cowgirls question

Has been the Eagles (since the Giants suns Skins have been garbage)
And

The organization has given you playmakers at several positions and you have NOT even been in the NFC championship game or won more than 2 playoff games in that span

That means you suck as a HC.

I can’t believe no one has discussed Garrett at all this past week...

on tv. The talent is top 5 in the league, namely because they have drafted well and they have a massive massive discount at QB. Rod Marinelli is a problem though I think, his philosophy is starting to look outdated because teams are built to dink and dunk all the way down the field now. I used to think it was a competitive disadvantage having him on the sidelines, but now I think he is going to be shown the door pretty soon with Garrett and I don't think he finds another position.

is not what it use to be the last number of years.

Look at New England and how they play against. The NFC east is not the different. The competition,is just not there in this division.

3 division titles and never made it out of the divisional round of the playoffs.

This is how low the Giants organization has fallen. Jason Garrett looks good.

the better part of a decade, winning 3 out of 5 isn't some grand achievement. Garrett is better than Shurmur, but I'd hope for better.

All you need to know is that Jerry Jones would fly Garrett to NY for his Giants' interview.

In comment 14703673 Ben in Tampa said:

Quote:

3 division titles and never made it out of the divisional round of the playoffs. This is how low the Giants organization has fallen. Jason Garrett looks good.

I never quite understood this argument. There are going to be very few coaches available that haven't had a decent amount of losing seasons the last few years. If they were winning they would still be employed in most cases. The winning coach that gets fired is rather rare.

by Jerry Jones. who know what kind of coach he is other than a glorified yes man. The problem is you don't know what your getting when the Giant ownership is way laid back compared to Jerry. Of the names that have been mentioned I would go either Garrett or Rivera if you are not going to poach a Tomlin or someone like him.

I think he’s a good HC. Why? Because Dallas was worse off before he took over and he gets the most out of his players. I think it’s unfair to define or condemn certain HC based on one or two big moments where their respective team failed to win BIG. I try to look at the big picture. Who’s helping who here? Is dak covering up for Garrett or the other way around? All I keep hearing is dak fucking sucks and is limited and will could never possibly be a true franchise qb yet the guy is close to the top in nearly every statistical category. He was a 4th round pick who has done nothing but win and produce since DAY 1. Zeke is a shitty human being yet he’s been a near perfect rb for Dallas. The Dallas D was an absolute joke for a while but got better and better under garret.

Cherry picking one or two playoff losses or one or two moments while indicting Garrett is awfully convenient. I’ll say it again, who is helping who in Dallas? Everyone loves to kill Jones and zeke and dak. Can’t have it both ways. Someone is doing something right down there. The guy hasn’t had a terrible season since 2015 when the entire team got hurt, including the qb.