I believe we need to move Solder to right tackle for 2020 and let Thomas play left. Even as a rookie he is better than Solder who was terrible last year and will get Jones killed this year. He is not quick enough with his feet to handle the premier pass rushers. He was overrated because he protected Brady who got rid of the bell fast enough to not need as much protection. Who agrees Thomas at left tackle
The Solder decision, contract, and restructure have been a real mark on Gettleman's tenure.
Pound for pound I think it's the worst UFA acquisition the Giants have ever made.
The Solder decision, contract, and restructure have been a real mark on Gettleman's tenure.
Pound for pound I think it's the worst UFA acquisition the Giants have ever made.
DG had no other options other than Solder. I’ve been told.
Quote:
In comment 14915548 Angus said:
Quote:
Amateur coach that I am. I also think they should at least try Hernandez at left guard.
Hernandez has played left guard for 2 seasons.
All the more reason.
Awesome.
Watched him vs Auburn and man he is impressive. Moves people in the run game, really good feet in pass pro. Seemed aware of stunts and people crossing him. The Auburn DL has NFL people on there too. Just looked very polished, finished with proper anger and when he gets his hands on you its over.
Watched him vs Auburn and man he is impressive. Moves people in the run game, really good feet in pass pro. Seemed aware of stunts and people crossing him. The Auburn DL has NFL people on there too. Just looked very polished, finished with proper anger and when he gets his hands on you its over.
In a way we are blending two player personnel discussions with one positional discussion, you're correct.
I was in the Thomas camp from well before the draft; I thought he was the best OT available and thought him worthy of the 4th overall draft slot. So I though he was a better potential LT than Solder from the get go.
But there's another discussion about Solder's value relative to his cost, and also whether it's possible Solder has acome back year in 2020.
As I've noted I have perused just about every drop of Giants info available including podcasts by the beats and wannabe football pundits, and a few of the beats have remarked that the think Solder could have a HUGE comback year in 2020, based on info they have that we don't on two accounts.
1) Solder has been playing through injuries far worse than has been acknowledged, in both 2018 and 2019, and that this is the first year as a Giant he might enter the year, at least, injury free
2) is that the strain of managing and looking after his son through his battles with cancer have been far more disabling than the Giants or Solder have acknowledged.
Not just the obvious emotional strain, but the time consumption of the illness. Solder has, obviously with the Giants' full permission and support, missed lots of practice time last year (and presumably the year before too.)
Solder has spent many days flying back and forth to Boston, following his son's treatments and surgeries and supporting him through those.
"More time than you can imagine or than he's let on or talked about" according to Patty Traina, Paul Dottino, and John Schmeelk.
Solder really isn't THAT OLD for an OL, and if he and his son can get through a year healthy we may be underestimating his ability to come back to a plus level of play.
I guess we'll see soon enough, or not.
If he's going to be cut it will be only because of his play, IMO, not for cap space reasons. The Giants won't do that to a guy in his situation IMO.
The nature of age being such a factor in the NFL includes that injuries become more of an issue. His being banged up, or worse, having played through major injuries doesn't feel like a positive. Feels like a sign of things to come.
There are certainly the Peters, Whitworth, and Penn type players who play into their mid to late 30s, and there are myriad examples of guys with nice careers being done at his age.
The bottomline is he's played abysmal football, is on an abysmal contract, and the Giants just spent a top 5 pick to replace him.
I don't discount the personal and physical tole his time in NY has taken on him. I just wouldn't bet on a guy whose play has been in the virual basement, to return to anything approaching the value of his pay.
What happened to the turn over every stone Gettleman? That's what I want to see here. There are options. I think Beachum is a better, younger player, who will cost less than 10M.
This is dejavu. Another year where the most expensive player on the team has given no indication in the recent past he'll play up to his contract, and the justification is loyalty or a far flung hope he'll return to a level of play magically.
You can’t assume he isn’t looking to “turn over every stone” just because you don’t agree with the roster moves. Don’t discount Judge either, I believe he has more personnel say than Shurmur ever did.
If the Giants brass thoroughly assessed all options and came to a football based conclusion Nate Solder is a solid investment at that cost, coming off a 11 sack, 57 preasure, 4 holding penalty season -- that's a far more alarming prospect than them keeping him out of loyalty.
Just call it like it is, if the Giants don’t do what you would do then it must mean they aren’t trying trying hard enough to get better.
Just call it like it is, if the Giants don’t do what you would do then it must mean they aren’t trying trying hard enough to get better.
That's a pretty sassy conclusion.
How do you see it?
Like I said, and it isn’t just with Nate Solder, if the giants do not emulate your plan your conclusion is the same - that they aren’t looking into all options to improve.
Not really worth the back and forth on this.
Unfortunately, the likelihood is Solder isn’t going to play any better for the Giants in 2020 and he won’t be on the team much longer. But in 2020 he will be.
The guy who is creating the roster just finally brought in some options at tackle but hard to believe anybody should have enough confidence in those to just flat out cut Solder. Particularly with a new coaching staff in the door and a quarantine that has shrunk rookie practice and development time.
Grin and bear it.
I'm debating my opinion from my view, with the facts I feel support that view.
I am always happy to acknowledge when I'm wrong. I'm extra happy to acknowledge when I'm wrong, and the outcome is to the benefit of the Giants.
What's sassy is you assigning to me how I feel with little petty quips like:
Just call it like it is, if the Giants don’t do what you would do then it must mean they aren’t trying trying hard enough to get better..
I think the Giants try really hard. I just think they keep fucking it up.
I don't pretend to know how to run a football team. I do know how to run successful businesses. Paying old players who are arguably the worst at their jobs in the entire league, the very most in the entire league isn't very wise.
Quote:
It's dismaying that the best financial outcome for the Giants has Solder costing 26M against the cap in 20/22.
The Solder decision, contract, and restructure have been a real mark on Gettleman's tenure.
Pound for pound I think it's the worst UFA acquisition the Giants have ever made.
DG had no other options other than Solder. I’ve been told.
It was a horrible move in hindsight but at the time DG didn’t have many other options. I thought at the time that they overpaid for Solder but they couldn’t go into another season with Flowers at left tackle.
What if Solder is slightly better at LT and Thomas is much better at RT this summer?
Imv, the decision is about what combo of tackles is best for the offense this year.
Quote:
reason. If Thomas is our LT of the future, and Solder only has a year or two left, I want Thomas getting all the reps at LT now, even if Solder is slightly better. The guy spent the last several years at LT, so you're going to make him learn RT for a year or two and then switch him back? They're not quite as interchangeable as one might think. Let him get his reps and take hi lumps now.
What if Solder is slightly better at LT and Thomas is much better at RT this summer?
Imv, the decision is about what combo of tackles is best for the offense this year.
I think we have very little chance of being a legitimately competitive team this upcoming year so in this scenario we play Thomas at LT. I guess a good counter-argument is not getting Jones killed, but it can't be too much worse than last year, and really we're playing for 2021/2022.
Think long term in creating the best roster but play to win in short term.
Think long term in creating the best roster but play to win in short term.
I think I disagree but I definitely see your point. Maybe I'll start a new thread at some point to have this debate with everyone.
Grammar is overrated no one needs grammar its a waste of time and effort
Grammar is overrated no one needs grammar its a waste of time and effort
Ronnie Stanley was drafted 6th, Jack Conklin 8th, Laremy Tunsil 13th, and Taylor Decker 16th. FWIW, all 3 of them hard PFF grades above 75 this past year with Stanley earning a whopping 88.5 and earning first team All Pro.
Thomas is IMO a better prospect than Stanley was that year.
That's no guarantee he'll turn out as well, but there's a good chance he will. And pretty much every opinion I've heard about him is that he's the most ready of 2020's quartet of OTs.
I'm guessing he'll win the starting LT position right off if there's anything like a normal training camp, even if Solder does come in healthy and ready to have a bounce back year.
Quote:
at the end of training camp. Spending another 13 Million of cap space (between this year and next) is absurd. Williams is at least decent for his $16 Million and we now get a comp pick for him if he signs elsewhere. If we pay Solder this year, we still have to cut him next year and, hence, no comp pick even if someone were foolish enough to sign him.
Who will we be able to spend it on thats a definitive upgrade? Can't worry about how much he's making relative to his production - the money is spent. All that matters is what we will get out of him and whether or not its a better option than the alternative.
The comp pick compensation for cutting him likely isn't very high and would potentially be negated with future FA acquisitions.
1. Cap money rolls over, so while there's no one to spend it on now, there's still a benefit to saving that money (if the CS views other players as better options).
2. Players that are cut don't factor into comp picks.
3. Cutting Solder only saves $9.9M in total, which is his 2020 base salary. He's already been paid a $3M roster bonus this offseason and from a cap perspective has $6.5M in prorated bonus money against both the 2020 and 2021 salary caps.
It's often hyperbole, but it's quite true in this instance -- it would be difficult to be as bad as Solder was last year for Thomas and Fleming.
We're what, 3 years removed from having Flowers and Hart as our starting OTs. It's not that difficult to be worse than Solder.
Thomas starts RT. Plan A is that stays there, and Peart starts at LT in 2021. Looking at prototype physical characteristics, Peart projects better than Thomas as an LT, while Thomas projects better than Peart as an RT.
The other advantage is less shuffling is necessary as time goes by. Naturally the hurdle is Peart must develop more core strength to be ready to start next year.
Would I love an upgrade? Yes, I think anyone would. But I'm not going to pretend to claim anyone out there in FA is a definitive upgrade, not to mention said upgrade would have to come here, learn the offense, build rapport, etc all during a time where players are still isolated. Maybe Thomas is the upgrade and I hope he is, but that still means we'd have no depth if we didn't replace Solder this year.