Bomani Jones says McNabb was better than Eli

In comment 14792586 Tuckrule said:

Quote:

Good points about the offensive line, Reid and the defense. However we can use that same argument about the weak division with Brady and the pats but nobody seems to.

Sure we can. Brady has definitely been supported with a weak division, the greatest Coach of all time and a strong roster.

If people would take a look at QB's stats objectively (Bradshaw, Aikman) objectively they will see their stats diminished as the teams around them did. The HOF's put the team over the top when enough of a supporting team exists imo. I think McNabb had the team.

Eli beats him in TD's, Yards, Completion %, Super Bowl MVPs, TD %, Game-winning drives, YPA, Yards per game, Completions, Games played.
link - ( New Window )

McNabb puked on the field.

Case closed.

THROWING UP IN THE HUDDLE
McNabb 1
Manning 0

did win 3 Super Bowls, right? He's better than Eli at using a sideline phone and vomiting too.

or maybe not.

guy wont like anything the giants do ever.

That plays well in the media.

.

In comment 14792444 Jimmy Googs said:

Quote:

and one of them earned MVP twice, and one of them vomited in the huddle. That's all I have to say about that...

LOL 👍

In comment 14792474 Chris in Philly said:

Quote:

The Master

In comment 14792466 Jints in Carolina said:

Quote:

for the newspaper...and he in local sports radio from time to time....he thinks he's the smartest man in the room. He's a blow hard.

I�ve lived in Raleigh for more than 25 years and I�ve never heard the name before ... I guess he�s one of those legends in his own mind ...in any event, he can kiss my ass.

than Eli. However Eli was a better pure passer. For a 5 year span (2000-2005)McNabb was the most dangerous QB. I know McNabb and Romo are underappreciated around here but both those guys were better than Eli.

In comment 14792900 compton said:

Quote:

than Eli. However Eli was a better pure passer. For a 5 year span (2000-2005)McNabb was the most dangerous QB. I know McNabb and Romo are underappreciated around here but both those guys were better than Eli.

Amani Toomer? Is that YOU?

McNabb - 3
Eli - 11

4,000+ yard passing seasons

McNabb - 0
Eli - 7

I�m sure if Eli played for Andy Reid his entire career his numbers would be worse than they are now.

I can�t take stupid anymore. And I can�t take these unfounded, boring hot takes. Cool you said something. Congrats. Now fuck off.

Seriously I've never heard of him.

Andy Reid was so impressed by his own "Genius" that He starved the Eagle offense of Impact Players---short the brief TO "Era". The Latter and recent portion of Reids Career doesn't feature that mistake.

McNabb was a Great Player. Some of my Philly Friends used to criticize McNabb....I'd ask them to name 5 better contemporary QB's and they began babbling after #3.

In comment 14793223 Rafflee said:

Quote:

Andy Reid was so impressed by his own "Genius" that He starved the Eagle offense of Impact Players---short the brief TO "Era". The Latter and recent portion of Reids Career doesn't feature that mistake. McNabb was a Great Player. Some of my Philly Friends used to criticize McNabb....I'd ask them to name 5 better contemporary QB's and they began babbling after #3.

Great is not the right word. Definitely very good. A 6X pro bowler.

But not a good team leader. A real divisive jack ass...

In comment 14792474 Chris in Philly said:

Quote:

This photo is legendary. ALL YEAR BABY!!!