but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Just read some stat and apparently GT is TL's kryptonite
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
I think he has a shot to be better than Elway. Bigger arm, as athletic, better field and pocket awareness... all the goods. After watching the '18 QB combine I knew Josh Allen would be the best of the bunch. Trevor Lawrence is a generational talent. If we lose tomorrow, we have to do everything in our power to tank for him.
This board was absolutely behind draft Haskins last year and drafting Rosen and Darnold two years ago. This board generally gets everything wrong.
That's damn interesting considering I wanted nothing to do with either Haskins OR Rosen. Darnold? I would have been OK with that but was 100% against using a #2 pick on a damn RB when you have zero OL.
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Just
- wow.
TL would likely have been the #1 pick in the NFL draft coming out of
high school and he's lived up to the hype. It doesn't mean he'll end up being a Rodgers or Mahomes, but he has a pretty high floor. His floor may be higher than DJ's ceiling.
Yeah, once you take away the two trips to the National Championship game, winning one....the kid really hasnt proven a thing. Lets see him play someone!
JFC..
JFC - I think you missed the point. It’s about how
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
If you see Josh freaking Rosen when you watch TL play, I really don't know what to tell you.
Except maybe put down the ketamine, because Lawrence is to Rosen as DiFara's is to Famous Rays
Maybe you should be down the ketamine because I was clearly
Ofcourse you need a good QB but sustained quality is because of a solid team with depth that can handle injuries. When you add a good to great QB to that you have what we have seen with the Steelers and Patriots.Those teams Still won when the QBs went out.
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Fields is more athletic, has a sturdier build, and is much better at improv. Rosen, at this stage threw a better ball and had better mechanics, but Fields has the chance to get there.
Fields is raw, but he there is an interesting ceiling. I wasn't on board at first, because Day's offense with superior talent can make a lot of QBs look great (e.g. Haskins), but Fields is growing on me based on re-watching more footage from last year...That's why I am very eager to see him play this.
Fields last year was a more accurate passer than I thought he would be. Plus, he will benefit by playing against much better competition than Lawrence does in the ACC. Either way, the NFL can look forward to at least two and maybe three very good QB’s in the 2021 draft.
Maybe some of you will learn it’s not the QB but the OL
I understand Seattle had a terrible OL a short time ago. Imagine Russell still won games with a bad OL. Are you saying no other QB in the history of the sport has won a decent amount of games with a bad OL?
Secondly, why can't they draft Lawrence, trade Jones, draft an OL or 2, and get one or two in FA, and at least be decent enough?
Third- is Lawrence better than DJones? If he is-- maybe Giants are have 2 or maybe 3 wins right now?
RE: JFC - I think you missed the point. It’s about how
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Ofcourse you need a good QB but sustained quality is because of a solid team with depth that can handle injuries. When you add a good to great QB to that you have what we have seen with the Steelers and Patriots.Those teams Still won when the QBs went out.
Mahomes is great but KC is also a strong team.
How long do they sustain their success without the super QB? Why does it seem any team that sustains success it is generally because they've had a super QB vs any other position?
RE: JFC - I think you missed the point. It’s about how
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Why can’t you all start looking objectively at the prospect? I like him a whole lot but I don’t base whether he should be drafted from games like today.
high school and he's lived up to the hype. It doesn't mean he'll end up being a Rodgers or Mahomes, but he has a pretty high floor. His floor may be higher than DJ's ceiling.
Now THAT IS an exaggeration!
If ANYTHING has been underestimated around here, its DJ's and Thomas's ceilings. The question for both is will they get there?
Ofcourse you need a good QB but sustained quality is because of a solid team with depth that can handle injuries. When you add a good to great QB to that you have what we have seen with the Steelers and Patriots.Those teams Still won when the QBs went out.
Mahomes is great but KC is also a strong team.
the counter argument is that 80% of the teams that have won the Superbowl over the last 20 years have had great quarterbacks. only 4 pedestrian QBs have won Superbowls in that period (unless you count Eli as pedestrian). The stats are about the same going all the way back to Superbowl 1.
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Why can’t you all start looking objectively at the prospect? I like him a whole lot but I don’t base whether he should be drafted from games like today.
My advice is you all shouldn’t either.
I can't speak for other but have.
AN I listen ot others as well.
And it's overwhelmingly positive.
The only counter I've seen that can be even near a slam is one game vs LSU. SO I'm supposed to kill him for one game vs arguably open of the best college team that has played over the past 510 years - or longer?
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Why can’t you all start looking objectively at the prospect? I like him a whole lot but I don’t base whether he should be drafted from games like today.
My advice is you all shouldn’t either.
I can't speak for other but have.
AN I listen ot others as well.
And it's overwhelmingly positive.
The only counter I've seen that can be even near a slam is one game vs LSU. SO I'm supposed to kill him for one game vs arguably open of the best college team that has played over the past 510 years - or longer?
Ok good. Then we shouldn’t have to really concern ourselves with ultra positive games against the high school defenses in the ACC.
Know- I am one of the few saying Jones is our guy!
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Quote:
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
He is not Josh Rosen.
Not sure who the comment is directed at But, I am 100% behind Jones as our QB.
So in KC it's the line, not Mahomes?
So in Seattle it's the line, not Wilson?
So in GB it's the line, not Rodgers?
...
Quote:
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Seriously?!! ROSen? Stop it
Yea that why Green Bay has been good all this years, not because of two hall of fame QBS
That's damn interesting considering I wanted nothing to do with either Haskins OR Rosen. Darnold? I would have been OK with that but was 100% against using a #2 pick on a damn RB when you have zero OL.
Stop speaking for the entire board.
Quote:
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Just
- wow.
Maybe the next GM will finish the job and not listen to BBI mouth breathers targeting WRs and corners?
Best QB prospect since Peyton. What does madden have to do with it
Yeah, once you take away the two trips to the National Championship game, winning one....the kid really hasnt proven a thing. Lets see him play someone!
JFC..
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
Give me a break. He is head and shoulders above Fields as a prospect. And Travis Etienne is the best RB in the nation.
Quote:
Maybe some of you will learn it’s not the QB but the OL
So in KC it's the line, not Mahomes?
So in Seattle it's the line, not Wilson?
So in GB it's the line, not Rodgers?
...
In the immortal words of Forrest Gump
Maybe it’s both
Maybe it’s both happening at the same time
Quote:
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
If you see Josh freaking Rosen when you watch TL play, I really don't know what to tell you.
Except maybe put down the ketamine, because Lawrence is to Rosen as DiFara's is to Famous Rays
Ofcourse you need a good QB but sustained quality is because of a solid team with depth that can handle injuries. When you add a good to great QB to that you have what we have seen with the Steelers and Patriots.Those teams Still won when the QBs went out.
Mahomes is great but KC is also a strong team.
Quote:
but if we end up with, say, the third pick, and Fields is there, that's going to be a very interesting debate...
I can't say I've seen him more than twice, but he screams Josh Rosen to me. A guy that is pretty good, but gets hyped a lot more because of his high school recruiting status.
Fields is more athletic, has a sturdier build, and is much better at improv. Rosen, at this stage threw a better ball and had better mechanics, but Fields has the chance to get there.
Fields is raw, but he there is an interesting ceiling. I wasn't on board at first, because Day's offense with superior talent can make a lot of QBs look great (e.g. Haskins), but Fields is growing on me based on re-watching more footage from last year...That's why I am very eager to see him play this.
I understand Seattle had a terrible OL a short time ago. Imagine Russell still won games with a bad OL. Are you saying no other QB in the history of the sport has won a decent amount of games with a bad OL?
Secondly, why can't they draft Lawrence, trade Jones, draft an OL or 2, and get one or two in FA, and at least be decent enough?
Third- is Lawrence better than DJones? If he is-- maybe Giants are have 2 or maybe 3 wins right now?
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Ofcourse you need a good QB but sustained quality is because of a solid team with depth that can handle injuries. When you add a good to great QB to that you have what we have seen with the Steelers and Patriots.Those teams Still won when the QBs went out.
Mahomes is great but KC is also a strong team.
How long do they sustain their success without the super QB? Why does it seem any team that sustains success it is generally because they've had a super QB vs any other position?
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
He played The No. 7 team in the country Miami last week. He lit them up too.
Yes misread. Sorry lol
Quote:
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Why can’t you all start looking objectively at the prospect? I like him a whole lot but I don’t base whether he should be drafted from games like today.
My advice is you all shouldn’t either.
Now THAT IS an exaggeration!
If ANYTHING has been underestimated around here, its DJ's and Thomas's ceilings. The question for both is will they get there?
Quote:
Take a look at the Jets' schedule. THey're almost a lock for 0-16.
Jets are also getting worse as the season goes on.
The Jets might go 0-17...
Ofcourse you need a good QB but sustained quality is because of a solid team with depth that can handle injuries. When you add a good to great QB to that you have what we have seen with the Steelers and Patriots.Those teams Still won when the QBs went out.
Mahomes is great but KC is also a strong team.
the counter argument is that 80% of the teams that have won the Superbowl over the last 20 years have had great quarterbacks. only 4 pedestrian QBs have won Superbowls in that period (unless you count Eli as pedestrian). The stats are about the same going all the way back to Superbowl 1.
Quote:
In comment 15011240 LBH15 said:
Quote:
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Why can’t you all start looking objectively at the prospect? I like him a whole lot but I don’t base whether he should be drafted from games like today.
My advice is you all shouldn’t either.
I can't speak for other but have.
AN I listen ot others as well.
And it's overwhelmingly positive.
The only counter I've seen that can be even near a slam is one game vs LSU. SO I'm supposed to kill him for one game vs arguably open of the best college team that has played over the past 510 years - or longer?
Quote:
Maybe some of you will learn it’s not the QB but the OL
So in KC it's the line, not Mahomes?
So in Seattle it's the line, not Wilson?
So in GB it's the line, not Rodgers?
...
Absolutely right, the idea that a offensive line is important for a quarterback s success is silly
Quote:
In comment 15011279 giantstock said:
Quote:
In comment 15011240 LBH15 said:
Quote:
he plays in those to shelf games. Not his performance versus the Georgia Techs of the ACC.
Lawrence is excellent against GT, but he didn’t throw 5 TDs at the half versus LSU last January.
So he doesn't win one game in 2 years so he isn't worth the pick?
He was super vs Alabama. He was terrific - 259 years pass and 106 yards rushing getting beat up like Manning did vs San Fran and just showed tough as nails- vs Ohio State- but let's pick one game he loses as the defining moment rather than what it appears every analysts is saying about him?
Might as well destroy him too for the 1 interception he threw today- the 1st one he has had in about a year.
Why can’t you all start looking objectively at the prospect? I like him a whole lot but I don’t base whether he should be drafted from games like today.
My advice is you all shouldn’t either.
I can't speak for other but have.
AN I listen ot others as well.
And it's overwhelmingly positive.
The only counter I've seen that can be even near a slam is one game vs LSU. SO I'm supposed to kill him for one game vs arguably open of the best college team that has played over the past 510 years - or longer?
Ok good. Then we shouldn’t have to really concern ourselves with ultra positive games against the high school defenses in the ACC.
Start a thread when he plays somebody.