metric you use on the offenses ranking. In yards, they were top 5 twice and top 10 3 times in Garrett's OC tenure. Points is different. Look to the right side of the table linked Dallas Yearly Records and Rankings - ( New Window )
So Ralph V used total yards instead of points scored to make that comment. I guess he wanted to support his agenda (promote Garrett) with more convincing stats. Me personally, I prefer total points over yards...might have red zone issues.
Either way shows a better than average to a very good offense
good for Jones is a foolish reason for the hire. We have a QB coach whose job is to coach the QB, we need an OC who is good for the whole Offense game plan...
how comfortable a brand new HC would feel about having a
OC, who spent 10 years as a HC working alongside him?
I have to believe this interview most likely came from Mara and DG, just a guess.
I mean Garrett did play here for a couple years
as a backup to Kerry Collins, so the Giants have always liked him.
He did a good job with Romo in Dallas,
especially when he was just getting started as a
QB there. I think Wade Phillips was the HC then, until he got axed.
They could do worse than Garrett,
and probably will if they don't hire him, LOL.
there were a number of posters who said if we have a young HC, he needs to bring in experienced coordinators. Then when it is rumored he will, people are freaking out that the coordinators are going to be pressing for the HC job or intimidating the young guy with their mere presence on the sidelines.
And of course the logical offshoot of that is that Mara and DG are forcing the hire. Shhesh.
That Garrett or somebody else would be 'pressing' for
the HC position. I am simply stating that a guy who was a long shot to become the HC in the first place, and has never been a HC before, just might not be extremely comfortable with the possible hiring at the outset.
It doesn't mean it couldn't work.
As i said, I believe that Mara and the GM most likely
talked to Judge about interviewing Garrett.
I mean, they do like Garrett, from his time here as a player, and from afar.
there were a number of posters who said if we have a young HC, he needs to bring in experienced coordinators. Then when it is rumored he will, people are freaking out that the coordinators are going to be pressing for the HC job or intimidating the young guy with their mere presence on the sidelines.
And of course the logical offshoot of that is that Mara and DG are forcing the hire. Shhesh.
Are you doing the old 'BBI sez' thing again? Because you and I both know you're referring to different posters and different opinions there.
So basically - taken as a whole, BBI is all over the place regarding a potential Jason Garrett hire. Did or should you have expected differently? Some people didn't like the Judge hire, some loved it. Some people liked Garrett as a potential HC, some hated him. Why would you expect some sort of magical harmonization of opinion at this point given how people's opinions diverged so greatly before he was an OC candidate?
Quote:
metric you use on the offenses ranking. In yards, they were top 5 twice and top 10 3 times in Garrett's OC tenure. Points is different. Look to the right side of the table linked Dallas Yearly Records and Rankings - ( New Window )
So Ralph V used total yards instead of points scored to make that comment. I guess he wanted to support his agenda (promote Garrett) with more convincing stats. Me personally, I prefer total points over yards...might have red zone issues.
Either way shows a better than average to a very good offense
OC, who spent 10 years as a HC working alongside him?
I have to believe this interview most likely came from Mara and DG, just a guess.
I mean Garrett did play here for a couple years
as a backup to Kerry Collins, so the Giants have always liked him.
He did a good job with Romo in Dallas,
especially when he was just getting started as a
QB there. I think Wade Phillips was the HC then, until he got axed.
They could do worse than Garrett,
and probably will if they don't hire him, LOL.
And of course the logical offshoot of that is that Mara and DG are forcing the hire. Shhesh.
the HC position. I am simply stating that a guy who was a long shot to become the HC in the first place, and has never been a HC before, just might not be extremely comfortable with the possible hiring at the outset.
It doesn't mean it couldn't work.
As i said, I believe that Mara and the GM most likely
talked to Judge about interviewing Garrett.
I mean, they do like Garrett, from his time here as a player, and from afar.
And of course the logical offshoot of that is that Mara and DG are forcing the hire. Shhesh.
Are you doing the old 'BBI sez' thing again? Because you and I both know you're referring to different posters and different opinions there.
So basically - taken as a whole, BBI is all over the place regarding a potential Jason Garrett hire. Did or should you have expected differently? Some people didn't like the Judge hire, some loved it. Some people liked Garrett as a potential HC, some hated him. Why would you expect some sort of magical harmonization of opinion at this point given how people's opinions diverged so greatly before he was an OC candidate?
Because when the usual 5-7 openings occur at the end of 2020, Garrett will be on everyone's short list. And Garrett will definitely want back in...