A lot of posters here criticize the NFL for greed, rule changes, etc, but the sport is as healthy as ever. Ratings and popularity through the roof.
Meanwhile, MLB isn’t even close to coming back after the players rejected the most recent proposal from the owners. NBA & NHL have a clear plan while MLB isn’t anywhere close.
The sport is pretty much irrelevant nationally, it doesn’t move the needle at all. If they don’t play this year, it will only get worse. Pretty pathetic by both sides here.
Link - (
New Window )
I couldn't care if the NFL was the only sport on TV- I would watch it if you paid me. You could give me a choice between watching paint dry and watching hockey. Paint will win every time. Could care less if the NFL folded tomorrow.
The NBA gets the fan experience- but unfortunately, it will be without for a while. THe NBA had personalities, fans right up to the edge of the action and loud indoor arenas. Could teams pretend to care about defense, sure- but it gets old fast- look at the Pistons from the 90's.
With that said, MLB is just the first sport that admits its money problems. Neither side is willing to be the one to eat the losses, so you are seeing all the posturing about splits and salary cuts. The problem with MLB is that it expanded into too many small markets that simply cannot compete with financial powerhouses like LA, NYC, Boston or Chicago. The Milwaukees, Kansas Citys, Tampas and Pittsbughs are the problem- can't and wont' compete, so their owners expect everyone else to subsidize them- and the commish goes along.
You want to see fighting, wait until the NFL and NBA have to knock tens of millions off the salary caps next season. The TV contracts won't be anything like what the NFL was planning- and without full stadiums (not happening in 2020)- then we will see strife. People getting their jollies off on MLBs fighting are due for a reality check next spring.
I couldn't care if the NFL was the only sport on TV- I would watch it if you paid me. You could give me a choice between watching paint dry and watching hockey. Paint will win every time. Could care less if the NFL folded tomorrow.
The NBA gets the fan experience- but unfortunately, it will be without for a while. THe NBA had personalities, fans right up to the edge of the action and loud indoor arenas. Could teams pretend to care about defense, sure- but it gets old fast- look at the Pistons from the 90's.
With that said, MLB is just the first sport that admits its money problems. Neither side is willing to be the one to eat the losses, so you are seeing all the posturing about splits and salary cuts. The problem with MLB is that it expanded into too many small markets that simply cannot compete with financial powerhouses like LA, NYC, Boston or Chicago. The Milwaukees, Kansas Citys, Tampas and Pittsbughs are the problem- can't and wont' compete, so their owners expect everyone else to subsidize them- and the commish goes along.
You want to see fighting, wait until the NFL and NBA have to knock tens of millions off the salary caps next season. The TV contracts won't be anything like what the NFL was planning- and without full stadiums (not happening in 2020)- then we will see strife. People getting their jollies off on MLBs fighting are due for a reality check next spring.
LOL - you criticize the NHL for "letting everyone in the playoffs", yet the NBA actually fewer number of teams left out of playoff (15 for NHL, 14 for NBA).
NHL actually has the most constant action of any major sport, but don't let facts get in the way...
Oh, and if you "could care less", that means you actually care a great deal about it. The phrase you might want to use is "couldn't care less".
Carry on...
I haven't seen a season proposal, but it's the bottom of the pay scale players who will crack IMO because that 434k may mean more to them than the 7.8M to the player who is making $35M in the example (just IMO)
@JesseRogersESPN
Sources: Under MLB proposal to players, a player making $35 mil in 2020 would make about $7.8 mil. A player making 10 mil would get about 2.9 mil and a player making a mil would make $434k.
This. And after the reduced schedule and cutback I thnk players would only be making 33% of what their salaries would have been.
Quote:
the problems....
This. And after the reduced schedule and cutback I thnk players would only be making 33% of what their salaries would have been.
After seeing PJ's thread, it is less than 33%.
Quote:
In comment 14911200 Crazed Dogs said:
Quote:
the problems....
This. And after the reduced schedule and cutback I thnk players would only be making 33% of what their salaries would have been.
After seeing PJ's thread, it is less than 33%.
Jason Collette
@jasoncollette
·
10m
So that’s a:
-78% paycut
-71% paycut
-57% paycut
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
· 9m
Potential salary cuts in MLB plan, sources tell @JesseRogersESPN and me:
Full-year Proposal
$563.5K $262K
$1M $434K
$2M $736K
$5M $1.64M
$10M $2.95M
$15M $4.05M
$20M $5.15M
$25M $6.05M
$30M $6.95M
$35M $7.84M
and an independent auditor since no one trusts MLB bookkeepers.
Or..like I said before, some of the players get desperate.
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
· 54m
Seen another way: 82-game prorated salaries vs. MLB's proposal
Full Proposal
prorated
$285K $262K
$506K $434K
$1.01M $736K
$2.53M $1.64M
$5.06M $2.95M
$7.59M $4.05M
$10.1M $5.15M
$12.7M $6.05M
$15.2M $6.95M
$17.7M $7.84M
@JeffPassan
· 1h
The Oakland A's informed minor league players today that they would not continue paying them $400 a week after the end of the month, sources familiar with the situation told ESPN.
Other decisions from organizations should arrive in the coming days. A bad sign to start, though.
The MLB Unifirm Player Contract contains this language:
“... and subject also to the right of the Commissioner to suspend the operation of this contract during any national emergency during which Major League Baseball is not played.”
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
·
2h
Just some rough math. Say there are 200 players in a minor league system. Paying each $400/week for July, July and August is $5,200 per player. To pay every minor leaguer would have cost the Oakland A's a hair over $1 million.
Owner John Fisher is worth an estimated $2 billion.
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
·
2h
Just some rough math. Say there are 200 players in a minor league system. Paying each $400/week for July, July and August is $5,200 per player. To pay every minor leaguer would have cost the Oakland A's a hair over $1 million.
Owner John Fisher is worth an estimated $2 billion.
I am playing Devil's advocate here. That will be his argument. This is why I say the league should pool ALL revenues for this season. This is a disgusting policy. How do teams expect to play without minor leagues below them?
They're going to expand the 40 man roster to 50, and have that entire roster with the team all year. The likelihood that a team would have a need for a minor leaguer outside that pool of 50 seems awfully low.
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
·
2h
Just some rough math. Say there are 200 players in a minor league system. Paying each $400/week for July, July and August is $5,200 per player. To pay every minor leaguer would have cost the Oakland A's a hair over $1 million.
Owner John Fisher is worth an estimated $2 billion.
Can probably make more collecting unemployment
Quote:
realist is as bad as the optics IMO.
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
·
2h
Just some rough math. Say there are 200 players in a minor league system. Paying each $400/week for July, July and August is $5,200 per player. To pay every minor leaguer would have cost the Oakland A's a hair over $1 million.
Owner John Fisher is worth an estimated $2 billion.
Can probably make more collecting unemployment
If they can file they will, I assume they're eligible for PUA which I think is federally added $600 per week to whatever your state pays.
I still think if the league can suspend the contract the player isn't under contract and should be able to declare free agency.
Quote:
In comment 14911334 pjcas18 said:
Quote:
realist is as bad as the optics IMO.
Jeff Passan
@JeffPassan
·
2h
Just some rough math. Say there are 200 players in a minor league system. Paying each $400/week for July, July and August is $5,200 per player. To pay every minor leaguer would have cost the Oakland A's a hair over $1 million.
Owner John Fisher is worth an estimated $2 billion.
Can probably make more collecting unemployment
If they can file they will, I assume they're eligible for PUA which I think is federally added $600 per week to whatever your state pays.
I still think if the league can suspend the contract the player isn't under contract and should be able to declare free agency.
Not if the contract says the commish can suspend play in a national emergency..
I thought that the 1st plan was based on a shortened season, but with spectators? Baseball makes a lot of money off tickets and concessions. Not sure some of these teams could afford paying salaries with empty stadiums and no concession sales..
+1
Its called seeing the long picture - lots of large corporations this year will suffer some losses but while protecting the livelihoods and health of their employees... and they'll be rewarded over the long-term for that.
Oh and no one believes MLB's books either
something like that I think may make it more equitable for the players.
Kyle Glaser
@KyleAGlaser
·
30m
Add the Marlins to the list of teams who will continue paying their minor leaguers. Miami will continue giving its minor leaguers $400 per week.
Kyle Glaser
@KyleAGlaser
·
30m
Add the Marlins to the list of teams who will continue paying their minor leaguers. Miami will continue giving its minor leaguers $400 per week.
Also, not sure you know what you're talking about. From what I can find, only 4 teams have publicly stated plans for paying their minor leaguers. The White Sox, Marlins and Phillies all announced plans to continue to paying their players - though the phillies said the $400 might be lower. Only the A's said otherwise. So far.
Its called seeing the long picture - lots of large corporations this year will suffer some losses but while protecting the livelihoods and health of their employees... and they'll be rewarded over the long-term for that.
Oh and no one believes MLB's books either
Well said. And the owners know they can win the PR battle, "look at these greedy players who refuse to still play for millions while a significant amount of people remain unemployed!"
It's BS, this group of Owners, with spineless Manfred doing their bidding, are absolutely killing Baseball. There is no eye on the bigger picture, just short term profit. If they can't find a way to play this season, the sport may never fully recover.
@JonHeyman
·
1h
Union leadership, many top agents and surely highly-paid star players are upset by MLB proposal (“barely worth a response”), but many lower-paid players may have different reax. Know this: 65% of MLB players make $1M or less and off prorated pay they still get at most a 15% cut.
Sports owners have forever taken advantage of the emotional response that sports brings to people and have benefited greatly from a closed market for each of their respective leagues.
They'll never drum up that much sympathy from me.
1) How do you play baseball without minor leagues ? This isn't football where you have a practice squad. The minor leaguers have to play games to be viable as call ups, but they won't be able to. In football you play one day a week and practice 5 days. In baseball you play every day. There is no time for these minor leaguers to do any meaningful work.
2) The proposed COVID protocols are ridiculous. Players not in the game can't be on the bench ? Players are expected to social distance on the base paths ? This is going to make putting in a pinch hitter as slow as making a pitching change. The whole flow of the game is going to be disruptive to players and boring for viewers.
3) What about reporters and announcers ? Having them remote doesn't work. For example when a player hits a fly ball how does the announcer know whether its a pop up or a home run ? Unless its an obvious moonshot he watches how the players react. Otherwise from a broadcast booth its difficult to tell the difference between a pop up or a fly ball to the outfield. It won't work from a remote monitor.
I suspect many owners and many players really don't want to play. The smaller markets are going to have a negative cash flow as it is. What happens if a significant number of players want to sit the season out, the money be damned. If the product they put out there is perceived as a farce its going to be even worse for the owners.
Quote:
Jon Heyman
@JonHeyman
·
1h
Union leadership, many top agents and surely highly-paid star players are upset by MLB proposal (“barely worth a response”), but many lower-paid players may have different reax. Know this: 65% of MLB players make $1M or less and off prorated pay they still get at most a 15% cut.
Lol what kind of logic is that.... at most a 15% cut.... off a prorated pay amount (which is their annual salary). You are asking lower paid players to take a 57.5%-plus paycut for their 2020 take home pay. End of story.
of the players dont play and teams lose money you will see more teams go the way of the Marlins and Pirates and load up on minmimum contract guys. There is already to many teams crying poor and gicing up on this season before the pandemic it will double next year.
Players are painted into a corner and MLB knows it
I understand how contracts work, but if there's no basbeall nobody at the networks makes nickel. I think we can all agree that there are a little different cirumstances than normal.
Quote:
.
I understand how contracts work, but if there's no basbeall nobody at the networks makes nickel. I think we can all agree that there are a little different cirumstances than normal.
If theres no baseball the networks dont have to pay the fees to broadcast it. What incetive do they have to pay more for it?
You can argue about the players union all you want, but MLB owners have repeatedly acted in bad faith, shielding revenue from the MLBPA (such as RSN revs).
The NBA and, to a lesser degree, the NFL have been much more transparent about revenues, and therefore haven't had the number of work stoppages that MLB has. Another lost WS would be really damaging to a sport already struggling to attract fans.
I think you are right. And the nature of how baseball is played makes it a risky proposition.
@dennistlin
· 27m
The Padres plan to continue paying their minor-leaguers $400 per week through the end of August, a source tells The Athletic.
Is that for the full 52 weeks? Even if it is, is that all minor league baseball players get paid? That's $20,000 if it's for the whole year. How do they live?
and they need to fold minor league teams?
? Lets keep it to the covid thread, there's a lot of evidence that unless we as a country continue to act like morons (e.g., treat this as a state/regional issue and not an age/conditions one) that there isnt "huge" risk in playing baseball this summer. South Korea is doing just fine. Germany, albeit early, seems to be doing fine.
And there are so many ways to disagree with you on the rest of it, that it's not even funny. Well, none of this is funny. But that part should go on the COVID thread.
Is that for the full 52 weeks? Even if it is, is that all minor league baseball players get paid? That's $20,000 if it's for the whole year. How do they live?
and they need to fold minor league teams?
Re contracts...wait until you see all the litigation over force majeure (sp?) clauses that is going to happen over the next several years.
Re contracts...wait until you see all the litigation over force majeure (sp?) clauses that is going to happen over the next several years.
So for a lot of the late round picks, who get small bonuses how much do they typically get paid?
For example when I look at the Mets 2019 draft results, 17th round Dan Goggin got a 10k bonus. Is he just making $400 per week (or 20K per year?)
Eric Sim
@esim69
·
Feb 14
Just a heads up A ball guys making $500/weekly is still only $2000/mo which the minor league season is 5 months so their salary for the year would be $10k before taxes, fees, clubhouse dues.
Still not getting paid for ST.
I mean I’m happy to see some increase, but do better."
Re contracts...wait until you see all the litigation over force majeure (sp?) clauses that is going to happen over the next several years.
I should be more clear. They obvi get meals and lodging on the road. I think there may be a meal allowance at home, but many players stay with host families, so they may either get very little for lodging at home or nothing at all. However you slice it, it's not a happy existence except for the guys who had gotten big bonuses.
@JonHeyman
· 14h
The added shame about the A’s halting $400 weekly stipends for minor leaguers is that they remain A’s employees — just unpaid employees — and can’t seek free agency or file for unemployment. With the move the A’s save about $1M to 1.2M. @stephapstein and @EmilyCWaldon on it
@JonHeyman
·
5m
If you wonder if/why teams can do this (and many did wonder), the Uniform Player Contract combined with the declaration of a National Emergency leaves little doubt they can. But so far the A’s are the only ones known to take this drastic step.
Quote:
Jon Heyman
@JonHeyman
· 14h
The added shame about the A’s halting $400 weekly stipends for minor leaguers is that they remain A’s employees — just unpaid employees — and can’t seek free agency or file for unemployment. With the move the A’s save about $1M to 1.2M. @stephapstein and @EmilyCWaldon on it
Quote:
Jon Heyman
@JonHeyman
·
5m
If you wonder if/why teams can do this (and many did wonder), the Uniform Player Contract combined with the declaration of a National Emergency leaves little doubt they can. But so far the A’s are the only ones known to take this drastic step.
And even if they do agree to play on reduced salary I cannot imagine they'd be willing to accept more cuts and/or freezes in reduction once the CBA expires. Seems like it's setting up for disaster.
Is this to avoid paying them? At least in this case they become free agents I imagine and can collect unemployment which is more than they were making.
While I will withhold judgment until I see the reports and ideally commentary, it's more humane than just suspending the contract like the A's did.
Michael Mayer
@mikemayerMMO
·
14s
Mets are informing minor leaguers of release this afternoon. Expected to be a significant number.
Robert Murray
@ByRobertMurray
·
25m
Expect most teams to make minor-league cuts in coming days. Said one agent: “40 players per team just got whacked so the club could save $50k/month. This is the equivalent of trying to save money by cutting out your daily Starbucks trip but still driving an X5 you can’t afford.”
@JonHeyman
· 2m
Mets are committed to paying minor leaguers the weekly $400 through the month of June
WTF Mets, hopefully they extend this. it's not like they're even saving $1M now, it's to save a couple hundred grand probably. I'll withhold judgment until I see facts. Doesn't matter much anyway, I already don't give the Mets any money.
@JonHeyman
· 2m
Mets are committed to paying minor leaguers the weekly $400 through the month of June
WTF Mets, hopefully they extend this. it's not like they're even saving $1M now, it's to save a couple hundred grand probably. I'll withhold judgment until I see facts. Doesn't matter much anyway, I already don't give the Mets any money.
Just going month to month which seems practical given the circumstances.
MLB had a real opportunity long term to grow the game by owning the month of July - people stuck at home, not traveling, thirsty for a distraction...
NHL and nba unable for whatever reason to get going before August ... what a real shame and embarrassment on both sides, moreso imo the owners but everyone just sucks in this
$100MM of player salaries (all from contracts >$10MM) to be deferred if the post-season is cancelled, to be paid in Nov 2021 and 2022
Players who are deemed "high-risk" could opt-out of the season for health concerns, while still receiving the same pro-rated salary as guys who play (apparently this would include players with spouses, kids or other live=in family who are high risk)
Expanded playoffs both this year and next year.
Heyman has already reported that an ownership source called the proposal a "non-starter". We'll see where they go from here.
link - ( New Window )
$100MM of player salaries (all from contracts >$10MM) to be deferred if the post-season is cancelled, to be paid in Nov 2021 and 2022
Players who are deemed "high-risk" could opt-out of the season for health concerns, while still receiving the same pro-rated salary as guys who play (apparently this would include players with spouses, kids or other live=in family who are high risk)
Expanded playoffs both this year and next year.
Heyman has already reported that an ownership source called the proposal a "non-starter". We'll see where they go from here.
link - ( New Window )
I don't know which proposal is worse, the owners or this one.
Opt out and get paid?
114 games is too much if they want a postseason. Cannot be playing baseball in snow.
I get MLB is in a shit position being that they didnt complete a large part of their season like NHL/NBA but still. Owners want to complete screw over the players by using their BS numbers and players want to act like nothing is wrong and get paid the same. I mean did i see that any player can opt out (high risk or not) and accrue service time? Are you kidding? Every person should have the right to opt out of their job but you dont get paid for it or get closer to a new contract. Like i said, both sides can go kick rocks. NBA/NHL will lead right into football.
As for # of games, i think its too much as well, but i suppose if you're not going to have fans anyway, then you can play a World Series on a neutral field in Florida or Arizona.
Do the networks have any say in that? Doubleheaders and more use of minor league players to get through all the innings... will drive some fatigue in viewership and overall lower ratings.