I can't remember another subject like it during my nearly 20 years on this site. Eli kind of, I guess, is the only other one.
This horse has been beaten to glue. We know some people despise the Barkley pick. We know some people love the Barkley pick. We know some people would have been cool with a trade down but understand and are okay with picking Barkley.
I don't really know what there is left to discuss on it other than to agree to disagree on what could've, should've, would've happened. What's done is done.
I don't really know what there is left to discuss on it other than to agree to disagree on what could've, should've, would've happened. What's done is done.
Probably then a good signal for you to bow out, and not jump in when others are having perfectly enjoyable conversation on a topic you aren't interested in?
Well, when people stop bringing it up on EVERY thread, Â
The Barkley pick is controversial, and it is going to be second guessed until the Giants win super bowl with him as a major contributor, or he is gone without a SB... It will likely die down some, but not all the way, if DG is gone.
It was such pivotable moment in Giant's history, that is stands above all others for the foreseeable future.
As you know, I hated the pick at the time, and to this day I believe it was a colossal mistake. I want to be clear though. I for one am first and foremost a Giants fan. I want all this to work out and for the Giants to be adding to their trophy case. So if there is some middle ground being sought, rest assured, that I have accepted the Barkley pick and I for one root for Barkley every time he is out there. I root for Daniel Jones every time he is out there. I root for every player on the roster to do well. However, there is a big difference, for me at least, between rooting, and looking at the team with a critical lens.
Lol. Oh Britt.
This horse has been beaten to glue. We know some people despise the Barkley pick. We know some people love the Barkley pick. We know some people would have been cool with a trade down but understand and are okay with picking Barkley.
I don't really know what there is left to discuss on it other than to agree to disagree on what could've, should've, would've happened. What's done is done.
It’s not one subject.
Probably then a good signal for you to bow out, and not jump in when others are having perfectly enjoyable conversation on a topic you aren't interested in?
It made it about 10 posts and here we are, 200 later.
It was such pivotable moment in Giant's history, that is stands above all others for the foreseeable future.
As you know, I hated the pick at the time, and to this day I believe it was a colossal mistake. I want to be clear though. I for one am first and foremost a Giants fan. I want all this to work out and for the Giants to be adding to their trophy case. So if there is some middle ground being sought, rest assured, that I have accepted the Barkley pick and I for one root for Barkley every time he is out there. I root for Daniel Jones every time he is out there. I root for every player on the roster to do well. However, there is a big difference, for me at least, between rooting, and looking at the team with a critical lens.