Giant should bring back Corey Coleman

think a guy coming off an ACL injury would help.

I'd rather see Victor get promoted and get some reps.

110%

bring back a player nobody else wants, that's the ticket

But, even though we can bash the GM for bringing in the players we have, I do trust the coaching staff who was able to see and rank Coleman directly against those players. IOW, our players might not be good, but head-to-head Coleman was worse.

he'd be resigned after week 1 so they didn't have to pay him for a full season if he was cut later.

The fact he wasn't resigned and hasn't signed with anyone else may be an indication he's not that good.

and get the highest draft picks possible.

he hasn't been signed by any team. And it doesn't just have to do with his talent.

If he gets resigned, several other people will have to be out of the building before it happens.

but let’s not make him out to be any kind of savior here. We’re desperate for playmakers, and cut him. Nobody else has signed him. Sometimes you have to read the writing on the wall

New York Giants!

In comment 14997219 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

he hasn't been signed by any team. And it doesn't just have to do with his talent. If he gets resigned, several other people will have to be out of the building before it happens.

So it's a relationship/culture issue? And this must be known in NFL circles as he hasn't been picked up. We all know Coleman can be useful on a NFL team.

a culture issue. Read between the lines

at this point. I would rather them play the UDFA to see if they have anything there.

Is on to something....

Like others, I was surprised when he was cut, but he hasn't been signed by anyone.

In comment 14997247 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

a culture issue. Read between the lines

I'm trying! But thanks for the nugget, helps me understand why he's not here (or anywhere).

Should be open to anyone young but your now stuck with mostly practice squad guys due to COVID-19. They would have to sign them to the team but take two weeks before putting them on the actual field. Look at this roster not many guys you would say he’s a building block for the future. Jones, Slayton, Smith, Thomas, Peart, Hernandez, Lemieux, Gates, Lawrence, Carter, Ximines, Brown, Crowder, Brunson, Bradberry, Holmes, Harper, Ballentine, Love, Williamson, Dixon, Gano less then 25 players all the rest are trade chips or let’s go our separate ways. You’ve got 31 other teams PS to go shopping on without breaking the bank to see are they good enough to turn into NFL players. No longer concerned about wins and losses concerned with these guys learning and getting better each week at what they will be in the future.

In comment 14997294 Dragon said:

Quote:

Should be open to anyone young but your now stuck with mostly practice squad guys due to COVID-19. They would have to sign them to the team but take two weeks before putting them on the actual field.

I'm not sure you understand the COVID rules that well.

anyone is insinuating that Corey Coleman is going to cure our offensive woes. However, he adds some useful traits that our current weapons simply lack - size and speed. I simply think it's worth a flier to see if he can help.

Herman Moore. He's still available isn't he?

Why hasnt Coleman been picked up by anybody? Especially with the ability to put him on the practice squad at a minimum. Guessing theres something off with him that hasnt been made public because he looked good in the limited training camp.

Or is it just conjecture at this point? I haven't read anything to indicate that he was any type of problem.

might still have something left in the tank

In comment 14997247 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

a culture issue. Read between the lines

Pretty cryptic Fat Man. I guess I need to be hit over the head. Care to elaborate?

The knee injury reportedly affected his speed which eliminated his main value.

The Giants would be better off giving Mack, Victor, Bachman, or Dillon a shot.

as a fan... who knows how the ACL really is?

He didn't exactly have a stellar reputation coming here, either. It is certainly conceivable that something else is at play.

You should be banned for your rampant stupidity, you won't of course because you're the type of idiot this place loves to cater to now but you still know absolutely dog shit nothing about football. Remember when you whined about how bad Gilbride was? The guy who oversaw the best offensive stretch this team ever had? You remember that you spoiled no nothing little twat? Go follow another sport, this one is still way over your puny fucking head.

In comment 14997868 Joey in VA said:

Quote:

You should be banned for your rampant stupidity, you won't of course because you're the type of idiot this place loves to cater to now but you still know absolutely dog shit nothing about football. Remember when you whined about how bad Gilbride was? The guy who oversaw the best offensive stretch this team ever had? You remember that you spoiled no nothing little twat? Go follow another sport, this one is still way over your puny fucking head.

Nice post at 1am bud. Seems like you're off your meds again. Either that or you need to lay off the 30 pack of NATTY Light because you're a loose cannon and morph into this internet tough guy. Okay there, little Joey?

In comment 14997219 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

he hasn't been signed by any team. And it doesn't just have to do with his talent. If he gets resigned, several other people will have to be out of the building before it happens.

if there's this big dark secret about Coleman, why did they bring him to camp at all? Or if this issue came to a head during camp, why keep him until the very end of camp?