an example, just learning one beginner piece out of the Jazz real book will teach you more about guitar than 100's of dollars worth method books.

Once you do that you can pretty much pick up just about anything reasonable and play it. Otherwise you will change how you play things so many times. A really good teacher can help with this, but not a guy/gal that is opinionated with their "kung fu" of guitar.




+1. The 2nd path requires at least two hours per day of practice though (which is what I get during the week with a little more on weekends). Are you still working through Bret Willmott's Harmony and Voicing book? It is in my regular practice rotation. I have picked up so many cool new voicing ideas, but that book has 15 lifetimes worth of material in it.



Yes, that book is a forever book. Good to hear you are working with that one as well. Check some of Garrison Fewells books, good upper extension solo basics and techniques from a melodic perspective to nail those changes with altered and other chord types.

Yeah. I have a couple of his too. The one I am focusing on the most recently is David Berkman's book on reharmonization (which is really nicely done).
Back to the Corner