A stunning fact about the Giants 2019 coaching staff

check into how many camp cuts from last year were signed by other teams. Don't worry it won't take you very long.

In comment 14812096 Giantsfan79 said:

Quote:

check into how many camp cuts from last year were signed by other teams. Don't worry it won't take you very long.

How many of them are still being paid by the Giants?

Don’t want to stay unemployed too long even if they are still being paid.

McAdoo sat out like an idiot the last two years. IMO. lucky to get a QB coaching job. He was a career TE coach w a couple of years as a QB coach. Stretch hire as a OC. Major stretch hire as a HC then sits out two years.

Most of these guys are going to have to take a step back. After the last two years they need too. Don’t wish anyone to lose their job but boy that staff was just horrible

In comment 14812117 LauderdaleMatty said:

Quote:

Don’t want to stay unemployed too long even if they are still being paid. McAdoo sat out like an idiot the last two years. IMO. lucky to get a QB coaching job. He was a career TE coach w a couple of years as a QB coach. Stretch hire as a OC. Major stretch hire as a HC then sits out two years. Most of these guys are going to have to take a step back. After the last two years they need too. Don’t wish anyone to lose their job but boy that staff was just horrible

Bettcher was horrendous. If it was all young guys I could have maybe given him the benefit of the doubt. But they brought in at least 5 of his former Cardinal players who knew his system and they still sucked.

an NFL coach. He was out of football in 2017 and Shurmur thought it was a good idea to bring him in as OL coach. After two dismal years, can't see anyone hiring him.

I think Shurmur is a good offensive mind but he sure seemed to be in over his head when it came to putting a staff together and holding them accountable for their own performance and the performance of their units.

Parcells would tell his staff "You SOBs aren't going to get me fired." Shurmur probably would have been fired anyway, but his staff sure greased the skids.

In comment 14812117 LauderdaleMatty said:

Quote:

Don’t want to stay unemployed too long even if they are still being paid. McAdoo sat out like an idiot the last two years. IMO. lucky to get a QB coaching job. He was a career TE coach w a couple of years as a QB coach. Stretch hire as a OC. Major stretch hire as a HC then sits out two years. Most of these guys are going to have to take a step back. After the last two years they need too. Don’t wish anyone to lose their job but boy that staff was just horrible

I don't think anyone wanted him as an OC so this is about what he could get at this point.

In comment 14812142 Dave on the UWS said:

Quote:

an NFL coach. He was out of football in 2017 and Shurmur thought it was a good idea to bring him in as OL coach. After two dismal years, can't see anyone hiring him.

He crippled Andrew Luck.

In comment 14812164 81_Great_Dane said:

Quote:

I think Shurmur is a good offensive mind but he sure seemed to be in over his head when it came to putting a staff together and holding them accountable for their own performance and the performance of their units.

Yes it was, and it seems like a tell that Mara and DG thought more highly of PS than many assistants and coordinators did.

In comment 14812117 LauderdaleMatty said:

Quote:

Don’t want to stay unemployed too long even if they are still being paid. McAdoo sat out like an idiot the last two years. IMO. lucky to get a QB coaching job. He was a career TE coach w a couple of years as a QB coach. Stretch hire as a OC. Major stretch hire as a HC then sits out two years. Most of these guys are going to have to take a step back. After the last two years they need too. Don’t wish anyone to lose their job but boy that staff was just horrible

I wouldn't call McAdoo an idiot for that necessarily. He wasn't getting any OC offers, and I have to imagine that NYG HC money still rolling in was worth sitting out. Probably won't be an NFL HC ever again, that was once-in-a-lifetime $ he would have just forfeited. All just to be a QB coach somewhere just to stay relevant? I'm sure he weighed his options the last couple years and considered the $ he would have lost. Meanwhile he still made it back in the league as a QB coach which is probably what he would have been anyway if he had come back in 2018 or 2019.

So, in hindsight, what do you see that this "idiot" could have done differently that would have benefited him more than the decisions he ended up making?

They must be knocking down his door based on his success here ! Oh wait....neither are true

to quote a famous American

Total duds.

the guy who allegedly can't keep his hands off sorority gals, can't stay an NFL coach long enough, as is interviewing for every college HC job he can.

O guess he's a really good coach, even if not so much a good person?