All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
That is what I read - at a casino. After all that went on with the Marlins, you would think players would get it.
You know, just cancel their season, and shuffle the schedule if both Marlins and Cards are out. There needs to be a penalty.
This. If you can't follow the guidelines and you have an outbreak like we've seen now with the Marlins tough shit your season is over.
Suspend players, not teams.
Canceling a team's season wouldn't be fair to the players on that team that DO comply, nor would it be fair to the fans of those teams.
I seriously doubt Yankee fans on this thread would be advocating for the Yanks' season to be canceled if a handful of Yankee players did something stupid that resulted in positive tests.
before the HR. Loafed after that ball and made a weak attempt at it. He usually gets there and is waiting
Re-sign Tanaka. Let Paxton go at this moment. Could change, but right now this version of Paxton is useless.
All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
That is what I read - at a casino. After all that went on with the Marlins, you would think players would get it.
You know, just cancel their season, and shuffle the schedule if both Marlins and Cards are out. There needs to be a penalty.
This. If you can't follow the guidelines and you have an outbreak like we've seen now with the Marlins tough shit your season is over.
Suspend players, not teams.
Canceling a team's season wouldn't be fair to the players on that team that DO comply, nor would it be fair to the fans of those teams.
I seriously doubt Yankee fans on this thread would be advocating for the Yanks' season to be canceled if a handful of Yankee players did something stupid that resulted in positive tests.
That's how real like works though, a few people ruin it for the rest of everyone else. If that's true about the Cardinals, they should cancel their season as a warning to other clubs that this serious.
Canceling a team's season wouldn't be fair to the players on that team that DO comply, nor would it be fair to the fans of those teams.
I seriously doubt Yankee fans on this thread would be advocating for the Yanks' season to be canceled if a handful of Yankee players did something stupid that resulted in positive tests.
The players are obviously not following rules and the teams have not, obviously, communicated well enough or enforced the protocols. These appear to be total breakdowns. Yes the players are violating the rules and when large parts of the team are going out then a big part of the problem is with the organizations.
You are probably right because MLBPA would not allow it.
(I know this is bordering on Ferris Bueller Simone talk) with Judge at Linden High in CA. According to her, Judge is a really great guy. Very nice, down to earth, approachable.
and then comes to the majors and looks like a long term solution at 3B.
What I can't understand is his "bad" defensive metrics.
He made some bad plays last year. He had a bunch of errors. But you also see what he's capable of. That'll work itself out. It is funny though. His glove got him to the majors but his bat is keeping him here.
we have now. Maybe my favorite is Urshela. Like even now I’m still remembering the narrative that he was a defensive guy, and that’s what we were told when he came up. Then he just started mashing and hasn’t stopped. Just a stellar job of player development by the Yanks
I don't know this answer hence why I am asking the question.
Paxton had an injury this offseason. Most felt he wouldn't have been ready for the start of the season. I don't know when he really started to start working out again. Is it possible the Yanks took it very slow with him to guarantee he'd be ready to go when baseball started back up and could that be why he doesn't have that extra few mph on his fastball?
we have now. Maybe my favorite is Urshela. Like even now I’m still remembering the narrative that he was a defensive guy, and that’s what we were told when he came up. Then he just started mashing and hasn’t stopped. Just a stellar job of player development by the Yanks
developing guys is the story for me - the guys we drafted and the guys we traded for or signed off the scrap-heap. Love it.
Paxton had an injury this offseason. Most felt he wouldn't have been ready for the start of the season. I don't know when he really started to start working out again. Is it possible the Yanks took it very slow with him to guarantee he'd be ready to go when baseball started back up and could that be why he doesn't have that extra few mph on his fastball?
Good question. Don’t know the answer. However, I’m hoping he’s working his way back and as long as he’s at the top of his game come post season the Yankees should be ok.
Paxton had an injury this offseason. Most felt he wouldn't have been ready for the start of the season. I don't know when he really started to start working out again. Is it possible the Yanks took it very slow with him to guarantee he'd be ready to go when baseball started back up and could that be why he doesn't have that extra few mph on his fastball?
Good question. Don’t know the answer. However, I’m hoping he’s working his way back and as long as he’s at the top of his game come post season the Yankees should be ok.
Wasn't the injury related to his throwing arm? The lack of velocity can't be a coincidence. Would love for him to get right and price himself out of our budget. Doesn't seem likely though.
was one of the best defending outfielders last year and he hit lefties better than righties (less power). No reason to trot Andujar out there in a lineup where we need lefties.
and then comes to the majors and looks like a long term solution at 3B.
He really wasn't bad in the minors. He just didn't jump off the page or screen at you. He was a decent hitter and his power was up and down. He certainly showed signs and potential.
Paxton had an injury this offseason. Most felt he wouldn't have been ready for the start of the season. I don't know when he really started to start working out again. Is it possible the Yanks took it very slow with him to guarantee he'd be ready to go when baseball started back up and could that be why he doesn't have that extra few mph on his fastball?
Good question. Don’t know the answer. However, I’m hoping he’s working his way back and as long as he’s at the top of his game come post season the Yankees should be ok.
Wasn't the injury related to his throwing arm? The lack of velocity can't be a coincidence. Would love for him to get right and price himself out of our budget. Doesn't seem likely though.
I think he can get to 20 HR's but even that's a tall order (that's pro-rated 59 HR season). There's a bunch of guys that hit 30 HR's prior to the All Star Break and that's in what, 80/90 games?
I'd say if he's on a special run in this odd 2020 season that he has a shot at up to 25. More than that is just too big of an anomaly to predict.
When Judge came up in the 8th last night, DJ was on first. I'm saying to myself, no way I pitch to Judge. I don't care if walking him puts DJ at second base. I'd rather face an ice cold Torres with a runner in scoring position than a red hot Judge. What do you guys think, obviously with the benefit of hindsight now? I could not believe that 2-0 pitch to Judge.
RE: RE: RE: Could Judge hit 50 homers in 60 games?
When Judge came up in the 8th last night, DJ was on first. I'm saying to myself, no way I pitch to Judge. I don't care if walking him puts DJ at second base. I'd rather face an ice cold Torres with a runner in scoring position than a red hot Judge. What do you guys think, obviously with the benefit of hindsight now? I could not believe that 2-0 pitch to Judge.
.
That was not smart, with Torres struggling as well,
just put him on first base. Then Barnes throws a hanging curve ball, and boom!
Roenicke should have put up four fingers there.
way to spend some of the weekend. If this were a full season I'd be a bit concerned about Paxton. Hope he gets his shit together.
.
Paxton needs to find that fastball again, very mediocre
without it. They are 7-1 with only 3 good starts,
(two by Cole, and one by Monty). The BP has done its job
for the most part.
way to spend some of the weekend. If this were a full season I'd be a bit concerned about Paxton. Hope he gets his shit together.
The scary part about Paxton is he admitted he’s concerned about the velocity drop. Usually you get the ole “I’m fine, usually takes me awhile to get going”, etc. The Yankees can’t afford to keep running him out there if he’s only going to get them one or two innings and putting them in early deficits. If I’m the Yanks, he gets one or two more starts and if his velocity isn’t better, IL him. Clarke Schmidt is eagerly awaiting his opportunity...
Paxton's troubles seem so much like AJ Burnett's. Mental game just not being there so early in the game, and "throwing" moreso than pitching.
Not comparing the 2 specifically, just that there are similarities with there "stuff" and it just not clicking early in games.
I'm going to cut Pax a bit more slack early on this year coming off back surgery. I know he's had plenty of time to heal and it's not April, just that as far as actually pitching coming off that surgery it is April, innings wise for him.
He hit 93 last night so his velocity is creeping up, and I think maybe it's just a matter of working all the kinks out and maybe feeling comfortable and confident in his body out there again. Things that were second nature like release point, stride, landing etc might just take a bit more time to get right after surgery.
definitely not panicking at all, and its a good season for him to get back to things slowly.
Agreed. I just want to see improvement and have him on top of his game by mid season or so. If we get a stretch run out of him similar to last year, I'm fine with however long it takes him to get there.
I'd love to see him in top form right now but I think we have the team to give him the time to get there, and I want him right for the stretch.
the team is loaded and the division is nothing special we should moonwalk to 1st. Seeing as he's a FA we need to see what he has. With Schmidt and King in the wings I probably don't see us re-signing Tanaka and Paxton to big $ so we'll probably have to pick one. On the Judge front I agree 20-25 is his ceiling. Keep in mind one thing though he is playing virtually the whole 60 games in band boxes- YS, Fenway, Camden, Buffalo, Philly etc... even the other ones like Citi, Washington are not exactly cavernous any more. The 2 florida ones are a little tougher. So if he stays healthy he could put up monster #'s.
It’s likely that they are throwing a lot of analytics at pitchers and some it takes away the feel they have, maybe they’ve always been just kind of more instinctual and the Yankee ways of “improving” their game just take them out of the groove. Now clearly it works for many.
But I’m wondering if there is something (other than cheating) that the astros do to flesh out of pitcher personalities match up well with their teaching methods. And they do absolutely feel like organized methods and approaches, looking at someone like Charlie Morton.
Pax or Gray do not strike me as very cerebral players. But maybe it is something around only an unpleasant middle ground. The very cerebral players who can take in a lot of information without it overwhelming them like say Gerrit Cole or even a lot of the successful younger Yankee pitchers. (I do think some of the success of the way our bullpen performs) or even maybe simpler players that you can just give them specific game plans and they won’t get too much in their heads. Just some food for though.
In the middle of what is supposed to be a discussion about analytics, there is a completely unknowable conjecture about the degree of cerebral two pitchers you only saw through a TV camera, over telcom waves and then through your Tv...and tonally stated as if its a reasonable conclusion and not a complete wild ass guess.
In addition to pitching full time fall, summer and spring, Paxton was an all SEC Honor Roll player with a 3.35 GPA and a degree in Financial Accounting. He stayed beyond being drafted to finish his degree and graduate.
I understand the misconception. Einstein looked like a doddering fool and Michelangelo a mad man, Gates looks nervous, Jobs a hungry cat, Da Vinci a hermit so obviously none of them cerebral enough to pay attention to.
Paxton is coming back from off season back surgery. When he was pitching the best of his pro career last year with the Yankees was he cerebral then?
Maybe he was always cerebral enough and also had better feel when he felt better and his spinal column let him pitch to feel and his smarts.
Isn't "feel" a form of kinetic intelligence? One of the 22 forms of intelligence every person has to a greater and lesser extent?
Lincoln looked like a tubercular hick from beyond the sticks with one partial year of schooling before returning to the farm when his stepmother died and the crops needed planting.
At a time when Darwin's work was just becoming known many a commentator and cartoonist thought he was the evolutionary link.
but you haven't given me much of the benefit of the doubt here.
I was suggesting a personality difference over the idea that people that think more or less are better or worse.
Excelling at almost anything is some combination of preparation and the ability to find a peaceful focus when the moment calls for you to perform.
I'm suggesting that a of new information can also change a process or system that once worked for someone. It's not uncommon for athletes to get in their own heads when little changes.
I wasn't making any kind of value judgement by calling some people's processes simple.
And as I suggested with my Astros comparison sometimes it isn't what information you give people but the way you convey it to them. There are also elements of style in personalization in this involved in building the best culture.
Now the Yankees are a grade A organization through and through. Very little to pick at overall. Obviously a lot more pitchers are doing well here than not (Although they did just ask the pitching coach)
I was even asking if I was thinking about the Astros situation in a complete manner but I would say I can't think of great examples of pitchers losing much value in that uniform.
I ended with food for thought to indicate I was thinking out loud about something but you acted as if I drew some conclusions I very much did not.
the two years before he joined the Yanks his BAA was .223 and .224
Went up to .242 last year. I watched a lot of his starts and it definitely seemed like there were nights when he had it and nights when he didn't seem as composed, but his stuff still looked good. Like he was absolutely laboring too much mentally. Some players have much worse stuff than Paxton relying much more on the mental side vs the ability to still beat you if you guess the pitch right.
There is a big leap between this kind of observation and the implication that someone is smarter or dumber overall.
Variations in learning styles and adaptation to the "learning crucible" like going straight home to the kids after work instead of hanging around the clubhouse talking pitching nuances.
Very Possible. But also may be not yet healed so can't utilize the learning yet
Yes this topic also has me noodling on the types of pressure
that players could be better and worse at handling.
Take Gray for instance. Something about New York didn't fit with him. Yet playoff games were not an issue for him early in his career so the argument isn't to say that general pressure is a problem for him.
It is interesting to me to think about what was posed earlier as one thing that could interfere with a process that worked for him. It could be the general additional media attention in NY. It could just be that when you put on the pinstripes the expectation is that you win and maybe a more hey we are just having fun playing the game we love attitude works better for some. The A's are particularly good at the we are overplaying our dollars spent angle. That's harder to have for a franchise with constant lofty expectations.
Yankees:
Red Sox:
Weird to see Kevin Pillar in a Sox uni
Is it true that they went to some party?
Quote:
A bunch of cardinals tested positive today
Is it true that they went to some party?
All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
Quote:
In comment 14942542 bubba0825 said:
Quote:
A bunch of cardinals tested positive today
Is it true that they went to some party?
All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
That is what I read - at a casino. After all that went on with the Marlins, you would think players would get it.
You know, just cancel their season, and shuffle the schedule if both Marlins and Cards are out. There needs to be a penalty.
Quote:
In comment 14942545 section125 said:
Quote:
In comment 14942542 bubba0825 said:
Quote:
A bunch of cardinals tested positive today
Is it true that they went to some party?
All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
That is what I read - at a casino. After all that went on with the Marlins, you would think players would get it.
You know, just cancel their season, and shuffle the schedule if both Marlins and Cards are out. There needs to be a penalty.
This. If you can't follow the guidelines and you have an outbreak like we've seen now with the Marlins tough shit your season is over.
Quote:
In comment 14942548 bubba0825 said:
Quote:
In comment 14942545 section125 said:
Quote:
In comment 14942542 bubba0825 said:
Quote:
A bunch of cardinals tested positive today
Is it true that they went to some party?
All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
That is what I read - at a casino. After all that went on with the Marlins, you would think players would get it.
You know, just cancel their season, and shuffle the schedule if both Marlins and Cards are out. There needs to be a penalty.
This. If you can't follow the guidelines and you have an outbreak like we've seen now with the Marlins tough shit your season is over.
Suspend players, not teams.
Canceling a team's season wouldn't be fair to the players on that team that DO comply, nor would it be fair to the fans of those teams.
I seriously doubt Yankee fans on this thread would be advocating for the Yanks' season to be canceled if a handful of Yankee players did something stupid that resulted in positive tests.
Re-sign Tanaka. Let Paxton go at this moment. Could change, but right now this version of Paxton is useless.
Velocity down again. He can't have a clean 1st ever.
Quote:
In comment 14942551 section125 said:
Quote:
In comment 14942548 bubba0825 said:
Quote:
In comment 14942545 section125 said:
Quote:
In comment 14942542 bubba0825 said:
Quote:
A bunch of cardinals tested positive today
Is it true that they went to some party?
All of this is rumor and not confirmed, but it’s being reported they went to a casino
That is what I read - at a casino. After all that went on with the Marlins, you would think players would get it.
You know, just cancel their season, and shuffle the schedule if both Marlins and Cards are out. There needs to be a penalty.
This. If you can't follow the guidelines and you have an outbreak like we've seen now with the Marlins tough shit your season is over.
Suspend players, not teams.
Canceling a team's season wouldn't be fair to the players on that team that DO comply, nor would it be fair to the fans of those teams.
I seriously doubt Yankee fans on this thread would be advocating for the Yanks' season to be canceled if a handful of Yankee players did something stupid that resulted in positive tests.
That's how real like works though, a few people ruin it for the rest of everyone else. If that's true about the Cardinals, they should cancel their season as a warning to other clubs that this serious.
Suspend players, not teams.
Canceling a team's season wouldn't be fair to the players on that team that DO comply, nor would it be fair to the fans of those teams.
I seriously doubt Yankee fans on this thread would be advocating for the Yanks' season to be canceled if a handful of Yankee players did something stupid that resulted in positive tests.
The players are obviously not following rules and the teams have not, obviously, communicated well enough or enforced the protocols. These appear to be total breakdowns. Yes the players are violating the rules and when large parts of the team are going out then a big part of the problem is with the organizations.
You are probably right because MLBPA would not allow it.
I dont think it is silly. They struggled after the GS yesterday. They K quite a bit still.
Strike zone is inconsistent..
meanwhile he absolutely kills the next pitch
love hearing the crack of the bat
Healthy for the first time in 2 years
5 games in a row...
Twice? Could be at twilight not reading the ball. But he has misplayed two balls tonight.
I guarantee Gardy catches both of those balls
Quote:
oof
I guarantee Gardy catches both of those balls
Insert joke here.
Took a bad angle. Played it like an infielder. He'll make his mistakes. Got to live with him out there until he gets it.
As Hicks misreads another ball but gets it. He just must be not seeing it against the empty stadium?????
No reason we don't score 10 tonight.
The two doubles by Pillar and Martinez are on Hicks tonight.
5-4
5-5
Let's go!
What I can't understand is his "bad" defensive metrics.
Judge was out.
He is all about himself. He does a routine play, he struts around like his farts don't stink.
He makes a mistake, he mopes about it for a week.
Judge was out.
He moves well for a panda guy and has a great arm.
Quote:
and then comes to the majors and looks like a long term solution at 3B.
What I can't understand is his "bad" defensive metrics.
He made some bad plays last year. He had a bunch of errors. But you also see what he's capable of. That'll work itself out. It is funny though. His glove got him to the majors but his bat is keeping him here.
developing guys is the story for me - the guys we drafted and the guys we traded for or signed off the scrap-heap. Love it.
Good question. Don’t know the answer. However, I’m hoping he’s working his way back and as long as he’s at the top of his game come post season the Yankees should be ok.
This guy has been pretty bad behind the plate for sure
Quote:
Paxton had an injury this offseason. Most felt he wouldn't have been ready for the start of the season. I don't know when he really started to start working out again. Is it possible the Yanks took it very slow with him to guarantee he'd be ready to go when baseball started back up and could that be why he doesn't have that extra few mph on his fastball?
Good question. Don’t know the answer. However, I’m hoping he’s working his way back and as long as he’s at the top of his game come post season the Yankees should be ok.
Wasn't the injury related to his throwing arm? The lack of velocity can't be a coincidence. Would love for him to get right and price himself out of our budget. Doesn't seem likely though.
King needs to locate better. He stuff moves but he is not locating it well.
7-6
that was quite a hottake there between innings!
They need to fix this shit. two IF on each side of second at all times and they can't be standing in the outfield.
They need to fix this shit. two IF on each side of second at all times and they can't be standing in the outfield.
Hitters could also adjust.
Urshela is not better than Chapman in any universe.
Tauchman has earned the starting job. Don't screw with it.
468 foot bomb.
this is what a healthy Judge hits like. We just need to keep him healthy.
Over 900 ft of homerun
Fucking video game stuff.
Just talkin' 'bout Judge
468 foot bomb.
+1, that was a great call
Quote:
Varsgasian needs to scream like that every yankees game.
468 foot bomb.
+1, that was a great call
Matt Vas has no more "Santa Marias!" Left to give after tonight...
Britton has started to look like the old Britton.
Liked what I saw of King.
Have to wonder if Judge was hurt more last year than acknowledged. He is swinging so freely more like his rookie year.
They are all starting to see the ball now. Voit just missed that one he popped up on.
The 2nd place Orioles!
Quote:
That ends tomorrow either way since we play Philly, though. :(
The 2nd place Orioles!
LOL.
Quote:
In comment 14942705 robbieballs2003 said:
Quote:
Paxton had an injury this offseason. Most felt he wouldn't have been ready for the start of the season. I don't know when he really started to start working out again. Is it possible the Yanks took it very slow with him to guarantee he'd be ready to go when baseball started back up and could that be why he doesn't have that extra few mph on his fastball?
Good question. Don’t know the answer. However, I’m hoping he’s working his way back and as long as he’s at the top of his game come post season the Yankees should be ok.
Wasn't the injury related to his throwing arm? The lack of velocity can't be a coincidence. Would love for him to get right and price himself out of our budget. Doesn't seem likely though.
Believe it was his back, not arm.
Just talkin' 'bout Judge
468 foot bomb.
Quote:
In comment 14942780 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
That ends tomorrow either way since we play Philly, though. :(
The 2nd place Orioles!
LOL.
And the Rays are 4-6.
Quote:
Varsgasian needs to scream like that every yankees game.
468 foot bomb.
Would've been a HR in the old park!
Right over the 457 sign!
He gets probably 3.5 chances every game. He will probably play 50-55 with days off. He will have about 175 ABs. Seems a tall order.
A-Rod won MVP that year.
ESPN article - ( New Window )
Quote:
I mean, if he stays perfectly healthy all season?
He gets probably 3.5 chances every game. He will probably play 50-55 with days off. He will have about 175 ABs. Seems a tall order.
He'll get 4 PA per game unless we get shut out. He's batting second. No way he hits 50 HR tho. That's like 135 HR in a regular season.
Quote:
In comment 14942817 BlueLou'sBack said:
Quote:
I mean, if he stays perfectly healthy all season?
He gets probably 3.5 chances every game. He will probably play 50-55 with days off. He will have about 175 ABs. Seems a tall order.
He'll get 4 PA per game unless we get shut out. He's batting second. No way he hits 50 HR tho. That's like 135 HR in a regular season.
25 would probably be it, max.
I'd say if he's on a special run in this odd 2020 season that he has a shot at up to 25. More than that is just too big of an anomaly to predict.
27 he'd tie Barry bonds (72.9)
Quote:
In comment 14942817 BlueLou'sBack said:
Quote:
I mean, if he stays perfectly healthy all season?
He gets probably 3.5 chances every game. He will probably play 50-55 with days off. He will have about 175 ABs. Seems a tall order.
He'll get 4 PA per game unless we get shut out. He's batting second. No way he hits 50 HR tho. That's like 135 HR in a regular season.
Ah, that would be a no. He is sure fun to watch
right now though!
That was not smart, with Torres struggling as well,
just put him on first base. Then Barnes throws a hanging curve ball, and boom!
Roenicke should have put up four fingers there.
Paxton needs to find that fastball again, very mediocre
without it. They are 7-1 with only 3 good starts,
(two by Cole, and one by Monty). The BP has done its job
for the most part.
The scary part about Paxton is he admitted he’s concerned about the velocity drop. Usually you get the ole “I’m fine, usually takes me awhile to get going”, etc. The Yankees can’t afford to keep running him out there if he’s only going to get them one or two innings and putting them in early deficits. If I’m the Yanks, he gets one or two more starts and if his velocity isn’t better, IL him. Clarke Schmidt is eagerly awaiting his opportunity...
Not comparing the 2 specifically, just that there are similarities with there "stuff" and it just not clicking early in games.
Not comparing the 2 specifically, just that there are similarities with there "stuff" and it just not clicking early in games.
I'm going to cut Pax a bit more slack early on this year coming off back surgery. I know he's had plenty of time to heal and it's not April, just that as far as actually pitching coming off that surgery it is April, innings wise for him.
He hit 93 last night so his velocity is creeping up, and I think maybe it's just a matter of working all the kinks out and maybe feeling comfortable and confident in his body out there again. Things that were second nature like release point, stride, landing etc might just take a bit more time to get right after surgery.
I can see the A
Agreed. I just want to see improvement and have him on top of his game by mid season or so. If we get a stretch run out of him similar to last year, I'm fine with however long it takes him to get there.
I'd love to see him in top form right now but I think we have the team to give him the time to get there, and I want him right for the stretch.
But I’m wondering if there is something (other than cheating) that the astros do to flesh out of pitcher personalities match up well with their teaching methods. And they do absolutely feel like organized methods and approaches, looking at someone like Charlie Morton.
Pax or Gray do not strike me as very cerebral players. But maybe it is something around only an unpleasant middle ground. The very cerebral players who can take in a lot of information without it overwhelming them like say Gerrit Cole or even a lot of the successful younger Yankee pitchers. (I do think some of the success of the way our bullpen performs) or even maybe simpler players that you can just give them specific game plans and they won’t get too much in their heads. Just some food for though.
In addition to pitching full time fall, summer and spring, Paxton was an all SEC Honor Roll player with a 3.35 GPA and a degree in Financial Accounting. He stayed beyond being drafted to finish his degree and graduate.
I understand the misconception. Einstein looked like a doddering fool and Michelangelo a mad man, Gates looks nervous, Jobs a hungry cat, Da Vinci a hermit so obviously none of them cerebral enough to pay attention to.
Paxton is coming back from off season back surgery. When he was pitching the best of his pro career last year with the Yankees was he cerebral then?
Maybe he was always cerebral enough and also had better feel when he felt better and his spinal column let him pitch to feel and his smarts.
Isn't "feel" a form of kinetic intelligence? One of the 22 forms of intelligence every person has to a greater and lesser extent?
At a time when Darwin's work was just becoming known many a commentator and cartoonist thought he was the evolutionary link.
How did that turn out?
I was suggesting a personality difference over the idea that people that think more or less are better or worse.
Excelling at almost anything is some combination of preparation and the ability to find a peaceful focus when the moment calls for you to perform.
I'm suggesting that a of new information can also change a process or system that once worked for someone. It's not uncommon for athletes to get in their own heads when little changes.
I wasn't making any kind of value judgement by calling some people's processes simple.
And as I suggested with my Astros comparison sometimes it isn't what information you give people but the way you convey it to them. There are also elements of style in personalization in this involved in building the best culture.
Now the Yankees are a grade A organization through and through. Very little to pick at overall. Obviously a lot more pitchers are doing well here than not (Although they did just ask the pitching coach)
I was even asking if I was thinking about the Astros situation in a complete manner but I would say I can't think of great examples of pitchers losing much value in that uniform.
I ended with food for thought to indicate I was thinking out loud about something but you acted as if I drew some conclusions I very much did not.
Went up to .242 last year. I watched a lot of his starts and it definitely seemed like there were nights when he had it and nights when he didn't seem as composed, but his stuff still looked good. Like he was absolutely laboring too much mentally. Some players have much worse stuff than Paxton relying much more on the mental side vs the ability to still beat you if you guess the pitch right.
There is a big leap between this kind of observation and the implication that someone is smarter or dumber overall.
Variations in learning styles and adaptation to the "learning crucible" like going straight home to the kids after work instead of hanging around the clubhouse talking pitching nuances.
Very Possible. But also may be not yet healed so can't utilize the learning yet
Take Gray for instance. Something about New York didn't fit with him. Yet playoff games were not an issue for him early in his career so the argument isn't to say that general pressure is a problem for him.
It is interesting to me to think about what was posed earlier as one thing that could interfere with a process that worked for him. It could be the general additional media attention in NY. It could just be that when you put on the pinstripes the expectation is that you win and maybe a more hey we are just having fun playing the game we love attitude works better for some. The A's are particularly good at the we are overplaying our dollars spent angle. That's harder to have for a franchise with constant lofty expectations.