Is the type of guy that shows up every day and dominates practice so I can see where the coaches keep saying “we can work with him, we can fix him etc...”. I can see where the coaches want to keep him.
All that being said I think the kid needs a change of scenery. It just has not worked out for him here and we don’t have a system he works in.
Back in the day, Evan would have been called a "coach killer".
Can’t argue against the label. Him catching one ball was the difference between Garrett calling his best game as a Giant HC vs another crushing loss.
In spots u need him. Putting eagles drop on the side, he doesn’t do the small stuff as far as 3rd down conversions in tight spots, too many 50/50
Balls aren’t caught.
Seriously the play against the eagles is one you set up all game
Shit like that is a coach killer
And we have garbage behind him
Thought Kaden smith might turn out to be competent, he hasn’t shown anything this yr
Worse than Ellison
Put a real TE on the ever growing laundry list of needs. Top of 2nd rd, if kid from penn state is there, have to consider hi
BPA
realize they're not going to get much for him and despite his shortcomings is a better offensive weapon than most of the others. I would ask if they do keep him, stop with the end-around with EE
RE: Trade everything you can for whatever you can get
may be more valuable than what they have been offered. You also are screwing yourself out of a potential comp pick if you sell him for a 6th. I'd want more than that, even if its in 22'.
Because he sure doesn't have good body positioning or ability to change direction or extend himself to make a catch or have good hand-eye coordination.
Anybody saying it's to help Jones are clearly not watching the games. Majority of the turnovers on the season revolve around Plays to Engram whether he is deflecting the ball because of his stonehands, running the wrong route, or being slow and lazy to get the ball when he actually runs the right route.
I would easily argue that getting rid of Engram and replacing him with Kaden Smith is a huge addition by subtraction for Jones and for the coaching staff as a whole . This isn't me saying this because he dropped the ball and cost the giants the game this past Thursday. This is almost a weekly occurrence at this point .
Him and Thomas are easily the 2 worst players on offense but Thomas is a rookie so he gets a little slack
I wouldn't say it's likely, though that's mostly the superstitious side of me -- he just seems like one of those upside horseshoes of a player, where there's a strong likelihood something bad will happen whenever he's involved.
Still though, he could be a part of a future rebound if he himself rebounds. I don't really hold his contribution to this terrible present against him too much -- I knew the present would be terrible anyway, and at least he's young enough to potentially be part of a good future.
Coaches always think they can fix a player - and sometimes a change of scenery helps. And scheme. And coaching.
I was quick to say pull the plug after TNF, but unless you can get something of value (4th?) I'd be inclined to keep him just to help out Jones the little Engram can.
But I would certainly consider dumping his this offseason.
since his value is nil. If Judge thinks he can work with him and get him to improve, then that's worth more than a 6th round pick. He has made plays. He has had good games. He has some talent. He has been inconsistent and injury-prone. But, so far healthy this year. I'd rather see what he can do over the last 9 games than throw him away for nothing. It's not like we are dripping with talent at TE, just waiting for a chance.
Translation: No one will give us a jock strap for this guy. Draft Choice? BAHAHAHAHA!
He's a warm body that can play the position (not well), and knows the system. That's it at this point. Stop torturing yourselves that Engram can be "fixed". He's been in the league long enough...if he had any game, he would have shown it by now. I'm sure he's gone once the team gets an average TE to replace him. They don't have that now.
really do. A place where differing opinions about the team we root for collide
As a fan I like to have an opinion as well. My opinion is most often based on what the professionals decide.
If this staff wants to keep Engram, that s ok by me.
The professionals have led us to the worst record in the league over the last 3.5 seasons. WORST. Dave Gettleman has never had any solid vision in building this team outside of “betta cultcha”.
Deandre Baker was a case in point: trade UP for a guy with character concerns and specializes in MAN coverage to play for a DC who mostly uses his corners in ZONE (at a point in the draft where there were 2-3 other CBs of similar value we could’ve waited to draft at #37 or drafted a better fit at #30). It made zero sense whatsoever.
Looking back, we probably could have just drafted BPA at every spot based on Mel freaking Kiper’s big board and we’d probably be better off. That shouldn’t be the case— we wouldn’t have needed a professional GM to do that. The point of a “professional” GM is because they’re supposed to know how to build a winning NFL football TEAM... Gettleman clearly doesn’t know how to do that in TODAY’s NFL.
You get him, his disappointing play and his 1st round salary for 8 games. After that he is a UFA or you pick up his 5th year at 6M...
Make no sense. If you want to try a reclamation project on him, just wait until he hits FA in the spring. No need to give up anything now. Engram has 0 value on the trade market.
That said, the only thing that makes any sense at all is for the Giants to work with him and try to turn him around. This season is lost anyway. Engram is a good project to see if you can make some soup out of chicken shit.
Evan Engram is NOT expected to be traded. Other teams have called, but he's not being shopped. The Giants view him as an explosive offensive weapon that is part of their future, even though it hasn't clicked yet this season. #Giants #NFL
Why would anyone trade for a coach killer?
Take whatever you can for Evan Engram, he’s been here 4 season and hasn’t grown as a player. Time to move on.
Quote:
Is the type of guy that shows up every day and dominates practice so I can see where the coaches keep saying “we can work with him, we can fix him etc...”. I can see where the coaches want to keep him.
All that being said I think the kid needs a change of scenery. It just has not worked out for him here and we don’t have a system he works in.
Back in the day, Evan would have been called a "coach killer".
Can’t argue against the label. Him catching one ball was the difference between Garrett calling his best game as a Giant HC vs another crushing loss.
Balls aren’t caught.
Seriously the play against the eagles is one you set up all game
Shit like that is a coach killer
And we have garbage behind him
Thought Kaden smith might turn out to be competent, he hasn’t shown anything this yr
Worse than Ellison
Put a real TE on the ever growing laundry list of needs. Top of 2nd rd, if kid from penn state is there, have to consider hi
BPA
If/when the Giants become relevant again, it won't be with this roster. I'd make every single player available.
This. They are the worst team in football the last 3+ years. They should have allegiance to no one on the roster. Continue to draft new players.
Because he sure doesn't have good body positioning or ability to change direction or extend himself to make a catch or have good hand-eye coordination.
I would easily argue that getting rid of Engram and replacing him with Kaden Smith is a huge addition by subtraction for Jones and for the coaching staff as a whole . This isn't me saying this because he dropped the ball and cost the giants the game this past Thursday. This is almost a weekly occurrence at this point .
Him and Thomas are easily the 2 worst players on offense but Thomas is a rookie so he gets a little slack
Still though, he could be a part of a future rebound if he himself rebounds. I don't really hold his contribution to this terrible present against him too much -- I knew the present would be terrible anyway, and at least he's young enough to potentially be part of a good future.
Can't say the same about Zeitler and Tate.
They might need it,as he's fully capable of stifling Judge's routine press conference.
He could have a moment of clarity
Quote:
and he should be traded in the offseason.
Why would anyone trade for a coach killer?
Because someone's trash is another's gold.
Coaches always think they can fix a player - and sometimes a change of scenery helps. And scheme. And coaching.
I was quick to say pull the plug after TNF, but unless you can get something of value (4th?) I'd be inclined to keep him just to help out Jones the little Engram can.
But I would certainly consider dumping his this offseason.
I don't believe he's a player you will win with.
He's a warm body that can play the position (not well), and knows the system. That's it at this point. Stop torturing yourselves that Engram can be "fixed". He's been in the league long enough...if he had any game, he would have shown it by now. I'm sure he's gone once the team gets an average TE to replace him. They don't have that now.
As a fan I like to have an opinion as well. My opinion is most often based on what the professionals decide.
If this staff wants to keep Engram, that s ok by me.
The professionals have led us to the worst record in the league over the last 3.5 seasons. WORST. Dave Gettleman has never had any solid vision in building this team outside of “betta cultcha”.
Deandre Baker was a case in point: trade UP for a guy with character concerns and specializes in MAN coverage to play for a DC who mostly uses his corners in ZONE (at a point in the draft where there were 2-3 other CBs of similar value we could’ve waited to draft at #37 or drafted a better fit at #30). It made zero sense whatsoever.
Looking back, we probably could have just drafted BPA at every spot based on Mel freaking Kiper’s big board and we’d probably be better off. That shouldn’t be the case— we wouldn’t have needed a professional GM to do that. The point of a “professional” GM is because they’re supposed to know how to build a winning NFL football TEAM... Gettleman clearly doesn’t know how to do that in TODAY’s NFL.
You get him, his disappointing play and his 1st round salary for 8 games. After that he is a UFA or you pick up his 5th year at 6M...
Make no sense. If you want to try a reclamation project on him, just wait until he hits FA in the spring. No need to give up anything now. Engram has 0 value on the trade market.
That said, the only thing that makes any sense at all is for the Giants to work with him and try to turn him around. This season is lost anyway. Engram is a good project to see if you can make some soup out of chicken shit.
@JordanRaanan
Evan Engram is NOT expected to be traded. Other teams have called, but he's not being shopped. The Giants view him as an explosive offensive weapon that is part of their future, even though it hasn't clicked yet this season. #Giants #NFL