Jim Nagy called Peart better than Thomas back in May...

Do not care where they play...if they can fix OL

Also keep in Mind....Thomas is 21 and Peart is like 24.

Fix OL...many things improve

Peart turned 23 in June

In comment 15013810 George from PA said:

Quote:

Do not care where they play...if they can fix OL Also keep in Mind....Thomas is 21 and Peart is like 24. Fix OL...many things improve

Agree. Jumbo started at RT and stunk became a fine LT, Parcells admitted he should have moved William Roberts inside sooner to LG. Once he did he flourished. Eric Moore was drafted as a tackle but was most effective at RG (when he felt like playing that is). Who cares where they end up as long as they become good players and a cohesive unit?

then hopefully we can draft Ja marr Chase or Gregory Rousseau. Although it will be a hard pass on Sewell, best LT prospect in years...you just cant pass that up.

in mind, Nagy is the senior bowl guy. So he has Peart colored glasses on, since Thomas left as a junior.

Is what should be followed. Draft round be damned. It will be interesting to see how this develops, because it might give us an insight as to what might happen this offseason. If Judge is his own man, he just plays the guys who help us win, in whatever position is best for the team. If Peart starts playing more at LT, and Thomas possibly at RT, that's a bad sign for Getts.

LT, RG or RT, who the fock cares? I see big time potential in him on certain plays. Other plays, he gets dominated on the same one move. They all talked about it, and he's a rookie! He will learn to combat that one.

I don't care if he starts at LT, RT or RG/LG. As long as we found a 10 year stud starting lineman at #4, its a win!

With the sheer quantity of prospects he has to evaluate before January and for the amount of years he has done it. I’d think his glasses are as clear as any professional scout employed.

Almost like Saban’s endorsement of Alabama prospects, everyone’s fairly skeptical, of course, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it doesn’t hold any value.

From what I’ve seen, he’s pretty spot on, most of the time. Should of asked his opinion before we played the Steelers because something has to be flawed with our method of in-practice/training camp evaluations.

Like clockwork, every year some player, drafted or signed, is buried or cut that belongs in our best 11.

Peart at LT and Thomas at RT. I don’t see how this would be a bad look for DG if he got 2 starting tackles in the same draft.

Remember that the plan was for Thomas to start at RT, backed up by Fleming with Solder starting at LT backed up by Peart. If it had worked out that way, I was pretty sure Thomas would stay at RT in 2021 if he played well, while Solder tried to hold off Peart and play out his contract.

Also remember that Judge was big on versatility of the O-linemen, so in the back of his mind, he was thinking about which side Thomas and Peart would play on.

Lemieux working in at LG, and Hernandez competing with or replacing Zeitler at RG in 2021.

Hernandez always was a better fit at RG. And he was so raw when drafted, that he could have been trained to play either side. He survived as a rookie because he had the basics of the position, despite the fact that the OL coach was borderline incompetent.

who cares where they start as long as the OL works and you have legit 'starters' at every position and not 5 Cam Flemings or swing guys. AND more importantly, you can use your high draft picks on something other than OL. Like say an edge rusher or a CB (oops, baker and apple).

has it been, since we could discuss good OL prospects on our team. I'm excited, just have to suffer the growing pains.

In comment 15013810 George from PA said:

Quote:

Do not care where they play...if they can fix OL Also keep in Mind....Thomas is 21 and Peart is like 24. Fix OL...many things improve

This is my opinion too. If Peart starts 5 years at LT and Thomas 5 years at RT, then this draft was a tremendous success.

At UTEP so of course Shurmur plopped him in there. He’s a better fit at RG

one wonders. In this world of fractured hot take opinions, reading well is a key, IMHO.

SO BROADBANZ posts:

Quote:

Jim Nagy called Peart better than Thomas back in May...

His OP statement is flat out a lie, a distortion of what Nagy wrote, surprise. I will give the poster credit for providing the link, which storyline posits a slightly different POV.

Here's the full quote. Nagy talks about "potential upside to play the left tackle position", which is quite different, isn't it?

Quote:

Nagy made sure to assure everyone he’s not saying that Peart is the better player of the two Giants draft picks, but that Peart simply offers more athletic abilities at the position. "He’s not as good of a football player right now but he’s a better athlete. That’s clear. That’s inarguable."

Why bother with the misquote? To prove your point?

What's even more amusing to me is Ivan15's post above noting "quite a few threads were started [on BBI] about this..."

Yeah Ivan15, there were, and you started at least half of them, over and over and over. LOL.

drafting a player who may be as good or better than another they drafted.

In comment 15013810 George from PA said:

Quote:

Do not care where they play...if they can fix OL Also keep in Mind....Thomas is 21 and Peart is like 24. Fix OL...many things improve

Age is less important than football mileage.

who recently passed...he posted back in camp that he thought Peart would see the field and be ready to play a lot earlier than most people were projecting

If peart looks like the best candidate for OT, does it make any sense for Thomas or Sewell to play OG if we drafted Sewell?
Just thinking on how either would project at OG, not looking to throw Thomas at OG ala flowers because he stinks
Much rather have both rookie tackles pan out, improve going into 2021 and drafting an impact defender and a WR in first two rds
Or go all in on bud Dupree as the one big signing, trade down in first, grab 2 xtra picks and load up on wr and cb.
Seriously if we drafted 2 wr and 2 cb with our first 4 picks, wouldn’t complain

In comment 15013894 Ivan15 said:

Quote:

Lemieux working in at LG, and Hernandez competing with or replacing Zeitler at RG in 2021. Hernandez always was a better fit at RG. And he was so raw when drafted, that he could have been trained to play either side. He survived as a rookie because he had the basics of the position, despite the fact that the OL coach was borderline incompetent.

Hernandez had played zero snaps at RG in his life. What makes you think he is a better fit t there.

In comment 15014189 BlueLou'sBack said:

Quote:

one wonders. In this world of fractured hot take opinions, reading well is a key, IMHO. SO BROADBANZ posts: Quote: Jim Nagy called Peart better than Thomas back in May... His OP statement is flat out a lie, a distortion of what Nagy wrote, surprise. I will give the poster credit for providing the link, which storyline posits a slightly different POV. Here's the full quote. Nagy talks about "potential upside to play the left tackle position", which is quite different, isn't it? Quote: Nagy made sure to assure everyone he’s not saying that Peart is the better player of the two Giants draft picks, but that Peart simply offers more athletic abilities at the position. "He’s not as good of a football player right now but he’s a better athlete. That’s clear. That’s inarguable." Why bother with the misquote? To prove your point? What's even more amusing to me is Ivan15's post above noting "quite a few threads were started [on BBI] about this..." Yeah Ivan15, there were, and you started at least half of them, over and over and over. LOL.

I didnt miss quote anything you little bitch. It's all in black and white.

In comment 15013830 Jon in NYC said:

Quote:

in mind, Nagy is the senior bowl guy. So he has Peart colored glasses on, since Thomas left as a junior.

Does this matter though? Does he have a vested interest in hyping guys up from Senior Bowl after the draft. I know they love to highlight who has played in the game, but either he's going to be a player or not in the NFL and no need to hype him up for the Draft at that point.

In comment 15014973 broadbandz said:

Quote:

In comment 15014189 BlueLou'sBack said: Quote: one wonders. In this world of fractured hot take opinions, reading well is a key, IMHO. SO BROADBANZ replies: I didnt miss quote anything you little bitch. It's all in black and white.

After all that evidence I provided you illiterate half wit, all you got is invective?

Too bad cussing me out doesn't improve your illiteracy, not even a whit.

I'd call you a moron, except that would be an insult to disabled folks.

Learn to read, dolt. BEORE YOU MISQUOTE SOMEONE. Or just give up posting for awhile...

Unless you like getting called out for it.

BTW, what are you, 15? Try having respect for your elders, who can actually READ.